Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
Alissa Droog (2021)
ProQuest Dissertations & Theses GlobalThe Charleston Advisor
B. Frey (2018)
The Sage encyclopedia of educational research, measurement, and evaluation
M. Cargo, Gill Potaka-Osborne, L. Cvitanovic, Lisa Warner, S. Clarke, J. Judd, Amal Chakraborty, A. Boulton (2019)
Strategies to support culturally safe health and wellbeing evaluations in Indigenous settings in Australia and New Zealand: a concept mapping studyInternational Journal for Equity in Health, 18
(2018)
Potentials of the model of collaborative evaluation in developing the quality of the kindergarten practice in Serbia
Erica Odera (2021)
Capturing the Added Value of Participatory EvaluationAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 42
F. Cram, Kataraina Pipi, Kirimatao Paipa (2018)
Kaupapa Māori Evaluation in Aotearoa New ZealandNew Directions for Evaluation, 2018
Alexandra Drawson, E. Toombs, C. Mushquash (2017)
Indigenous Research Methods: A Systematic ReviewInternational Indigenous Policy Journal, 8
Katrina Bledsoe (2014)
Truth, Beauty, and Justice: Conceptualizing House's Framework for Evaluation in Community‐Based SettingsNew Directions for Evaluation, 2014
A. Kirova, Kelly Hennig (2013)
Culturally Responsive Assessment Practices: Examples from an Intercultural Multilingual Early Learning Program for Newcomer ChildrenPower and Education, 5
S. Muir, A. Dean (2017)
Evaluating the outcomes of programs for Indigenous families and communitiesFamily matters
Yvonne Anders, H. Rossbach, W. Tietze (2016)
Methodological challenges of evaluating the effects of an early language education programme in GermanyInternational Journal of Child Care and Education Policy, 10
Laura Peck, Lindsey Gorzalski (2009)
An Evaluation Use Framework and Empirical AssessmentJournal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation
Stacey Stockdill, M. Baizerman, D. Compton (2002)
Toward a definition of the ECB process: A conversation with the ECB literatureNew Directions for Evaluation, 2002
Lynn Westbrook (1998)
Utilization-focused evaluationLibrary & Information Science Research, 20
(2020)
Connecting the brain to the rest of the body: Early childhood development and lifelong health are deeply intertwined
(2021)
First Nations cultural safety framework
Hind Hudib, J. Cousins (2021)
Understanding Evaluation Policy and Organizational Capacity for Evaluation: An Interview StudyAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 43
Kylie Kingston (2016)
Development of a Child Evaluation Framework for Early Childhood Services Using Deliberative Democratic Evaluation and the Mosaic ApproachEvaluation Journal of Australasia, 16
D. Levac, H. Colquhoun, K. O’Brien (2010)
Scoping studies: advancing the methodologyImplementation Science : IS, 5
V. Thomas, Beverly Parsons (2017)
Culturally Responsive Evaluation Meets Systems-Oriented EvaluationAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 38
L. Peter (2003)
Assessing the Impact of Total Immersion on Cherokee Language Revitalization: A Culturally Responsive, Participatory Approach.
M. Tremblay, Debbie Martin, A. McComber, Amelia McGregor, A. Macaulay (2018)
Understanding community-based participatory research through a social movement framework: a case study of the Kahnawake Schools Diabetes Prevention ProjectBMC Public Health, 18
K. Askew, M. Beverly, M. Jay (2012)
Aligning collaborative and culturally responsive evaluation approaches.Evaluation and program planning, 35 4
S. Nielsen, S. Lemire, Christina Christie (2018)
The Evaluation Marketplace and Its IndustryNew Directions for Evaluation, 2018
Rhian Stack, N. Leal, Sarah Stamp, Bianca Reveruzzi, Katrina Middlin, A. Lennon (2018)
Complex evaluations in the political context: Engaging stakeholders in evaluation designEvaluation Journal of Australasia, 18
S. Newell, Anne Graham (2012)
Using an Empowerment Evaluation Approach with Community-based Programs: Reflections from the Front LineEvaluation Journal of Australasia, 12
Brooke McKie, Jo-Anne Butty, R. Green (2012)
Reading, Reasoning, and Literacy: Strategies for Early Childhood Education From the Analysis of Classroom ObservationsEarly Childhood Education Journal, 40
K. Chandna, Michelle Vine, S. Snelling, Rachel Harris, J. Smylie, H. Manson (2019)
Principles, Approaches, and Methods for Evaluation in Indigenous Contexts: A Grey Literature Scoping ReviewCanadian Journal of Program Evaluation
James Cook (2015)
Using Evaluation to Effect Social ChangeAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 36
(2021)
Transforming philanthropy: Embedding Indigenous principles in learning and evaluation
P. Brandon, Landry Fukunaga (2014)
The State of the Empirical Research Literature on Stakeholder Involvement in Program EvaluationAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 35
Sophie Purdue, H. Peterson, C. Deng (2018)
The case for greater youth participation in monitoring and evaluation in international developmentEvaluation Journal of Australasia, 18
Tina Cook (2006)
Collaborative Action Research within Developmental EvaluationEvaluation, 12
Rich Janzen, J. Ochocka, Leanne Turner, Tabitha Cook, M. Franklin, Debbie Deichert (2017)
Building a community-based culture of evaluation.Evaluation and program planning, 65
R. Gokiert, B. Kingsley, C. Poth, Karen Edwards, Btissam Hassar, Lisa Tink, M. Tremblay, Ken Cor, J. Springett, S. Hopkins (2018)
Developing an Evaluation Capacity Building Network in the Field of Early Childhood DevelopmentEngaged Scholar Journal: Community-Engaged Research, Teaching, and Learning
S. Sengupta, R. Hopson, Melva Thompson-Robinson (2004)
Cultural competence in evaluation: An overviewNew Directions for Evaluation, 2004
Darshini Jayawardena (2016)
Usefulness of a community-based voluntary preschool program's impact: Utilization-focused evaluative case study
R. Gokiert, N. Willows, R. Georgis, H. Stringer (2017)
Wâhkôhtowin: The Governance of Good Community–Academic Research Relationships to Improve the Health and Well-Being of Children in Alexander First NationInternational Indigenous Policy Journal, 8
(2001)
Enhancing quality in early childhood family education : Participatory evaluation as a means to organizational learning and change ( Publication No . 3028638 ) [ Doctoral dissertation
R. Bishop (2020)
Indigenous research methods
L. Greenaway (2013)
‘Evaluation that Empowers’: A Model for Generating Evaluation-Minded OrganisationsEvaluation Journal of Australasia, 13
(2018)
An evaluation framework to improve Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health. The Lowitja Institute
Kim Grey, J. Putt, N. Baxter, S. Sutton (2016)
Bridging the Gap Both-Ways: Enhancing Evaluation Quality and Utilisation in a Study of Remote Community Safety and Wellbeing with Indigenous AustraliansEvaluation Journal of Australasia, 16
Shannon Guss, D. Norris, Diane Horm, Lisa Monroe, Vicki Wolfe (2013)
Lessons Learned About Data Utilization From Classroom ObservationsEarly Education and Development, 24
I. Bourgeois, L. Simmons, N. Hotte, R. Osseni (2016)
Measuring Evaluation Capacity in Ontario Public Health UnitsThe Canadian Journal of Program Evaluation, 31
Gretchen Clarke, Elizabeth Douglas, M. House, K. Hudgins, S. Campos, Elizabeth Vaughn (2021)
Empowering Indigenous Communities Through a Participatory, Culturally Responsive Evaluation of a Federal Program for Older AmericansThe American Journal of Evaluation, 43
Elena Moretti (2021)
Exploring what motivates evaluation capacity building in early learning services: “What are the children getting out of this?”Evaluation Matters—He Take Tō Te Aromatawai
Kristin Hobson, Jason Burkhardt (2012)
A Lesson in Carefully Managing Resources: A Case Study from an Evaluation of a Music Education ProgramJournal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation
C. Biott, Tina Cook (2000)
Local Evaluation in a National Early Years Excellence Centres Pilot ProgrammeEvaluation, 6
S. Worton, G. Nelson, C. Loomis, S. Pancer, K. Hayward, R. Peters (2018)
Advancing Early Childhood Development and Prevention Programs: A Pan-Canadian Knowledge Transfer Initiative for Better Beginnings, Better FuturesAustralian and New Zealand Journal of Family Therapy
D. Fetterman (2019)
Empowerment evaluation: a stakeholder involvement approachHealth Promotion Journal of Australia, 30
J. Springett (2017)
Impact in participatory health research: what can we learn from research on participatory evaluation?Educational Action Research, 25
R. O'Sullivan (2012)
Collaborative evaluation within a framework of stakeholder-oriented evaluation approaches.Evaluation and program planning, 35 4
Y. Suarez-Balcazar, G. Harper (2014)
Promoting Program Success and Fulfilling Accountability Requirements in a Statewide Community-Based Initiative: Challenges, Progress, and Lessons Learned
B. Fischer (2016)
Lessons Learned.Schizophrenia bulletin, 42 1
M. Mark (2017)
Inequities and Evaluation InfluenceNew Directions for Evaluation, 2017
J. Ball, P. Janyst (2008)
Enacting Research Ethics in Partnerships with Indigenous Communities in Canada: “Do it in a Good Way”Journal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics, 3
H. Arksey, L. O’Malley (2005)
Scoping studies: towards a methodological frameworkInternational Journal of Social Research Methodology, 8
E. Kearney, L. McIntosh, B. Perry, Sue Dockett, K. Clayton (2014)
Building positive relationships with Indigenous children, families and communities: learning at the cultural interfaceCritical Studies in Education, 55
J. Scougall (2006)
Reconciling tensions between principles and practice in Indigenous evaluationEvaluation Journal of Australasia, 6
Purnima Sundar, S. Kasprzak, T. Halsall, H. Woltman (2010)
Using Web-Based Technologies to Increase Evaluation Capacity in Organizations Providing Child and Youth Mental Health ServicesCanadian Journal of Program Evaluation
R. Aronson, Anne Wallis, P. O’Campo, P. Schafer (2007)
Neighborhood Mapping and Evaluation: A Methodology for Participatory Community Health InitiativesMaternal and Child Health Journal, 11
K. Olejniczak (2017)
The Game of Knowledge BrokeringAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 38
Monica Hargraves, Jane Buckley, Jennifer Urban, M. Linver, Lisa Chauveron, Satabdi Samtani, T. Archibald, Leslie Moorman (2021)
Resonance, stickiness, and the value propositions of Evaluation Capacity Building: Key takeaways and future directionsNew Directions for Evaluation, 2021
Jaimie Haugen, J. Chouinard (2018)
Transparent, Translucent, Opaque: Exploring the Dimensions of Power in Culturally Responsive Evaluation ContextsAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 40
(2018)
The state of evaluation measurement and evaluation practices in Ontario's nonprofit sector
A. Collier, S. Daiss, Everlynn Temengil, S. Russell, J. Miller, Fumiana Renguul (2018)
Developing an obesity intervention in Micronesia: From needs assessment to planning.Evaluation and program planning, 69
(2011)
2011).Collecting data from parents and children for the purpose
Maya Haviland, W. Pillsbury (2012)
Challenges Faced when Evaluating the Jalaris Kids Future ClubEvaluation Journal of Australasia, 12
(2021)
Office of Planning, Research, and Evaluation, Administration for Children and Families
R. Aronson, Anne Wallis, P. O’Campo, T. Whitehead, P. Schafer (2007)
Ethnographically Informed Community Evaluation: A Framework and Approach for Evaluating Community-Based InitiativesMaternal and Child Health Journal, 11
(2013)
summary-strategies-for-engaging-early-learning-stakeholders International Association for Public Participation
A. Tricco, Erin Lillie, W. Zarin, K. O’Brien, H. Colquhoun, D. Levac, D. Moher, M. Peters, T. Horsley, L. Weeks, S. Hempel, E. Akl, Christine Chang, J. McGowan, L. Stewart, L. Hartling, Adrian Aldcroft, Michael Wilson, C. Garritty, S. Lewin, C. Godfrey, M. Macdonald, Etienne Langlois, K. Soares-Weiser, J. Moriarty, T. Clifford, zge Tunalp, S. Straus (2018)
PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR): Checklist and ExplanationAnnals of Internal Medicine, 169
(2020)
Understanding community-led approaches to community change
Tribal Workgroup (2013)
A roadmap for collaborative and effective evaluation in Tribal communities
J. Chouinard, Peter Milley (2018)
Uncovering the mysteries of inclusion: Empirical and methodological possibilities in participatory evaluation in an international context.Evaluation and program planning, 67
M. McDonald, K. Rosier (2011)
Collecting data from parents and children for the purpose of evaluation Issues for child and family services in disadvantaged communities
E. Danseco (2013)
The Five Cs for Innovating in Evaluation Capacity Building: Lessons from the FieldCanadian Journal of Program Evaluation
David Mykota (2008)
Implementing paraprofessional strength-based early intervention home visitations.Evaluation and program planning, 31 3
Linda Mitchell (2011)
Enquiring teachers and democratic politics: transformations in New Zealand’s early childhood education landscapeEarly Years, 31
Hannah Harrison, S. Griffin, I. Kuhn, J. Usher-Smith (2020)
Software tools to support title and abstract screening for systematic reviews in healthcare: an evaluationBMC Medical Research Methodology, 20
(2021)
Te Ara Poutama indicators of quality for early childhood education: What matters most
J. Chouinard (2016)
Introduction: Decolonizing International Development EvaluationThe Canadian Journal of Program Evaluation, 30
(2003)
A naturalistic study of the Cherokee language immersion preschool project
(2018)
Leadership in evaluation capacity building: Influencing organizational change and learning about how to do and use evaluation (Publication No. 13422121
Nicole Bowman-Farrell (2020)
EvalIndigenous Origin Story: Effective Practices within Local Contexts to Inform the Field and Practice of EvaluationThe Canadian Journal of Program Evaluation, 34
Q. Brewington, J. Hall (2018)
Givin’ Stakeholders the MicAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 39
P. Flaspohler, A. Wandersman, Dana Keener, Kathryn Maxwell, A. Ace, A. Andrews, Baron Holmes (2003)
Promoting Program Success and Fulfilling Accountability Requirements in a Statewide Community-Based InitiativeJournal of Prevention & Intervention in the Community, 26
F. Baum, C. MacDougall, Danielle Smith (2006)
Participatory action researchJournal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 60
J. Acree (2019)
Applying the Collaborative Approaches to Evaluation (CAE) Principles in an Educational Evaluation: Reflections from the FieldThe Canadian Journal of Program Evaluation, 34
T. Abma, H. Leyerzapf, Elleke Landeweer (2017)
Responsive Evaluation in the Interference Zone Between System and LifeworldAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 38
Naomi Andrews, D. Pepler, M. Motz (2019)
Research and Evaluation With Community-Based Projects: Approaches, Considerations, and StrategiesAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 40
D. Bailey, M. Bruder, Kathleen Hebbeler, J. Carta, Michelle Defosset, C. Greenwood, Lynne Kahn, Sangeeta Mallik, Joy Markowitz, D. Spiker, D. Walker, Lauren Barton (2006)
Recommended Outcomes for Families of Young Children with DisabilitiesJournal of Early Intervention, 28
J. Cousins, S. Goh, C. Elliott, I. Bourgeois (2014)
Framing the Capacity to Do and Use EvaluationNew Directions for Evaluation, 2014
I. Bourgeois, Bradley Cousins (2013)
Understanding Dimensions of Organizational Evaluation CapacityAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 34
R. O'Sullivan, A. D'Agostino (2002)
Promoting Evaluation through CollaborationEvaluation, 8
Children’s early experiences and environments profoundly impact their development; therefore, ensuring the well-being of children through effective supports and services is critical. Evaluation is a tool that can be used to understand the effectiveness of early childhood development (ECD) practices, programs, and policies. A deeper understanding of the evaluation landscape in the ECD field is needed at this time. The purpose of this scoping review was to explore the state of evaluation in the ECD field across four constructs: community-driven evaluation, culturally responsive evaluation, evaluation capacity building, and evaluation use and influence. A comprehensive search of 7 electronic databases, including Canadian and international literature published in English from 2000 to 2020, was conducted. A total of 30 articles met the inclusion criteria. Findings demonstrate that some studies include aspects of a community-engaged approach to evaluation; however, comprehensive approaches to community-driven evaluation, culturally responsive evaluation, evaluation capacity building, and evaluation use in the field of ECD are not commonly achieved. This review will inform strategies for bridging evaluation gaps in the ECD sector, ultimately equipping organisations with the evaluative tools to improve practices, programs, and policies that impact the children, families, and communities they serve.
Evaluation Journal of Australasia – SAGE
Published: Mar 24, 2022
Keywords: early childhood development; evaluation capacity; community-driven evaluation; culturally responsive evaluation; evaluation use and influence
Read and print from thousands of top scholarly journals.
Already have an account? Log in
Bookmark this article. You can see your Bookmarks on your DeepDyve Library.
To save an article, log in first, or sign up for a DeepDyve account if you don’t already have one.
Copy and paste the desired citation format or use the link below to download a file formatted for EndNote
Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
All DeepDyve websites use cookies to improve your online experience. They were placed on your computer when you launched this website. You can change your cookie settings through your browser.