Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
“Sweepstakes”
L. Abrams, Joseph Pedulla, G. Madaus (2003)
Views from the Classroom: Teachers' Opinions of Statewide Testing ProgramsTheory Into Practice, 42
David Pope, G. Barnes (2015)
Influence of Education, Performance Level, and Presentation Medium on Evaluations of String Orchestra PerformancesBulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education
(2007)
Doing Interviews
M. Clarke, Arnold Shore, Katherine Rhoades, L. Abrams, Jingmin Miao, Jie Li (2003)
Perceived Effects of State-Mandated Testing Programs on Teaching and Learning: Findings from Interviews with Educators in Low-, Medium-, and High-Stakes States.
Ryan Shaw (2016)
Music teacher stress in the era of accountabilityArts Education Policy Review, 117
Chad West (2012)
Teaching Music in an Era of High-Stakes Testing and Budget ReductionsArts Education Policy Review, 113
Eugenia Costa-Giomi, Elizabeth Chappell (2007)
Characteristics of band programs in a large urban school district: Diversity or inequality?Journal of Band Research, 42
D. Eicher (2016)
of the United States
Tina Beveridge (2009)
No Child Left Behind and Fine Arts ClassesArts Education Policy Review, 111
Lisa Martin (2014)
An Exploratory Study of Music Teacher Evaluation Practices in Multiple States with Race to the Top Funding: K-12 Music Educators’ Experiences, Perspectives, and Recommendations
(2020)
2018-19 Texas academic performance reports
J. Hoffman, Lori Assaf, S. Paris (2001)
High-Stakes Testing in Reading: Today in Texas, Tomorrow?.The Reading Teacher, 54
(2021)
Correlations between socioeconomic status and scores at a marching band contest
(2008)
Accountability Texas-style: The process
(2010)
Effect of socioeconomic status on musical achievement as reflected in Texas U.I.L. choral contest ratings
O'leary (2019)
A Phenomenological Study of Competition in High School BandsBulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education
Y. Lincoln, E. Guba, J. Pilotta (1985)
Naturalistic inquiry: Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications, 1985, 416 pp., $25.00 (Cloth)International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 9
Erin Rooney (2015)
“I’m just going through the motions”: High-Stakes Accountability and Teachers’ Access to Intrinsic RewardsAmerican Journal of Education, 121
Sandra Howard (2012)
The Effect of Selected Nonmusical Factors on Adjudicators’ Ratings of High School Solo Vocal PerformancesJournal of Research in Music Education, 60
W. Au (2010)
The Idiocy of Policy: The Anti-Democratic Curriculum of High-Stakes TestingCritical Education, 1
(2020)
Texas Education Agency
Geoffrey Lowe (2018)
Competition Versus Cooperation: Implications for Music Teachers following Students Feedback from Participation in a Large-scale Cooperative Music FestivalAustralian Journal of Teacher Education, 43
(2001)
Introduction: Policy as/in practice—A sociocultural approach to the study of educational policy
(2018)
It’s more than playing music”: Perceptions of a concert band program from members of a predominantly Latino school community [Doctoral dissertation, Ohio State University
D. Springer, Kelly Bradley (2018)
Investigating adjudicator bias in concert band evaluations: An application of the Many-Facets Rasch ModelMusicae Scientiae, 22
defines policy for the operation of sport-ing, academic, and music competitions among schools in Texas
David Pope (2013)
Influence of Primary Performance Area, Education Level, and Performance Quality on Pre-Service Music Teachers’ Ratings of String Orchestra PerformancesString Research Journal, 4
Walt Haney (2000)
The Myth of the Texas Miracle in EducationEducation Policy Analysis Archives, 8
(2019)
When does race matter in music education? An exploration of race, racial hegemony, and predominantly Latinx secondary music programs through the theory of racial formation
Mitchell Robinson (2008)
From competition to collaboration: lessons from the Second ChairResearch Studies in Music Education, 30
Jared Rawlings (2018)
Benefits and Challenges of Large-Ensemble Instrumental Music Adjudicated Events: Insights From Experienced Music TeachersUpdate: Applications of Research in Music Education, 37
Thomas Regelski, D. Coan (2004)
Action, Criticism and Theory for Music Education
J. Robinson (2021)
So many expectations: A study of Australian early-career secondary school music teachersResearch Studies in Music Education, 44
Guy Forbes (1994)
Evaluative Music Festivals and Contests—Are They Fair?Update: Applications of Research in Music Education, 12
Phillip Hash (2013)
Large-Group Contest Ratings and Music Teacher Evaluation: Issues and RecommendationsArts Education Policy Review, 114
C. Easthope, Gary Easthope (2000)
Intensification, Extension and Complexity of Teachers' WorkloadBritish Journal of Sociology of Education, 21
Timothy Ford, Mary Sickle, L. Clark, Michelle Fazio-Brunson, Dorothy Schween (2017)
Teacher Self-Efficacy, Professional Commitment, and High-Stakes Teacher Evaluation Policy in LouisianaEducational Policy, 31
J. Heilig, Linda Darling-Hammond (2008)
Accountability Texas-Style: The Progress and Learning of Urban Minority Students in a High-Stakes Testing ContextEducational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 30
(2016)
Characteristics of communities with Bands of America Grand National Finalists
R. Baker (2012)
The Effects of High-Stakes Testing Policy on Arts EducationArts Education Policy Review, 113
S. Merriam (2009)
Qualitative Research: A Guide to Design and Implementation
Karen Shakman, Leslie Goodyear, J. DeLisi, Neil Schiavo, Sophia Mansori, S. Rodriguez, T. McMahon, Josephine Louie, Sara Greller, G. Fitzhugh, C. Irwin (2017)
Book Review: Qualitative Research & Evaluation Methods: Integrating Theory and Practice (4th ed.)American Journal of Evaluation, 38
(2020)
“ Everybody is good enough ” : Band teacher agency in a highly competitive environment [ Doctoral dissertation , University of North Texas ]
Richard Valencia (2000)
Inequalities and the Schooling of Minority Students in Texas: Historical and Contemporary ConditionsHispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences, 22
(2015)
Investigating selective practices in high school choral ensembles : An intrinsic case study
J. Saldaña (2009)
The Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers
WU KarenT, E. Kylie (1969)
ResultsActa Radiologica, 9
Due to the large size of music programs in some parts of the state, it is common for a single school to have multiple full-time teachers on staff for a single musical ensemble program
Alejandro González, M. Peters, A. Orange, B. Grigsby (2017)
The influence of high-stakes testing on teacher self-efficacy and job-related stressCambridge Journal of Education, 47
Philip Hash (2013)
An Analysis of Middle/high School Band and Orchestra Festival RatingsJournal of Band Research, 49
(2018)
Purpose: Title I, Part A
Katrijn Ballet, Geert Kelchtermans (2008)
Workload and willingness to change: disentangling the experience of intensificationJournal of Curriculum Studies, 40
M. Lecompte, J. Schensul (2010)
Designing & conducting ethnographic research : an introduction
Katrijn Ballet, Geert Kelchtermans, J. Loughran (2006)
Beyond intensification towards a schotarship of practice: analysing changes in teachers' work livesTeachers and Teaching, 12
Phillip Hash (2012)
An Analysis of the Ratings and Interrater Reliability of High School Band ContestsJournal of Research in Music Education, 60
(2018)
changed the name from contest to evaluation to more explicitly reflect the curricular nature of the event
The culture of competition in music education is pervasive, reflecting the overall growth in standardization and accountability measures in education. With this study, I addressed the intersection of two underexamined topics in music education: teachers’ experience with competitive ensemble events and the structural challenges of working in a low-income, student of color (SOC) majority campus. In this basic qualitative study, I examined how instrumental music teachers navigate the high-stakes policy of an adjudicated large-ensemble contest within and beyond their classrooms. Research questions include the following: (a) What do teachers perceive to be the unique challenges they face in preparing for and participating in ensemble adjudication as a result of their context in a low-income, SOC-majority campus? (b) How does preparation and participation ensemble adjudication influence teaching and learning in instrumental music classrooms? (c) What do teachers perceive to be the function and justification for compulsory ensemble adjudication? Findings suggest that teachers working in these contexts experience unique challenges in preparing for and succeeding in adjudication events due to the intersection of campus-based challenges and policy. In addition, music teachers experience similar narrowing of content and heightened stress as their general education counterparts within accountability structures.
Research Studies in Music Education – SAGE
Published: Jul 1, 2023
Keywords: marginalized students; policy; qualitative; social justice; sociology
Read and print from thousands of top scholarly journals.
Already have an account? Log in
Bookmark this article. You can see your Bookmarks on your DeepDyve Library.
To save an article, log in first, or sign up for a DeepDyve account if you don’t already have one.
Copy and paste the desired citation format or use the link below to download a file formatted for EndNote
Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
All DeepDyve websites use cookies to improve your online experience. They were placed on your computer when you launched this website. You can change your cookie settings through your browser.