Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
Loading next page...
/lp/sage/the-structure-of-complexity-and-the-limits-of-collective-GOp0FJPXs9
References (115)
-
S. Turner (1999)
Searle's Social RealityHistory and Theory, 38
-
I. Craib, M. Archer (1997)
Realist Social Theory: The Morphogenetic ApproachCanadian Journal of Sociology-cahiers Canadiens De Sociologie, 22
-
D. Little (2020)
Organizations as Actors: Microfoundations of Organizational IntentionalityPhilosophy of the Social Sciences, 50
-
Margery Doyle, Leslie Marsh (2013)
Stigmergy 3.0: From ants to economiesCognitive Systems Research, 21
-
Nathalie Bulle (2020)
Trois versions de l’individualisme méthodologique à l’aune de l’épistémologieL'Année Sociologique, 70
-
J. Searle (2001)
Rationality in Action -
Gerard Delanty (2009)
The Foundations of Social Theory -
J. Shearmur (2008)
The Construction of Social Reality: Searle, de Soto, and Disney -
Peter Boettke (2012)
Living Economics : YEstErdaY , todaY , and tomorrow -
F. Hayek (1978)
New studies in philosophy, politics, economics, and the history of ideas -
S. Turner (2015)
Functionalism, Field Theories, and Unintended Consequences -
A. Dawe (1969)
Studies in Philosophy, Politics and EconomicsSociology, 3
-
C. Menger, L. Schneider (1985)
Investigations into the method of the social sciences, with special reference to economics : formerly published under title, Problems of economics and sociology -
F. Hayek (1953)
The counter-revolution of science : studies on the abuse of reasonThe Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science, 19
-
F. Hayek (1953)
Elementist Going Up. (Book Reviews: The Sensory Order: An Inquiry into the Foundations of Theoretical Psychology) -
D. Leat (2005)
Theories of Social Change -
Peter Boettke (2018)
F. A. Hayek: Economics, Political Economy and Social Philosophy -
L. Kaelber (2009)
:Good Intentions: Max Weber and the Paradox of Unintended ConsequencesAmerican Journal of Sociology
-
M. Weber (2019)
Economy and SocietyJournal of Economic Sociology, 18
-
A. Petroni (1991)
L'INDIVIDUALISME METHODOLOGIQUEJournal des Économistes et des Études Humaines, 2
-
(2012)
SEARLEWORLD1 -
A. Kirman (2010)
Complex Economics: Individual and Collective Rationality -
Å. Andersson (2007)
Power and Social Ontology -
J. Searle (2016)
The Limits of Emergence: Reply to Tony LawsonJournal for The Theory of Social Behaviour, 46
-
(2001)
The Origins of Value -
Francesco Iorio (2020)
Individualisme méthodologique et réductionnismeL'Année Sociologique, 70
-
R. Boudon, François Bourricaud (1991)
A critical dictionary of sociology -
Emma Tieffenbach (2010)
Searle and Menger on MoneyPhilosophy of the Social Sciences, 40
-
R. Boudon (1984)
The Unintended Consequences of Social Action -
P. Hedström, P. Bearman (2009)
What is Analytical Sociology All About? An Introductory Essay -
(1998)
Social mechanisms without black boxes. -
S. Lukes (1968)
Methodological Individualism ReconsideredBritish Journal of Sociology, 19
-
F. Linares (2018)
Los modelos basados en agentes y la ciencia de las consecuencias inintencionadas de la acción / Agent Based Models and the Science of Unintended Consequences of Social ActionRevista Espanola De Investigaciones Sociologicas
-
K. Ludwig, M. Jankovic (2017)
The Routledge Handbook of Collective Intentionality -
Barry Smith, L. Zaibert (2001)
The Metaphysics of Real EstateTopoi, 20
-
E. Whitley (1999)
The Construction of Social RealityInformation Technology & People, 12
-
J. Searle (1997)
Responses to Critics of The Construction of Social RealityPhilosophy and Phenomenological Research, 57
-
(1973)
Law, Legislation and Liberty, Vol -
F. Hayek (1949)
Individualism and Economic Order -
F. Iorio (2015)
Cognitive Autonomy and Methodological Individualism - The Interpretative Foundations of Social Life, 22
-
Gianluca Manzo (2014)
mechanisms:More on the principles of analytical sociology -
Gianluca Manzo (2007)
Comment on Andrew Abbott/2Sociologia
-
J. Birner (2015)
Complexity and social scienceson The Horizon, 23
-
A. Meijers (2003)
Can Collective Intentionality Be IndividualizedThe American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 62
-
Amie Thomasson (2003)
Foundations for a Social Ontology, 18
-
(2006)
New Introduction by the Author. -
G. Poggi (1969)
Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive SociologySociology, 3
-
N. Miščević (2003)
Explaining Collective IntentionalityThe American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 62
-
(1997)
Introduction: Process and Emergence in the Economy -
Peter Boettke, Kyle O'Donnell (2013)
The Failed Appropriation of F. A. Hayek by Formalist EconomicsCritical Review, 25
-
Mathias Beike (2016)
The Economic Approach To Human Behavior -
(2014)
Rationality and Cultural Interpretivism: A Critical Assessment -
(2017)
Agir Ensemble: Fondements de la Coopération -
N. Bulle (2019)
Methodological individualism as anti-reductionismJournal of Classical Sociology, 19
-
Barry Smith, D. Reisman (1997)
The Connectionist Mind: A Study of Hayekian Psychology -
(2011)
Introduction” to Analytical Sociology and Social Mechanisms -
(2020)
Individualism Versus HolismSAGE Research Methods Foundations
-
R. Bierstedt, F. Hayek (1941)
The Counter-Revolution of Science -
P. Demeulenaere (2020)
L’individualisme méthodologique et les représentations collectivesL'Année Sociologique, 70
-
(1988)
La société de droit selon Hayek -
L. Mises
Socialism: An Economic and Sociological Analysis -
Gianluca Manzo (2020)
Agent-based models and methodological individualism: are they fundamentally linked?L'Année Sociologique, 70
-
T. Lawson (1997)
Economics and Reality -
F. Iorio (2016)
World 3 and Methodological Individualism in Popper's ThoughtPhilosophy of the Social Sciences, 46
-
R. Boudon (1971)
The uses of structuralism -
P. Demeulenaere (2000)
Individualism and holism: New controversies in the philosophy of social scienceMind & Society, 1
-
U. Mäki (2002)
Explanatory ecumenism and economics imperialismEconomics and Philosophy, 18
-
A. Wellmer (1970)
Some Remarks on the Logic of Explanation in the Social SciencesRoyal Institute of Philosophy Lectures, 4
-
U. Mäki (1990)
Practical syllogism, entrepreneurship, and the invisible hand: A critique of the analytic hermeneutics of G.H. von Wright -
Barry Smith (2003)
John Searle: From speech acts to social reality -
(2021)
From the Division of Labour to the Division of Knowledge: Smith, Hayek and the Role of Reason in Social Coordination. -
Francesco Iorio, Shu-Heng Chen (2019)
On the connection between agent-based simulation and methodological individualismSocial Science Information, 58
-
Jennifer Hornsby (1997)
Collectives and intentionalityPhilosophy and Phenomenological Research, 57
-
(2009)
Some Comments on Lawson’s Reorienting Economics: Same Facts, Different conclusions. -
T. Lawson (2012)
Ontology and the study of social reality: emergence, organisation, community, power, social relations, corporations, artefacts and moneyCambridge Journal of Economics, 36
-
Bruce Caldwell (2003)
Hayek's challenge : an intellectual biography of F.A. Hayek -
Daniel Fitzpatrick (2003)
Searle and Collective IntentionalityThe American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 62
-
H. Gintis (2018)
Rational Choice Explained and Defended -
P. Pettit (1981)
The Possibility of Naturalism.Philosophical Books, 22
-
N. Bulle, Denis Phan (2017)
Can Analytical Sociology Do without Methodological Individualism?Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 47
-
(2007)
Popper’s Vienna -
Emma Tieffenbach (2013)
Invisible-hand explanations: From blindness to lack of we-nessSocial Science Information, 52
-
Christofer Edling (2014)
Book review: Sociology as Science – An Intellectual AutobiographyJournal of Classical Sociology, 14
-
Gerald O'driscoll, M. Rizzo, Roger Garrison (1987)
The economics of time and ignorance -
A. Bouvier (2020)
L’Individualisme méthodologique au défi des critiques de la philosophie analytique récenteL'Année Sociologique, 70
-
H. Rakoczy, M. Tomasello (2007)
The Ontogeny of Social Ontology: Steps to Shared Intentionality and Status Functions -
G. Zanotti, N. Cachanosky (2015)
IMPLICATIONS OF MACHLUP’S INTERPRETATION OF MISES’S EPISTEMOLOGYJournal of the History of Economic Thought, 37
-
Margery Doyle, M. Kalish (2004)
Stigmergy: Indirect Communication in Multiple Mobile Autonomous Agents -
Lars Udehn (2001)
Methodological Individualism: Background, History and Meaning -
金银星, 姜楠 (2009)
浅谈“Individualism”的翻译 -
L. Mises (1949)
Human Action: A Treatise on Economics -
(1955)
Societal Facts -
K. Hoover (2006)
Microfoundations and the Ontology of MacroeconomicsHistory of Economics eJournal
-
Robert Wilson (2007)
SOCIAL REALITY AND INSTITUTIONAL FACTS: SOCIALITY WITHIN AND WITHOUT INTENTIONALITY -
Leslie Marsh, C. Onof (2008)
Stigmergic epistemology, stigmergic cognitionCognitive Systems Research, 9
-
R. Cubeddu (1993)
The Philosophy of the Austrian School -
A. King (2004)
The Structure of Social Theory -
M. Rizzo (2000)
Chapter 9 Real time and relative indeterminacy in economic theory, 2
-
K. Popper (1959)
The Poverty of Historicism -
P. Dumouchel, J. Dupuy (1983)
L'auto-organisation : de la physique au politique -
F. Hindriks, F. Guala (2015)
Understanding institutions: replies to Aoki, Binmore, Hodgson, Searle, Smith, and SugdenJournal of Institutional Economics, 11
-
Deborah Tollefsen (2017)
Collective Intentionality and Methodology in the Social Sciences -
J. Searle (2010)
Making the Social World: The Structure of Human Civilization -
Barry Smith, D. Mark, I. Ehrlich (2008)
The mystery of capital and the construction of social reality -
Glenn-Marie Lange, James Cust, Diego Herrera, Esther Naikal (1999)
The wealth of nations -
H. Kincaid (1986)
Reduction, Explanation, and IndividualismPhilosophy of Science, 53
-
T. Lawson (2016)
Some Critical Issues in Social Ontology: Reply to John SearleJournal for The Theory of Social Behaviour, 46
-
J. Friedman (2006)
Comment on Searle's ‘Social ontology’Anthropological Theory, 6
-
J. Ravetz (1972)
Sociology of ScienceNature, 238
-
M. Sproule-jones (1984)
Methodological IndividualismAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 28
-
W. Raub, T. Voss, Ben Jann, W. Przepiorka (2017)
Micro-Macro Models in Sociology: Antecedents of Coleman’s Diagram -
Robert Bernasconi, Robert Bernasconi, T. Gendler, Matthew McGrath, Sean Kelly, Krista Lawlor, Steven Gross, Rachel Barney, Kevin Klement, Daniel Nolan, Lisa Shabel, Wolfgang Huemer (1953)
Studies in Philosophy, 27
-
Alban Bouvier (2011)
INDIVIDUALISM, COLLECTIVE AGENCY AND THE "MICRO-MACRO RELATION" -
A. Kirman (2004)
The Structure of Economic Interaction: Individual and Collective Rationality -
Philip Cohen, J. Morgan, M. Pollack (2003)
Collective Intentions and Actions
- Publisher
- SAGE
- Copyright
- © The Author(s) 2022
- ISSN
- 0048-3931
- eISSN
- 1552-7441
- DOI
- 10.1177/00483931221074294
- Publisher site
- See Article on Publisher Site
Abstract
According to Searle’s theory of collective intentionality, the fundamental structure of any society can be accounted for in terms of cooperative mechanisms that create deontic relations. This paper criticizes Searle’s standpoint on the ground that, while his social ontology can make sense of simple systems of interaction like symphony orchestras and football teams, the whole coordinative structure of the modern market society cannot be explained solely in terms of we-intentional collaboration and deontic relations. As clarified by Hayek, because of its complexity, this society is a self-organizing system. It results not only from micro-level agreed constraints, but also from an unintended cybernetic mechanism that affects and shapes both its micro and macro dynamics via a circular causality. Searle ignores the coordination problem posed by complexity and provides strawman arguments against the theory of action underpinning the invisible hand explanation of social phenomena.
Journal
Philosophy of the Social Sciences – SAGE
Published: Jul 1, 2022