Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

From free to forced adaptation: A political ecology of the ‘state‐society‐flood’ nexus in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta

From free to forced adaptation: A political ecology of the ‘state‐society‐flood’ nexus in the... This paper investigates the adaptation processes with reference to the narrative analysis of human–environment interactions in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta. From the political ecology perspective, it focuses on the discourses of the power relationships embedded within the ‘state‐society‐flood’ nexus over the course of its ‘opening‐up and closing‐off’ processes (e.g. excavating large‐scale canals for human settlements and agricultural expansion (opening‐up) and human interventions into natural systems through water control structures (closing‐off)). Drawing on empirical data gathered from 33 interviews and nine focus group discussions in three study areas and relevant literature, the paper argues that human interactions with the flood environments are intertwined with adjustments of adaptation patterns as evidenced through three periods: free adaptation (pre‐1975), transitional adaptation (1976–2010) and forced adaptation (after 2010). These processes have witnessed a gradual power shift in the ‘state‐society’ relations in manipulating floods, which moves from the top‐down towards a more collaborative fashion. By unravelling the political ecology of the ‘state‐society‐flood’ nexus, this paper exhibits the skewed development in the delta, which is largely bound to short‐term development planning to prioritise local socio‐economic and political objectives. The paper contributes important policy implications for achieving socially just and environmentally sustainable development in the delta. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Asia Pacific Viewpoint Wiley

From free to forced adaptation: A political ecology of the ‘state‐society‐flood’ nexus in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta

Tran, Thong Anh
Asia Pacific Viewpoint , Volume 61 (1) – Apr 1, 2020
Download PDF
21 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/wiley/from-free-to-forced-adaptation-a-political-ecology-of-the-state-kL89jd03W7
Publisher
Wiley
Copyright
© 2020 Victoria University of Wellington and John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd
ISSN
1360-7456
eISSN
1467-8373
DOI
10.1111/apv.12241
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

This paper investigates the adaptation processes with reference to the narrative analysis of human–environment interactions in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta. From the political ecology perspective, it focuses on the discourses of the power relationships embedded within the ‘state‐society‐flood’ nexus over the course of its ‘opening‐up and closing‐off’ processes (e.g. excavating large‐scale canals for human settlements and agricultural expansion (opening‐up) and human interventions into natural systems through water control structures (closing‐off)). Drawing on empirical data gathered from 33 interviews and nine focus group discussions in three study areas and relevant literature, the paper argues that human interactions with the flood environments are intertwined with adjustments of adaptation patterns as evidenced through three periods: free adaptation (pre‐1975), transitional adaptation (1976–2010) and forced adaptation (after 2010). These processes have witnessed a gradual power shift in the ‘state‐society’ relations in manipulating floods, which moves from the top‐down towards a more collaborative fashion. By unravelling the political ecology of the ‘state‐society‐flood’ nexus, this paper exhibits the skewed development in the delta, which is largely bound to short‐term development planning to prioritise local socio‐economic and political objectives. The paper contributes important policy implications for achieving socially just and environmentally sustainable development in the delta.

Journal

Asia Pacific Viewpoint – Wiley

Published: Apr 1, 2020

Keywords: ; ; ; ;

References

  • Climate change, adaptive capacity and development
    Adger, W.N.
  • Successful adaptation to climate change across scales
    Adger, W.N.; Arnell, N.W.; Tompkin, E.L.
  • Cultural dimensions of climate change impacts and adaptation
    Adger, W.N.; Barnett, J.; Brown, K.; Marshall, N.; O'Brien, K.
  • Báo cáo tổng kết 5 năm (2006–2010) thực hiện chương trình khai thác lợi thế mùa nước nổi [Summary report (2006–2010) on implementing program for exploitation of benefits in the rising water season]
  • Công văn tạm ngừng mở mới và kết thúc chính sách hỗ trợ kinh phí xây dựng đê bao mở mới diện tích sản xuất vụ Thu‐Đông trên địa bàn tỉnh, số 1259/UBND‐KT ngày 01 tháng 11 năm 2013 [Official document on temporary deferral and termination of funding support to high dyke construction for expanding the autumn–winter crop cultivation areas in An Giang province, No. 1259/UBND‐KT dated November 01st, 2013]
  • Adaptive co‐management for socialecological complexity
    Armitage, D.; Plummer, R.; Berkes, F.
  • A climate of control: Flooding, displacement and planned resettlement in the Lower Zambezi River valley, Mozambique
    Arnall, A.
  • Vietnam: Integrated water management plan. North Vam Nao Water Control Project II, Independent completion report
  • Social challenges for the Mekong region
    Bach, T.S.
  • Indigenous knowledge and disaster risk reduction: From practice to policy
    Bach, T.S.; Lebel, L.; Nguyen, T.T.
  • The Vietnamese hydrocracy and the Mekong Delta – Vietnamresources development from State socialism to bureaucratic capitalism
    Benedikter, S.
  • Recognizing wetland ecosystem services for sustainable rice farming in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam
    Berg, H.; Söderholm, A.E.; Söderström, A.‐S.; Tam, N.T.
  • Quagmire: Nation‐building and nature in the Mekong Delta
    Biggs, D.
  • Environmental change and agricultural sustainability in the Mekong Delta
    Biggs, D.
  • Contested waterscapes in the Mekong Region – Hydropower, livelihoods and governance
    Biggs, D.; Miller, F.; Chu, T.H.; Molle, F.
  • Factors affecting farmers’ adoption of integrated rice‐fish farming systems in the Mekong delta, Vietnam: Rice‐fish systems in the Mekong delta
    Bosma, R.H.; Nhan, D.K.; Udo, H.M.J.; Kaymak, U.
  • The Mekong Delta: Ecology, economy, and revolution, 1860–1960
    Brocheux, P.
  • Intensification, and alternative approaches to agricultural change
    Brookfield, H.
  • The place of histories in development: Creating spaces for participation through narrative analysis
    Car, E.R.
  • Adaptation and development trade‐offs: Fluvial sediment deposition and the sustainability of rice‐cropping in An Giang Province, Mekong Delta
    Chapman, A.D.; Darby, S.E.; Hong, H.M.; Tompkins, E.L.; Van, T.P.D.
  • Irrigation development in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta: Towards polycentric water governance?
    Chu, T.H.; Suhardiman, D.; Le, A.T.
  • The nature of urban gardens: Toward a political ecology of urban agriculture
    Classens, M.
  • Water resources and food security in the Vietnam Mekong Delta
    Cosslett, T.L.; Cosslett, P.D.
  • Water governance assessment: The case of the Mekong Delta
  • Hydrological alterations from water infrastructure development in the Mekong floodplains
    Dang, T.D.; Cochrane, T.A.; Arias, M.E.; Van, P.D.T.; Vries, T.T.
  • Post‐1975 land reform in southern Vietnam: How local actions and responses affected national land policy
    Dang, D.T.
  • Proceedings of the 3rd World Water Forum
    Dang, Q.T.; Pham, T.H.
  • Learning as you journey: Anishinaabe perception of social–ecological environments and adaptive learning
    Davidson‐Hunt, I.; Berkes, F.
  • The Mekong Delta system – Interdisciplinary analyses of a River Delta
    Delgado, J.M.; Merz, B.; Apel, H.
  • Report for Viet Nam–Netherlands Research Program (VNRP)
    Duong, V.N.
  • Wetlands management in Vietnam: Issues and perspectives
    Duong, V.N.; Maltby, E.; Stafford, R.; To, P.T.; Vo, T.X.
  • Beautiful floods – Environmental knowledge and agrarian change in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam
    Ehlert, J.
  • Reframing adaptation: The political nature of climate change adaptation
    Eriksen, S.; Nightingale, A.J.; Eakin, H.
  • Hydraulic bureaucracy in a modern hydraulic society – Strategic group formation in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam
    Evers, H.D.; Benedikter, S.
  • Vulnerability after ‘the end of famine’: Political ecology, development, and deconcentrated starvation
    Fogelman, C.
  • Taking a climate chance: A procedural critique of Vietnam's climate change strategy
    Fortier, F.
  • Probing system limits: Decentralization and local political accountability in Vietnam
    Fritzen, S.A.
  • The Mekong Delta system – Interdisciplinary analyses of a River Delta
    Garschagen, M.; Diez, J.R.; Nhan, D.K.; Kraas, F.
  • Statistical yearbook
  • Integrated water resources management in south and Southeast Asia
    Hansen, J.M.; Do, H.P.
  • Political ecologies of the state: Recent interventions and questions going forward
    Harris, L.M.
  • Command and control and the pathology of natural resource management
    Holling, C.S.; Meffe, G.K.
  • Mekong Delta at the crossroads: More control or adaptation?
    Käkönen, M.
  • Learning from the history of disaster vulnerability and resilience research and practice for climate change
    Kelman, I.; Gaillard, J.C.; Lewis, J.; Mercer, J.
  • An approach for analysing state‐society relations in Vietnam
    Kerkvliet, B.J.T.
  • Climate change and water resources in the Lower Mekong River Basin: Putting adaptation into the context
    Keskinen, M.; Chinvanno, S.; Kummu, M.
  • Interviews in qualitative research
    King, N.; Horrocks, C.
  • Environmental stressors and migration: Evidence from Vietnam
    Koubi, V.; Spilker, G.; Schaffer, L.; Bernauer, T.
  • Flood mapping and flood dynamics of the Mekong Delta: ENVISAT‐ASAR‐WSM based time series analyses
    Kuenzer, C.; Guo, H.; Huth, J.; Leinenkugel, P.; Li, X.; Dech, S.
  • The political ecology of ecosystem services
    Kull, C.A.; Sartre, X.A.; Castro‐Larrañaga, M.
  • Reinventing rural development in Vietnam: Discursive construction of grassroots democracy during the renovation reform
    Larsen, R.K.
  • The combined impact on the flooding in Vietnam's Mekong River delta of local man‐made structures, sea level rise, and dams upstream in the river catchment
    Le, T.V.H.; Nguyen, H.N.; Wolanski, E.; Tran, T.C.; Haruyama, S.
  • The historical flood in 2000 in Mekong River Delta, Vietnam: A quantitative analysis and simulation
    Le, T.V.H.; Haruyama, S.; Nguyen, H.N.; Tran, T.C.; Bui, D.L.
  • Challenges to sustainable development in the Mekong Delta: Regional and national policy issues and research needs
    Le, A.T.; Chu, T.H.; Miller, F.; Bach, T.S.
  • Infrastructure effects on floods in the Mekong River Delta in Vietnam
    Le, T.V.H.; Shigeko, H.; Nguyen, H.N.; Tran, T.C.
  • Chuyện nước và con người ở Đồng Bằng Sông Cửu Long [Stories of human–water relations in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta]
    Le, A.T.; Nguyen, H.T.; Duong, V.N.; Dao, T.T.; Le, P.Q.; Nguyen, D.T.
  • Interplay between land‐use dynamics and changes in hydrological regime in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta
    Le, T.N.; Bregt, A.K.; Halsema, G.E.v.; Hellegers, P.J.G.J.; Nguyen, L.D.
  • Risk reduction or redistribution? Flood management in the Mekong region
    Lebel, L.; Bach, T.S.
  • Local knowledge and adaptation to climate change in natural resource‐based societies of the Asia‐Pacific
    Lebel, L.
  • Climate and narrative: Environmental knowledge in everyday life
    Lejano, R.P.; Tavares‐Reager, J.; Berkes, F.
  • The role of culture and traditional knowledge in climate change adaptation: Insights from East Kimberley, Australia
    Leonard, S.; Parsons, M.; Olawsky, K.; Kofod, F.
  • Qualitative research methods
    Liamputtong, P.
  • Reducing flood risks in rural households: Survey of perception and adaptation in the Mekong delta
    Ling, F.H.; Tamura, M.; Yasuhara, K.; Ajima, K.; Trinh, C.V.
  • Coupled human and natural systems
    Liu, J.; Dietz, T.; Carpenter, S.R.
  • Designing qualitative research
    Marshall, C.; Rossman, G.B.
  • Using historical political ecology to understand the present: Water, reeds, and biodiversity in the Camargue biosphere reserve, Southern France
    Mathevet, R.; Peluso, N.L.; Couespel, A.; Robbins, P.
  • State in society – Studying how states and societies transform and constitute one another
    Migdal, J.S.
  • Environment, development and change in rural Asia – Pacific between local and global
    Miller, F.
  • Participatory rural appraisal: Principles, methods and application
    Narayanasamy, N.
  • Master plan for the Mekong Delta in Vietnam – A perspective for sustainable development of land and water resources
  • Social research methods – Qualitative and quantitative approaches
    Neuman, L.
  • Challenges to sustainable development in the Mekong Delta: Regional and national policy issues and research needs
    Nguyen, D.C.; Le, T.D.; Nguyen, V.S.; Miller, F.
  • Former and present cropping patterns in the Mekong delta
    Nguyen, H.C.
  • Floodplain hydrology of the Mekong Delta, Vietnam
    Nguyen, N.H.; Delgado, J.M.; Vo, K.T.
  • Governing the Mekong – Engaging in the politics of knowledge
    Nguyen, H.T.; Le, A.T.; Tran, T.T.; Bastakoti, R.C.; Lebel, L.
  • Administrative co‐management: The case of special‐use forest conservation in Vietnam
    Nguyen, K.D.; Bush, S.R.; Mol, A.J.
  • Perceiving to learn or learning to perceive? Understanding farmers’ perceptions and adaptation to climate uncertainties
    Nguyen, T.P.L.; Seddaiu, G.; Virdis, S.G.P.; Tidore, C.; Pasqui, M.; Roggero, P.P.
  • Development of farming systems in the Mekong Delta of Vietnam
    Nguyen, V.S.; Vo, T.X.; Tran, A.P.
  • Water governance in the face of global change – From understanding to transformation
    Pahl‐Wostl, C.
  • Informing adaptation responses to climate change through theories of transformation
    Park, S.E.; Marshall, N.A.; Jakku, E.
  • Báo cáo kết quả thực hiện nhiệm vụ năm 2013 và chương trình công tác năm 2014, số 28/BC‐DU ngày 04 tháng 12 năm 2013 [Summary report on mission implementation of 2013 and working agenda for 2014, No. 28/BC‐DU dated December 04th, 2013]
  • Narrative research in climate change adaptation – Exploring a complementary paradigm for research and governance
    Paschen, J.‐A.; Ison, R.
  • Adaptation to climate change: From resilience to transformation
    Pelling, M.
  • Social learning and adaptation to climate change
    Pelling, M.; High, C.
  • Nam Bộ 300 năm làm thủy lợi [The Southern region in the 300‐year history of hydraulic development]
    Phan, K.
  • Báo cáo tình hình thực hiện nhiệm vụ phát triển kinh tế xã hội năm 2013 – Phương hướng nhiệm vụ năm 2014, số 120/BC‐UBND [Report on implementation of socio‐economic development mission in 2013 – Orientation and mission towards 2014, No. 120/BC‐UNBD]
  • Experience and practices on flood control in Vietnam
    Pilarczyk, K.W.; Nguyen, S.N.
  • Introduction to social research – Quantitative and qualitative approaches
    Punch, K.F.
  • A comparison of peasant social systems of Northern and Southern Vietnam: A study of ecological adaptation, social succession, and cultural evolution
    Rambo, A.T.
  • Political ecology: A critical introduction
    Robbins, P.
  • Development narratives, or making the best of blueprint development
    Roe, E.M.
  • Action research for climate change adaptation – Developing and applying knowledge for governance
    Roggema, R.; Martin, J.; Vos, L.
  • Seeing like a state: How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed
    Scott, J.C.
  • Political ecology: Science, myth and power
    Scott, P.; Sullivan, S.
  • Voluntary and forced adaptation
    Shabanova, M.A.
  • Handbook of research methods in social and personality psychology
    Smith, C.P.
  • Đồng bằng sông Cửu Long – Nét sinh hoạt xưa và văn minh miệt vườn [The Vietnamese Mekong Delta – Features of the past and civilization of the garden regions]
  • Mekong Delta Plan: Long‐term vision and strategy for a safe, prosperous and sustainable delta
  • Are cultures endangered by climate change? Yes, but …
    Strauss, S.
  • Transformation of rice‐based cropping patterns in the Mekong Delta: From intensification to diversification
    Tanaka, K.
  • Fragments of the present – Searching for modernity in Vietnam's South
    Taylor, P.
  • Establishing river basin organizations in Vietnam: Red River, Dong Nai River and Lower Mekong Delta
    Taylor, P.; Wright, G.
  • Văn hóa dân gian người Việt ở Nam Bộ [Folk culture of the Viet people in Southern Vietnam]
    Phuong, T.; Le, H.; Lua, H.; Nguyen, Q.V.
  • Urbanization and rural development in Vietnam's Mekong Delta: Revisiting livelihood transformations in three fruit‐growing settlements, 2006–2015
    Thanh, H.X.; Phuong, D.T.T.; Hoa, D.T.T.; Lap, L.D.; Consultants, A.
  • Observed adaptation to climate change: UK evidence of transition to a well‐adapting society
    Tompkins, E.L.; Adger, W.N.; Boyd, E.; Nicholson‐Cole, S.; Weatherhead, K.; Arnell, N.
  • Rice intensive cropping and balanced cropping in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam – Economic and ecological considerations
    Tong, Y.D.
  • Collection of engineering and technology achievements during the fifty‐year construction and development 1959–2009
    Tran, N.H.
  • The wetland book – Distribution, description and conservation
    Tran, T.
  • Transformation of household livelihoods in adapting to the impacts of flood control schemes in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta
    Tran, T.A.; James, H.
  • Social learning through rural communities of practice: Empirical evidence from farming households in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta
    Tran, T.A.; James, H.; Pittock, J.
  • Land use change driven out‐migration: Evidence from three flood‐prone communities in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta
    Tran, T.A.
  • Anticipatory learning for climate change adaptation and resilience
    Tschakert, P.; Dietrich, K.A.
  • Fighting climate change: Human solidarity in a divided world – Human development report 2007/2008
  • The tenth dragon: Controlled seasonal flooding in long‐term policy plans for the Vietnamese Mekong delta
    Staveren, M.F.; Tatenhove, J.P.M.; Warner, J.F.
  • The Mekong Delta system – Interdisciplinary analyses of a River Delta
    Vo, K.T.
  • Rice cultivation in the Mekong Delta – Present situation and potentials for increased production
    Vo, T.X.
  • Development of farming systems in the Mekong Delta of Vietnam
    Vo, T.X.; Matsui, S.
  • The Mekong Delta system – Interdisciplinary analyses of a river delta
    Waibel, G.; Benedikter, S.; Reis, N.
  • Large‐scale management experiments and learning by doing
    Walters, C.J.; Holling, C.S.
  • A companion to economic geography
    Watts, M.J.
  • Socio‐hydrology and hydro‐social analysis: Toward dialogues across disciplines
    Wesselink, A.; Kooy, M.; Warner, J.
  • Narrative analysis as a strategy for understanding interview talk in geographic research
    Wiles, J.L.; Rosenberg, M.W.; Kearns, R.A.
  • Adaptive management of natural resources – Framework and issues
    Williams, B.K.
  • Canal development and intensification of rice cultivation in the Mekong Delta: A case study in Can Tho Province, Vietnam
    Yasuyuki, K.
  • A portfolio approach to analyzing complex human‐environment interactions: Institutions and land change
    Young, O.; Lambin, E.; Alcock, F.