Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
Loading next page...
/lp/multidisciplinary-digital-publishing-institute/towards-sustainable-heritage-tourism-a-space-syntax-based-analysis-OLSQwX6D0U
- Publisher
- Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute
- Copyright
- © 1996-2020 MDPI (Basel, Switzerland) unless otherwise stated Disclaimer The statements, opinions and data contained in the journals are solely those of the individual authors and contributors and not of the publisher and the editor(s). Terms and Conditions Privacy Policy
- ISSN
- 2075-5309
- DOI
- 10.3390/buildings10020029
- Publisher site
- See Article on Publisher Site
Abstract
buildings Article Towards Sustainable Heritage Tourism: A Space Syntax-Based Analysis Method to Improve Tourists’ Spatial Cognition in Chinese Historic Districts 1 1 , 1 1 2 2 Yabing Xu , John Rollo *, David S. Jones , Yolanda Esteban , Hui Tong and Qipeng Mu School of Architecture and Built Environment, Deakin University, Melbourne, VIC 3220 Australia; xuyab@deakin.edu.au (Y.X.); david.jones@deakin.edu.au (D.S.J.); yolanda.esteban@deakin.edu.au (Y.E.) School of Architecture and Urban Planning, Shandong Jianzhu University (Shandong University of Architecture and Engineering), Jinan 250101, China; huitong@sdjzu.edu.cn (H.T.); qipengmu@sdjzu.edu.cn (Q.M.) * Correspondence: john.rollo@deakin.edu.au; Tel.: +61-3522-78329 Received: 31 December 2019; Accepted: 11 February 2020; Published: 14 February 2020 Abstract: Historical and cultural blocks in Chinese historic districts are important components of sustainable heritage tourism. In towns along the Grand Canal, historical and cultural blocks are generally integrated with modern commerce, forming a complex space characterized by multi-elements, multi-cultures, and multi-functions. The understanding of tourists’ spatial cognition thus becomes extremely important to support heritage conservation and encourage sustainable heritage tourism. This study proposes a space syntax-based methodology to help inform heritage consultants and urban designers in understanding the tourists’ spatial cognition of canal town cultural blocks, and thereby assists designers and managers in identifying where cognitive experiences can be improved. The proposed method is applied to Nanyang, which is a canal town currently in decline in Shandong Province, and is contrasted with the ancient town of Wuzhen in Zhejiang Province, China, a highly successful tourist town. By using this proposed method, the relationship between street networks and tourists’ spatial cognition has been explored. The results of the analysis were evaluated in order to inform a range of design concepts that could enhance the sustainable heritage tourism experience of these two towns. Keywords: space syntax; canal town; spatial cognition; sustainable heritage tourism 1. Introduction Sustainable heritage tourism has been a major concern for many countries who possess rich culture heritages, and its establishment as a discipline requires a systematic analysis of the spatial characteristics of historical districts. At present, research on the spatial characteristics of historical districts in the fields of architecture, landscape architecture, and urban design is largely qualitatively-based on environmental cognition information of tourists being derived by means of interviews, questionnaires, cognitive maps, and factor analysis. In recent years, the space syntax model has been widely used in the fields of architecture and urban planning [1]. This model is considered to be a vital achievement and method in communicating the juncture between subjective and objective perspectives in the study of urban space [2]. Nevertheless, owing to the complexity of urban space, the di erences in cognitive subjects and the limitations of the syntax model in respect of methods and techniques (e.g., subjectivity in the construction of axial diagram models, and diculties in measuring three-dimensional urban space), there have been some deviations in the quality analysis of spatial syntax modelling. Hence, previous research Buildings 2020, 10, 29; doi:10.3390/buildings10020029 www.mdpi.com/journal/buildings Buildings 2020, 10, 29 2 of 18 using space syntax to analyze Chinese historical districts rarely considered tourists’ perceptions of spatial configuration. This research aims to develop a space syntax-based analysis method that combines environmental psychology and space syntax. The method applies linear mathematical analysis methods in spatial syntax, which is a default built into Depthmap [3] analysis software, to calculate a series of parameters to generate an axis map, and then to select the main variables in the space syntax model by analyzing variables, including the connectivity value, control value, mean depth value, global integration value, local integration value, and intelligibility value. The correlation between the value and spatial information are reported in several recent studies [4–7]. If a space has high connectivity value, it means a large number of spaces connect with this space [4]. Control value could reflect spatial connectivity [5]. Furthermore, the mean depth value refers to the shortest topological distance of the space from all other spaces. The higher the integration value, the higher the accessibility and commonality of the space [6]. Intelligibility value is used to measure whether the local spatial structure helps to establish an understanding of the entire inter-spatial system, and indicates spatial identifiability [7]. Based on the definitions of main variables and spatial cognition of environmental psychology [8], tourist spatial cognition indicators can be developed. This proposed method is explored through a case study of Nanyang, in China, in which tourists’ spatial cognition is analyzed, in order to develop a range of urban design options to support sustainable heritage tourism. The following paper is divided into five distinct sections. Following the introduction, the second section introduces the methodology that focuses on space syntax. The third section presents the case study that applied contrast analysis theory to correlate the findings of a space syntax analysis of Nanyang. The fourth section elaborates on the limitations and future research, and presents a range of design suggestions to help improve tourists’ spatial cognition in the historic districts of Nanyang. Conclusions are drawn in the fifth section. 2. Overview of Space Syntax Space syntax is a method for describing and analyzing the relationships between spaces of urban areas and buildings [9]. Since Hillier put forward the concept of space syntax in the late 1970s, the model has been widely used as a social logic language to comprehend urban or architectural space [10]. Especially since 2000, the integration of the space syntax model and geographic information systems (GIS) has greatly enhanced its space form analysis and expression competence, making it an important tool for space planning and design. In recent years, the space syntax model has been also used to investigate urban land use, conservation, and renewal of ancient blocks, accessibility of urban public facilities, and distribution of crimes in the city. As a theory, space syntax di ers from classical urban morphology because it focuses on open space systems to pursue a form of spatial representation [10]. Space syntax theorists call sets of simulated relations between spaces a “configuration” or “accessibility” and these terms are used as ways of describing what they understand to be the intrinsic properties of space [11]. Space syntax-based analysis uses three types of distance metrics [12]: topological (fewest turns paths); geometrical (least angle change paths); and metric (shortest physical paths). The space syntax then calculates the street network configuration at di erent scales according to the size of the research area. The global scale analysis measures the average depth of an axial line or segment to all other axial lines or segments in whole street networks, while the local scale analysis makes calculations in a limited radius [13]. In light of a large number of studies on the comparison and relationship between space syntax model and space image and cognitive map, Turner [14] believed that there was a relationship between isovist graphs and visibility graphs, which can be used in the study of spatial cognition. Shokouhi et al. [15] suggested that the coherent structure composed of the prominent elements of the city, the organic organization of buildings and the continuity between landmark visual inter-domains is the key to the interpretation of the city by comparing the space syntax analysis and image map of di erent cities. Tao [16] combined the axis map and image map in order to discuss the spatial forms of Buildings 2020, 10, 29 3 of 18 villages. Koohsari [17] took the historic block of Taiping Street in Changsha, Hunan Province as an example, comparing the cognitive map with the space syntax model, and found that the space syntax model had a high degree of correlation with the node and road network in the cognitive map. There are also studies that sought to test and revise the research conclusions of the space syntax model by means of experiments upon tourists’ behaviours and analysis of their comments. Li et al. [18] applied space syntax analysis to provide an understanding of tourist space at historic sites on Gulangyu Island in Fujian Province. They explored the relationship between street network integration and the urban fabric as well as tourist preferences. Kubat [19] investigated pedestrian and vehicular activities in Sharjah historic center in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) in order to understand current movement patterns, and analyzed physical structure based on understanding the spatial configuration of the historic center. Data in the research generated a multi-level, electronic database of urban form and function, containing levels of spatial integration in the current street networks and levels of pedestrian and vehicular movement. The analysis results have been comparatively evaluated, leading to an in-depth understanding of the decay of Chinese historic districts. Sheng et al. [20] took the Chaoyang historic block renewal project in Jilin Province as a case study, and applied the space syntax model to trac volumes and visual integration of the site. All these analyses provided a basis for the full design process from conceptual design to proposal evaluation in order to activate this site by introducing pedestrian vitality. Multiple spatial characteristics, such as waterways, bridges, streets, laneways, as well as the roadside stalls and performances, benefits the improvement of spatial cognition and experience Spatial characteristics have a direct impact on people’s cognition, which is always accompanied by emotional reactions in the process of cognition [2]. Lynch [21] mentioned that di erent environments were easier to understand and find because di erent parts are clearer and more memorable for people, additionally, di erentiation creates better landmarks and urban space. Montello [22] proposed that urban spatial environments were di erentiated by their chaotic and disorienting appearances. Rollo and Barker [23] focused on the responses of 30 postgraduate participants who were asked to evaluate a streetscape experience based on favourable and unfavourable perceptive qualities. The study presented in this paper intends to promote the research of space syntax. It will provide a visualized and quantitative approach to the field of sustainable heritage tourism via understanding the urban morphological features and tourist preferences. 3. Proposed Method The proposed space syntax-based analysis method contains two main parts. The first part is the extraction of spatial morphology information on the basis of the space syntax model. The second part is the analysis of tourists’ spatial cognition. 3.1. Extraction of Spatial Morphology Information Depthmap [3], an open source software, is selected to extract the spatial morphology information of block. Having regard to the density of buildings in the ancient Nanyang town area, the axis segmentation method in the space syntax theory is used. In the analysis of variables, the main index items in the space syntax model were selected to analyze the spatial topological relationship of the street axis of the historical block of the canal town. The main index items include a connectivity value, control value, mean depth value, global integration value, local integration value, and intelligibility value [9]. The connectivity value (C ) refers to the number k of spaces connected to the ‘i’ space as following equation: C = k (1) The higher connectivity value indicates the closer space to the surrounding space, the stronger influence on the surrounding space, and the better space permeability. The control value (C ) refers to 1i Buildings 2020, 10, 29 4 of 18 the reciprocal sum of other spatial connection values connected to the ‘i’ spatial node as the following equation: C = (2) 1i j = 1 The larger control value denotes the greater degree of control the ‘i’ space over the space which it intersects. The mean depth value (D ) refers to the shortest topological distance (d ) of the ‘i’ space i i j from all other spaces ( j) as the following equation: i j j = 1 D = (3) n 1 The lower mean depth indicates the space is more convenient so the lower mean depth value is desired. The global integration value (I ) refers to the degree of spatial aggregation or dispersion between the ‘i’ space and other spaces as the following equation: n(log ((n + 2)/3) 1) + 1 I = (4) (n 1)(D 1) The integration value is the most commonly used and important analysis variable. The higher integration value indicates the higher accessibility and commonality of the space. Besides the global integration value, the local integration value, I (K), is used and refers to the relationship between the ‘i’ space and other spaces within K steps. Usually K is 3 and this term is named as radius-3 integration. 3.2. Analysis of Tourists’ Spatial Cognition Previous studies [2,8,24] on spatial cognition studied how people recognize and understand the environment, including environmental image, distance judgment, spatial orientation, wayfinding, and place naming. The five analysis variables in space syntax models and the corresponding spatial characteristics and tourist spatial cognition indicators are shown in Table 1. Table 1. Analysis variables in space syntax model and tourist spatial cognition indicators. Analysis Variables in Space Syntax Spatial Characteristics Tourist Spatial Cognition Indicators Model Road-network structure is complex. Connectivity value Spatial permeability Tourists’ journey through the town is intriguing. Few dead-end roads. Spatial connectivity Control value Lane ways and streets are well interconnected. Few repeated-visit happen. Mean depth value Spatial compactness High spatial compactness, high tour eciency. Spatial accessibility There is a clear main tour road. Integration value Spatial publicity There is a significant gathering center. Tourist can accurately determine the current location. Intelligibility value Spatial identifiability Tourist can eciently find their way to the destinations. The spatial functional zoning of the block is clear and easy to identify. The information that people perceive in the canal town is relatively complex. In addition, people’s cognition of a space experience is a complex psychological process, involving the characteristics of environmental information, complexity preference, emotional response, social and cultural background, the interaction between people and the environment. Environmental psychologists mentioned that people have di erent cognitions for di erent spaces [8]. The information provided by space and environment is the premise of behaviour, and space is the place where behaviour occurs [24]. Spatial cognition is influenced by many kinds of sensory stimuli [25]. When considering spatial cognition, social Buildings 2020, 10, 29 5 of 18 and cultural information should be paid special attention. In the environment, di erent perceptions can also replace each other. The combination of waterways, bridges, streets, and laneways often within a dense one- and two-storey block structure not only makes the canal towns in China popular for tourists, but also this interest is sca olded with local food shops along streets, cultural and artistic performances, folk-customs within a cultural background setting, and all these spatial characteristics contribute to make a lasting impression upon tourists. All of these elements contribute to the improvement of spatial cognition and experience. With respect to the relationship between the space syntax model and subjective analysis methods, this research takes the historic and cultural block of Nanyang ancient town the case study. Research sought to measure its spatial topological relationship under a walking scale by employing the connectivity value, control value, mean depth value, integration value and intelligibility value in the spatial syntax model. In addition, a survey questionnaire has been designed on tourists’ spatial cognition in line with the spatial characteristics represented by indexes. The report will discuss the relationship between the two methods from the point of view of both subjective and objective information through data contrast analysis. 4. Case Studies: Nanyang and Wuzhen 4.1. Overview of Nanyang Nanyang is a canal town located in Weishan County, Jining City, Shandong Province in China. It has an area of 4.5 km , spreading over 13 islands, and a population of 30,800. The Nanyang ancient town is located on the main island of Nanyang, covering an area of 1.68 km with 12,000 people [26]. Nanyang used to be a thriving business center during the Ming and Qing Dynasties (1368~1911), and became a ferry port with the construction of a ditch during the reign of Emperor Long Qing of the Ming Dynasty (1368~1644). The Beijing–Hangzhou Grand Canal, the oldest and longest man-made canal in the world, built in 468 BC, cuts through it, and the township served as a water transportation hub between the north and south of China allowing the transportation and exchange of goods such as fish, liquor, rice, bean curd, silk, and kerosene [27]. However, Nanyang has become a town in decline. To date, this ancient town has continued to maintain its historical buildings and natural scenery, being surrounded by small rivers and bridges that cross parts of the Grand Canal [28]. The locals still rely on boats as their main mode of transportation, and their houses retain ancient architectural styles. In 2014, the Beijing–Hangzhou Grand Canal was selected as a World Heritage List place, and Nanyang, as an important part of the Grand Canal, has received much recognition throughout the world as a consequence of this inscription [29]. Recognizing these problems, the local government of Nanyang has invited designs and plans for rebuilding and extending the town. Nevertheless, because parts of the town have been allowed to fall into disrepair, a review of comments on a tourist website reveals a range of opinions that critique the rather tired appearance of this town, as set out in Table 2. Buildings 2020, 10, 29 6 of 18 Table 2. Negative comments and source websites (the initial comments were written in Chinese and the authors translated them into English). Date Negative Comments Websites The buildings on the island are too crowded and it is boring to visit 17 September 2015 https://bbs.syuan.net/4/s1095657/ such an ancient town. The ancient buildings along the road are special and have a taste. Now, the town is a bit over-developed. Many characteristic houses have been 20 June 2015 https://bbs.syuan.net/4/s1017001/2/ demolished. I didn’t see any scenery last time because of walls. The characteristic street can be visited in less than half an hour. Dragon Boat Festival in Nanyang is usually very lively. Such a spectacular scene must not be missed. However, the scene will be very https://m.tuniu.com/tipnews/106197/ 4 June 2016 crowded. Do remember to keep your money and belongings, and ?p=27183 protect your kids, otherwise you may be overcrowded and injured. The first impression of Nanyang is that this town is still in the initial development stage: the terminal management is not formal, and the tourism facilities cannot satisfy the requirements of tourists. In http: 3 October 2018 summary, the tourism development of the ancient town has just begun, //www.mafengwo.cn/i/10768070.html and the software and hardware need to be improved. It is pity that there are too many new things and too few old things in the ancient town. Back on the island, there are restaurants and shopping streets http: 6 June 2019 everywhere. The similar commercial streets are not advisable and //www.mafengwo.cn/i/14721294.html attractive. It was quite messy on the ancient street, and people are busy with http: 2 August 2019 selling. //www.mafengwo.cn/i/16289208.html 4.2. Interpreting the Spatial Syntax Analysis of Nanyang Because the aim of this research is to explore the relationship between the space syntax analysis model of a historic and cultural block and tourists’ perception, the road network of Nanyang is segmented according to the principle of the minimum space syntax model, and the total number of axes is 315. The current road network and water channels are illustrated in Figure 1, which is the town planning for 2030. In this map, it is clear to see that the Grand Canal goes across the town and breaks many roads, and multiple squares are located at the ends of the roads. Buildings 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 7 of 19 Figure 1. Road-network waterway system plan in Nanyang (Source: Nanyang Government). Figure 1. Road-network waterway system plan in Nanyang (Source: Nanyang Government). Then, a magnified aerial map of the main tourist street near the Grand Canal is shown in Figure 2. Tourist attractions such as residences, palace, temples, etc., are marked and highlighted. In view of the difference between the ancient town area and non-ancient area, the research focuses on the ancient town area and the total number of axes in the ancient town area is 40. Figure 2. Aerial view map of Nanyang. In the results of space syntax-based analysis, the colours refer to high and low values; red refers to high values, while blue refers to low values of integration. On the whole, the axis structure of the ancient town area in Nanyang is not relatively simple. The Nanyang street as a clear ‘vertical’ main Buildings 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 7 of 19 Buildings 2020, 10, 29 7 of 18 Figure 1. Road-network waterway system plan in Nanyang (Source: Nanyang Government). Then, a magnified aerial map of the main tourist street near the Grand Canal is shown in Figure 2. Then, a magnified aerial map of the main tourist street near the Grand Canal is shown in Figure Tourist attractions such as residences, palace, temples, etc., are marked and highlighted. In view of the 2. Tourist attractions such as residences, palace, temples, etc., are marked and highlighted. In view of di erence between the ancient town area and non-ancient area, the research focuses on the ancient the difference between the ancient town area and non-ancient area, the research focuses on the town area and the total number of axes in the ancient town area is 40. ancient town area and the total number of axes in the ancient town area is 40. Figure 2. Aerial view map of Nanyang. Figure 2. Aerial view map of Nanyang. In the results of space syntax-based analysis, the colours refer to high and low values; red refers In the results of space syntax-based analysis, the colours refer to high and low values; red refers to high values, while blue refers to low values of integration. On the whole, the axis structure of the to high values, while blue refers to low values of integration. On the whole, the axis structure of the ancient town area in Nanyang is not relatively simple. The Nanyang street as a clear ‘vertical’ main ancient town area in Nanyang is not relatively simple. The Nanyang street as a clear ‘vertical’ main tourist street, connects the main tourist attractions such as the Bring-baby Palace and the River-god tourist street, connects the main tourist attractions such as the Bring-baby Palace and the River-god Temple. Because of the mixed functions of tourism and residence within the block, many living lanes Temple. Because of the mixed functions of tourism and residence within the block, many living lanes are enclosed to form an independent closed space, or exist in the form of a ‘broken road’, that results are enclosed to form an independent closed space, or exist in the form of a ‘broken road’, that results in in the weak spatial connectivity of the whole block. The results of space syntax analysis variables for the weak spatial connectivity of the whole block. The results of space syntax analysis variables for 10 streets and seven hutongs are shown in Table 3, where the average connectivity value for the 17 lanes is only 5. That is, there are on average five axis intersections with each street axis. Table 3. Space syntax analysis variables of ancient town area in Nanyang. Local Integration Global Integration Road Name Connectivity Value Control Value Mean Depth Value Value Value Shuangyang Street 6 1.708 105.609 3.887 130.595 Xiangyang Street 5 1.726 90.139 3.961 110.069 Kaiyang Street 5 1.726 92.667 2.931 113.985 Nanyang Street 18 10.031 124.960 3.300 111.841 Jinger Street 4 1.250 92.715 3.681 145.869 Matou Street 4 1.250 73.930 4.743 90.519 Jingzi Street 5 1.726 91.193 3.930 111.232 Shuyuan Street 5 1.726 100.868 3.662 126.501 Zhuangyuan Street 9 3.000 108.751 3.529 129.714 Beiyi Hutong 3 0.814 84.983 4.384 100.951 Beier Hutong 4 1.250 85.537 4.443 100.951 Beisan Hutong 4 1.250 84.198 4.424 100.594 Beisi Hutong 4 1.250 85.931 4.702 102.461 Beiwu Hutong 4 1.076 86.401 4.046 102.487 Beiliu Hutong 4 1.076 89.110 4.054 104.060 Beiqi Hutong 4 1.076 88.094 4.089 103.487 Kaian Street 9 2.430 76.425 4.653 90.414 Average value 5 2.015 85.236 4.505 110.059 The space syntax model analysis result based on four values are presented in Figure 3 where the red and blue denote the high values and low values, respectively. As the colour contour shown in Figure 3a, there is a significant di erence in the connectivity of the axis of di erent functional streets, Buildings 2020, 10, 29 8 of 18 and the average control value is 2.01 in the ancient town area. Since the historic and cultural block of Nanyang is a pedestrian street, the local integration value and mean depth value at walking scale were selected to analyze the compactness and accessibility of the ancient town area. On the whole, the space compactness of the historic and cultural block of the ancient town area in Nanyang is not strong. The local integration value of the main tourist streets is 85.236 (see Table 3). Figure 3b depicts the local integration value of streets in the ancient town area and it is obvious that Nanyang Street has the highest value, which is 124.960. This value is ~50% higher than the average value in Table 3. On the contrary, the mean depth value is illustrated in Figure 3c where Kaiyang Street has the lowest value, 2.961, which is ~50% compared to the average value. Considering the results in Figure 3b,c, it is worth noting that Nanyang Street with the highest degree of local integration is the main tourist street intersecting in the middle of the block, and also the streets with the lower mean depth value. However, the level of accessibility of the lanes near the Grand Canal is relatively low, such as Kaian Street on the east of the Canal. This shows that at the walking scale, the block has an obvious central structure. The main tourist street in the middle of the block has the strongest accessibility, convenience, and public exposure and is the main passageway of the block space organization. This obvious central structure strengthens the convergence of people and provides historic sites or attractions in the central region with a clear geographical advantage. Therefore, the central structure of the ancient town area is obvious, and the main tourist street has the potential to o er a strong public interface. The global integration value, see Figure 3d, could test the compactness of all nodes in the whole system. Buildings 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 19 Figure 3. The space syntax model analysis result on Nanyang town: (a) connectivity value, (b) local Figure 3. The space syntax model analysis result on Nanyang town: (a) connectivity value, (b) local integration value, (c) mean depth value and (d) global integration value. integration value, (c) mean depth value and (d) global integration value. As the colour contours in Figure 3d and values in Table 3, there are three streets with the highest global integration values, namely, Jinger Street (145.869), Shuangyang Street (130.595), Zhuangyuan Street (129.714). Li and Duan [30] suggested that a stronger global integration value makes it easier to accumulate pedestrian flow. Therefore, Jinger Street, Shuangyang Street, and Zhuangyuan Street are the most public and convenient spaces for tourists to gather. Spatial intelligibility is used to measure the cognitive degree of a spatial group. If a spatial group has a high degree of intelligibility, this means that its overall spatial layout is more easily recognized and mastered by people [31]. People’s cognition of the whole always comes from local information, and the degree of intelligibility reflects the difficulty of judging the whole information according to the local information of spatial groups. The characteristic of comprehensibility means that what one can see from the spatial layout matches or is a useful guide for what one cannot see [9]. For systems lacking intelligibility, there are many connected spaces, that often cannot be well integrated into the whole system. Therefore, according to the visible connections, one can often be misled into understanding the orientation of this space in the whole system [10]. In the space syntax model, intelligence value can measure whether the local space and the whole space are related and unified [9]. Generally, the range of the intelligence value R is 0–0.5, which indicates that the spatial 2 2 identifiability is weak; R locates at 0.5–0.7 which indicates that the spatial identifiability is good; R locates at 0.7–1.0 which indicates that the space recognizability is strong [32]. In consideration of the high density of historical buildings in ancient canal towns, this research is conducted using the method of segmentation axis and isovist maps based on space syntax [15]. The Buildings 2020, 10, 29 9 of 18 As the colour contours in Figure 3d and values in Table 3, there are three streets with the highest global integration values, namely, Jinger Street (145.869), Shuangyang Street (130.595), Zhuangyuan Street (129.714). Li and Duan [30] suggested that a stronger global integration value makes it easier to accumulate pedestrian flow. Therefore, Jinger Street, Shuangyang Street, and Zhuangyuan Street are the most public and convenient spaces for tourists to gather. Spatial intelligibility is used to measure the cognitive degree of a spatial group. If a spatial group has a high degree of intelligibility, this means that its overall spatial layout is more easily recognized and mastered by people [31]. People’s cognition of the whole always comes from local information, and the degree of intelligibility reflects the diculty of judging the whole information according to the local information of spatial groups. The characteristic of comprehensibility means that what one can see from the spatial layout matches or is a useful guide for what one cannot see [9]. For systems lacking intelligibility, there are many connected spaces, that often cannot be well integrated into the whole system. Therefore, according to the visible connections, one can often be misled into understanding the orientation of this space in the whole system [10]. In the space syntax model, intelligence value can measure whether the local space and the whole space are related and unified [9]. Generally, the range 2 2 of the intelligence value R is 0–0.5, which indicates that the spatial identifiability is weak; R locates at 0.5–0.7 which indicates that the spatial identifiability is good; R locates at 0.7–1.0 which indicates that the space recognizability is strong [32]. In consideration of the high density of historical buildings in ancient canal towns, this research is conducted using the method of segmentation axis and isovist maps based on space syntax [15]. The Depthmap Buildings 2020is , 10 used , x FOto R P extract EER REVIEW the connectivity value of the historical and cultural block of the Nanyang 10 of 19 ancient town area, according to the following formula: Depthmap is used to extract the connectivity value of the historical and cultural block of the Nanyang P 2 ancient town area, according to the following formula: C C I I i i R = (5) P ̅ 2 P ̅ 2 ∑ (𝐶 − 𝐶 )(𝐼 − 𝐼 ) (5) 𝑖 𝑖 C C I I i i 𝑅 = 2 2 ̅ ̅ ∑ (𝐶 − 𝐶 ) ∑ (𝐼 − 𝐼 ) 𝑖 𝑖 This is introduced to calculate the intelligibility value R of the historical and cultural block of This is introduced to calculate the intelligibility value R of the historical and cultural block of the Nanyang ancient town area, where I refers to the integration value, C̅ refers to the average of the Nanyang ancient town area, where 𝐼 i refers to the integration value, 𝐶 refers to the average of the C of all units, and I is ̅ the average value of the I of all units in space. The intelligibility value is i i the 𝐶 of all units, and 𝐼 is the average value of the 𝐼 of all units in space. The intelligibility value 𝑖 𝑖 calculated as 0.641 as shown in Figure 4. The value indicates that the recognizability of the street axis is calculated as 0.641 as shown in Figure 4. The value indicates that the recognizability of the street of the block is good. The intelligence value in Nanyang ancient town reflects that it is not dicult to axis of the block is good. The intelligence value in Nanyang ancient town reflects that it is not difficult establish an impression from the local part to the whole ancient town when tourists were walking in to establish an impression from the local part to the whole ancient town when tourists were walking the main streets. in the main streets. Figure 4. The space syntax model analysis result on Nanyang: intelligibility value. Figure 4. The space syntax model analysis result on Nanyang: intelligibility value. However, when considering that the functions of tourism, commerce, and residence are haphazardly mixed within the ancient town area, rather than being clearly defined in different sub- precincts, tourists often find themselves walking into semi-private residential areas, which is at first seem part of the public domain. In addition, with the renovation of shops and residential areas in recent years, part of the Hutong and lanes within the block has been interrupted, such as Beiqi Hutong and Beier Hutong. This makes it more difficult for tourists to obtain the overall spatial information of the block efficiently. Therefore, the spatial identifiability of Nanyang ancient town area should be strengthened by upgrading the laneway infrastructure, providing cognitive thresholds between public, semi-public and private areas, and developing a flexible wayfinding strategy for tourists as the town undergoes continued renovation. In this case study, visibility graph analysis (VGA) is conducted on a block beside Zhuangyuan Bridge. The location of the block for the case study in the ancient town as well as the buildings within the block, as shown in Figure 5. VGA is primarily applied to a building or a semi-urban scale in order to derive how visibility defines relationships of spatial elements and helps to understand the surrounding space [33]. Buildings 2020, 10, 29 10 of 18 However, when considering that the functions of tourism, commerce, and residence are haphazardly mixed within the ancient town area, rather than being clearly defined in di erent sub-precincts, tourists often find themselves walking into semi-private residential areas, which is at first seem part of the public domain. In addition, with the renovation of shops and residential areas in recent years, part of the Hutong and lanes within the block has been interrupted, such as Beiqi Hutong and Beier Hutong. This makes it more dicult for tourists to obtain the overall spatial information of the block eciently. Therefore, the spatial identifiability of Nanyang ancient town area should be strengthened by upgrading the laneway infrastructure, providing cognitive thresholds between public, semi-public and private areas, and developing a flexible wayfinding strategy for tourists as the town undergoes continued renovation. In this case study, visibility graph analysis (VGA) is conducted on a block beside Zhuangyuan Bridge. The location of the block for the case study in the ancient town as well as the buildings within the block, as shown in Figure 5. VGA is primarily applied to a building or a semi-urban scale in order to derive how visibility defines relationships of spatial elements and helps to understand the Buildin surrounding gs 2020, 10space , x FOR P [33 EE ].R REVIEW 11 of 19 Figure 5. The Current situation map of Nanyang (Source: Nanyang town government). Figure 5. The Current situation map of Nanyang (Source: Nanyang town government). The VGA results of the selected block based on four view locations were reported in Figure 6 The VGA results of the selected block based on four view locations were reported in Figure 6 where the white eye symbol denotes the view of one tourist. The red space is the space that the where the white eye symbol denotes the view of one tourist. The red space is the space that the pedestrians need to take more turns on the route through the block to see, and hence takes longer to be pedestrians need to take more turns on the route through the block to see, and hence takes longer to revealed and become available for tourists [34]. Based on Kaplan’s research [35], the red space has be revealed and become available for tourists [34]. Based on Kaplan’s research [35], the red space has greater depth and enhanced mystery. As the analysis results show in Figure 6, the largest red colour greater depth and enhanced mystery. As the analysis results show in Figure 6, the largest red colour regions were found when the tourist stands at the right east of the block. The yellow, the green and the regions were found when the tourist stands at the right east of the block. The yellow, the green and blue space denote the second least noticed space, the second most noticed space, and the most noticed the blue space denote the second least noticed space, the second most noticed space, and the most space, respectively. A little more space is visible for tourist standing at the south. Then, from the north noticed space, respectively. A little more space is visible for tourist standing at the south. Then, from and west perspectives, much more space is available for tourists in terms of visibility. the north and west perspectives, much more space is available for tourists in terms of visibility. Figure 6. Visibility graph analysis (VGA) of the highlighted block in Figure 5 (step1 denotes the most likely selected space for a tourist at the location of the eye symbol and step2 denotes the most likely selected space for tourists after step1.). Buildings 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 11 of 19 Figure 5. The Current situation map of Nanyang (Source: Nanyang town government). The VGA results of the selected block based on four view locations were reported in Figure 6 where the white eye symbol denotes the view of one tourist. The red space is the space that the pedestrians need to take more turns on the route through the block to see, and hence takes longer to be revealed and become available for tourists [34]. Based on Kaplan’s research [35], the red space has greater depth and enhanced mystery. As the analysis results show in Figure 6, the largest red colour regions were found when the tourist stands at the right east of the block. The yellow, the green and the blue space denote the second least noticed space, the second most noticed space, and the most Buildings 2020, 10, 29 11 of 18 noticed space, respectively. A little more space is visible for tourist standing at the south. Then, from the north and west perspectives, much more space is available for tourists in terms of visibility. Figure 6. Visibility graph analysis (VGA) of the highlighted block in Figure 5 (step1 denotes the most Figure 6. Visibility graph analysis (VGA) of the highlighted block in Figure 5 (step1 denotes the most likely selected space for a tourist at the location of the eye symbol and step2 denotes the most likely likely selected space for a tourist at the location of the eye symbol and step2 denotes the most likely selected space for tourists after step1.). selected space for tourists after step1.). Buildings 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 12 of 19 Besides the VGA, the pedestrian flow simulation is conducted and the results based on the four Besides the VGA, the pedestrian flow simulation is conducted and the results based on the four main entrances are shown in Figure 7, where the white triangle symbol denotes the main entrance main entrances are shown in Figure 7, where the white triangle symbol denotes the main entrance locations and the directions for pedestrian flow. High pedestrian flow is found in the regions near locations and the directions for pedestrian flow. High pedestrian flow is found in the regions near the entrance as well as the center region of this block. The integrated prediction is shown in Figure 8 the entrance as well as the center region of this block. The integrated prediction is shown in Figure 8 and it is clear that, regardless of the perspective, the space in the middle of the block (Songzi Hutong) and it is clear that, regardless of the perspective, the space in the middle of the block (Songzi Hutong) has the highest pedestrian flow. This may be an important consideration for designers, investors, has the highest pedestrian flow. This may be an important consideration for designers, investors, and and policymakers when restoring and enhancing the area for tourists. policymakers when restoring and enhancing the area for tourists. Figure 7. Pedestrian flow simulation on VGA of the highlighted block in Figure 5 (the red and the Figure 7. Pedestrian flow simulation on VGA of the highlighted block in Figure 5 (the red and the blue blue denote high and low tourist intensity, respectively.). denote high and low tourist intensity, respectively.). Figure 8. Integration of pedestrian flow simulation on VGA. 4.3. Comparing the Results of Nanyang with Wuzhen Wuzhen is regarded as the comparative case study in this paper. As with Nanyang, the Grand Canal crosses the town of Wuzhen and has also formed a special cultural relationship based upon water. However, unlike Nanyang, Wuzhen has become a very popular tourist destination along the Grand Canal as the town area map shown in Figure 9 where the highlighted region is selected for comparative study Buildings 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 12 of 19 Besides the VGA, the pedestrian flow simulation is conducted and the results based on the four main entrances are shown in Figure 7, where the white triangle symbol denotes the main entrance locations and the directions for pedestrian flow. High pedestrian flow is found in the regions near the entrance as well as the center region of this block. The integrated prediction is shown in Figure 8 and it is clear that, regardless of the perspective, the space in the middle of the block (Songzi Hutong) has the highest pedestrian flow. This may be an important consideration for designers, investors, and policymakers when restoring and enhancing the area for tourists. Buildings 2020, 10, 29 12 of 18 Figure 7. Pedestrian flow simulation on VGA of the highlighted block in Figure 5 (the red and the blue denote high and low tourist intensity, respectively.). Figure 8. Integration of pedestrian flow simulation on VGA. Figure 8. Integration of pedestrian flow simulation on VGA. 4.3. Comparing the Results of Nanyang with Wuzhen 4.3. Comparing the Results of Nanyang with Wuzhen Wuzhen is regarded as the comparative case study in this paper. As with Nanyang, the Grand Wuzhen is regarded as the comparative case study in this paper. As with Nanyang, the Grand Canal crosses the town of Wuzhen and has also formed a special cultural relationship based upon Canal crosses the town of Wuzhen and has also formed a special cultural relationship based upon water. However, unlike Nanyang, Wuzhen has become a very popular tourist destination along the water. However, unlike Nanyang, Wuzhen has become a very popular tourist destination along the Grand Canal as the town area map shown in Figure 9 where the highlighted region is selected for Grand Canal as the town area map shown in Figure 9 where the highlighted region is selected for comparative study comparative study Buildings 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 13 of 19 Figure 9. Wuzhen ancient town area map (Source: http://www.zjditu.cn/, accessed on 12 October Figure 9. Wuzhen ancient town area map (Source: http://www.zjditu.cn/, accessed on 12 October 2019). 2019). The space syntax model analysis results based on four values on Wuzhen were illustrated in Figure 10. The space syntax analysis variables of Wuzhen are summarised in Table 4 where the The space syntax model analysis results based on four values on Wuzhen were illustrated in r Fi esults gure 10 for . Th the e sp east acear synt ea ax and anwest alysis ar var eaia ar bl ees separatel of Wuzhen y listed. are sum As mari shown sed in in Ta Figur ble 4 e where 10a, the the highest results global integration values were observed in Shifuonan Street and Ziye Road which are located at the for the east area and west area are separately listed. As shown in Figure 10a, the highest global boundaries integration of values Wuzhen were town. observed The conne in Shif ctivity uonan values Street of the andstr Ziye eets Ro in W ad uzhen which ar ar e quite e located di erat entth as e shown in Figure 10b, however, the high average value in Table 4 indicates a much higher connectivity boundaries of Wuzhen town. The connectivity values of the streets in Wuzhen are quite different as in shown Wuzhen in Figure than10 Nanyang. b, however, Then, the hboth igh aver theag highest e valuelocal in Table integration 4 indicates value a much and higher mean depth connect value ivity were observed in streets in East Scenic Area as shown in Figure 10c,d, respectively. Therefore, this in Wuzhen than Nanyang. Then, both the highest local integration value and mean depth value were observed in streets in East Scenic Area as shown in Figure 10c,d, respectively. Therefore, this comparative study investigates the spatial structure of Wuzhen to see if there are any significant differences in the space syntax variables between the two towns (see the comparison between Tables 3 and 4) and, therefore, provides a more informed understanding of the spatial structure, especially relating to route complexity, which may contribute to a favourable canal town experience. Buildings 2020, 10, 29 13 of 18 comparative study investigates the spatial structure of Wuzhen to see if there are any significant di erences in the space syntax variables between the two towns (see the comparison between Tables 3 and 4) and, therefore, provides a more informed understanding of the spatial structure, especially relating to route complexity, which may contribute to a favourable canal town experience. Buildings 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 14 of 19 Figure 10. The space syntax model analysis results on Wuzhen town: (a) global integration value, (b) Figure 10. The space syntax model analysis results on Wuzhen town: (a) global integration value, connectivity value, (c) local integration value, and (d) mean depth value. (b) connectivity value, (c) local integration value, and (d) mean depth value. Table 4. Space syntax analysis variables of ancient town area in Wuzhen. Table 4. Space syntax analysis variables of ancient town area in Wuzhen. Global Connectivity Control Local Integration Mean Depth Global Connecti Local Mean Area Road Name Integration Value Value Co Value ntrol Value Value Area Road Name Integration vity Integration Depth Sizhou Street 134.345 9 2.430 88.988 2.764 Value Value Value Value Value Xiushui Xiang 123.249 4 1.250 69.489 3.556 Xiushui Street 148.472 7 2.025 89.761 2.962 Sizhou Street 134.345 9 2.430 88.988 2.764 Chashi Street 176.199 10 3.452 101.969 2.252 West Scenic Xiyouche Nong 123.165 4 1.250 74.044 2.929 Xiushui Xiang 123.249 4 1.250 69.489 3.556 Area Xishan Street 149.067 15 5.176 94.549 2.430 Xiushui Street 148.472 7 2.025 89.761 2.962 Youche Nong 170.513 14 4.408 95.644 2.713 Nvhong Street 142.149 8 2.500 77.698 3.441 Chashi Street 176.199 10 3.452 101.969 2.252 Shifuonan Street 236.458 11 2.615 75.662 2.301 West Xiyouche Xinhua Road 207.472 17 5.320 128.387 3.198 123.165 4 1.250 74.044 2.929 Renshou Road 142.804 6 2.000 127.479 4.009 Scenic Nong Guanqian Street 158.328 12 3.590 93.760 4.402 East Scenic Area Xishan Street 149.067 15 5.176 94.549 2.430 Yizhen Road 132.802 5 1.726 67.411 4.413 Area Guanquan Road 161.741 3 1.000 85.993 3.943 Youche Nong 170.513 14 4.408 95.644 2.713 Yongan Road 126.591 7 2.025 67.283 4.238 Ziye Road 240.210 12 3.590 110.947 2.711 Nvhong Street 142.149 8 2.500 77.698 3.441 Average value 160.848 9 2.750 90.567 3.266 Shifuonan 236.458 11 2.615 75.662 2.301 Street Xinhua Road 207.472 17 5.320 128.387 3.198 Renshou Road 142.804 6 2.000 127.479 4.009 East Guanqian 158.328 12 3.590 93.760 4.402 Scenic Street Area Yizhen Road 132.802 5 1.726 67.411 4.413 Guanquan 161.741 3 1.000 85.993 3.943 Road Buildings 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 15 of 19 Buildings 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 15 of 19 Buildings 2020, 10, 29 14 of 18 Yo Yo ngan Ro ngan Ro ad ad 126.5 126.5 91 91 7 7 2.025 2.025 67.28 67.28 3 3 4.238 4.238 Ziye Road 240.210 12 3.590 110.947 2.711 Ziye Road 240.210 12 3.590 110.947 2.711 Avera Avera ge ge valu valu e e 160.8 160.8 48 48 9 9 2.750 2.750 90.56 90.56 7 7 3.266 3.266 The similarities and di erences of the Nanyang ancient town area and Wuzhen ancient town area Th Th e e si si mm ilar ilar itiiti es es and and di di ffe ffre ences rences of oth f th e e Na Na ny ny ang ang anc anc ient ient toto wn wn arar ea ea and and W W uz uz he he n n anc anc ient ient toto wn wn are evaluated and summarised in Table 5. On the whole, compared with Wuzhen, the axis structure area are evaluated and summarised in Table 5. On the whole, compared with Wuzhen, the axis area are evaluated and summarised in Table 5. On the whole, compared with Wuzhen, the axis of the ancient town struct arure o ea in f the Nanyang ancient town is rar elatively ea in Nanysimple. ang is relatively Because simpl of e. B the ecause mixed of the functions mixed functions of tour of structure of the ancient town area in Nanyang is relatively simple. Because of the mixed functions of toto ur ur and and residen residen ce ce with with in in thth e e block, block, ma ma ny ny liv liing ving lan lan es es are are enclo enclo sese d d toto form form an an independen independen t close t close d d and residence within the block, many living lanes are enclosed to form an independent closed space, space, space, or or exis exis t in t in thth e e form form of of a a ‘b‘b roken roken road’, road’, which which resu resu lts lts in in thth e e weak weak sp sp ati ati alal con con nect nect ivity ivity of of thth e e or exist in the form of a ‘broken road’, which results in the weak spatial connectivity of the whole block. who who lele block. block. Th Th erefore erefore , th , th e e average average co co nnec nnec tivity tivity value value is is only only 5 5 in in Na Na nya nya ng, ng, th th at at is, i s, th th ere ere ar ar e e on on Therefore, the average connectivity value is only 5 in Nanyang, that is, there are on average five axis average five axis intersections with each street axis. However, the average connectivity value in average five axis intersections with each street axis. However, the average connectivity value in intersections with each street axis. However, the average connectivity value in Table Table 5. 5. S imilar Similar itie its ieand s and didi fferences fferences of of the the Nanyan Nanyan g g ancie ancie nt nt town town area area and and Wuz Wuz hen hen a n aci nent cient town town area area . . Table 5. Similarities and di erences of the Nanyang ancient town area and Wuzhen ancient town area. Nanyang Ancient Town Wuzhen Ancient Town Nanyang Ancient Town Wuzhen Ancient Town Nanyang Ancient Town Area Wuzhen Ancient Town Area Area Area Area Area Location o Location o f f Location of Grand Grand C Grand C anal anal Canal in the town Current Current Current situation in the town in the town sisi tutu ation ation Similarities Grand C Grand C Grand anal Canal anal runs runs runs thth thr roro ugh t ough ugh t he a the he a ancient nci nci ent ent tow town tow n a ar n a eas rere asas Similar scale SiSi mi mi lar lar sc sc ale ale The streets which have relatively high value are dispersed in the Connectivity Co Co nnec nnec value tivity tivity Th Th e streets e streets ww hich hich have re have re latively hi latively hi gh v gh v alue alue arar e e Similarities town. Similarities Space syntax model value dispersed in the town. value dispersed in the town. Local integration analysis results The relatively highest value is the main tourist street Local value Local Space Space Global integration The streets which have relatively highest value are functionally integrat integrat ion ion Th Th e r e r elel ative ative ly highe ly highe st va st va lue is lue is thth e e ma ma in in toto uri uri st st street street syntax syntax value important. value value model Mean depth value Relatively low model Glob Glob al al analy analy sisi s s Th Th e streets w e streets w hich h hich h ave re ave re latively hi latively hi ghe ghe st value st value arar e e Two scenic areas located on the integration integration One scenic area located on the result result s s fufu nct nct ion ion ally ally imp imp east ort ort side ant. ant. and west side of the west side of the Grand Canal. Current situation value value Grand Canal. Mea Mea n dept n dept h h Developing tourist town Developed tourist town Relatively low Relatively low Two streets connecting Nanyang Two entrances in West Scenic Di erences value value Connectivity value Dam have highest value. area have highest value. One scenic area located on Two scenic areas located One scenic area located on Two scenic areas located Space syntax model Local integration Highest value is main tourist The main street in East Scenic Current the west side of the Grand on the east side and west Current the west side of the Grand on the east side and west analysis results value street. area has highest value. situation Canal. side of the Grand Canal. situation Canal. side of the Grand Canal. A vehicle-way running through Global integration Highest value is main tourist Dev Dev eloping eloping touri touri st to st to wn wn the Dev Dev East eloped to eloped to and West urist urist Scenic tow tow ar n n eas value street. has highest value. Tw Tw o street o street s c s c onn onn ect ect ing ing Tw Tw o ent o ent rara nce nce s i s i n West n West Connectivity Connectivity Relatively low in ancient town The main entrances in East Nanyang Dam have highest Scenic area have highest Mean depth value Nanyang Dam have highest Scenic area have highest area. Scenic area have highest value. value value value. value. value. value. Intelligibility value 0.641 (strong). 0.356 (weak). Local Local Th Th e mai e mai n stre n stre et in E et in E asas t t Highest value is main Highest value is main integrat integrat ion ion Scenic Scenic a a rea h rea h asas h h igig he he st st tourist street. tourist street. Wuzhen is 9. Difference Difference Additionally s s Space Space , two strvalue eets value connecting Nanyang Dam have the value. highest value. value in syntax A vehicle-way running syntax A vehicle-way running Nanyang, and two entrances in West Scenic Area have a relatively high value in Wuzhen. In Nanyang, Glob Glob al al model Highest value is main through the East and model Highest value is main through the East and the highest value is the main tourist strintegrat eet. integrat In ion W ion uzhen, a vehicle-way running through the East and analy analy sisi s s toto uri uri st st street street . . West Sc West Sc enic enic areas areas has has value value West Scenic areas has the highest value. The intelligibility value of Nanyang ancient town area, which is result result s s highest v highest v alue alue . . 0.641 and indicates that the recognizability of the street axis of the block is good. Th Th e mai e mai n ent n ent rara nces nces in i n Mea Mea n dept n dept h h Relative Relative lyly lo lo w in w in ancien ancien t t East Scenic area have East Scenic area have The intelligence value in Nanyang ancient town reflects that it is easy to establish an impression value value toto wn are wn are a.a . highest value. highest value. from the local part to the whole ancient town when tourists are walking in the main streets. On the Int Int ell ell igibi igibi lity lity 0.641 (strong). 0.356 (weak). 0.641 (strong). 0.356 (weak). other hand, in Wuzhen’s ancient town area, the intelligence value is 0.356 as the results show in value value Figure 11. This means that it is not easy to form an overview or cognitive impression for the people who are first-time visitors to the town, which would appear to increase the level of intrigue and enhanced mystery about the town. Buildings 2020, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 16 of 19 Wuzhen is 9. Additionally, two streets connecting Nanyang Dam have the highest value in Nanyang, and two entrances in West Scenic Area have a relatively high value in Wuzhen. In Nanyang, the highest value is the main tourist street. In Wuzhen, a vehicle-way running through the East and West Scenic areas has the highest value. The intelligibility value of Nanyang ancient town area, which is 0.641 and indicates that the recognizability of the street axis of the block is good. The intelligence value in Nanyang ancient town reflects that it is easy to establish an impression from the local part to the whole ancient town when tourists are walking in the main streets. On the other hand, in Wuzhen’s ancient town area, the intelligence value is 0.356 as the results show in Figure 11. This means that it is not easy to form an overview or cognitive impression for the people who are first-time visitors to the town, which would appear to increase the level of intrigue and Buildings 2020, 10, 29 15 of 18 enhanced mystery about the town. Figure 11. Space syntax model analysis result on Wuzhen: intelligibility value. Figure 11. Space syntax model analysis result on Wuzhen: intelligibility value. 4.4. Suggestions for Nanyang and Future Research 4.4. Suggestions for Nanyang and Future Research Sustainable heritage tourism aims to maximize the quality of tourists’ experience and minimize Sustainable heritage tourism aims to maximize the quality of tourists’ experience and minimize their impacts to protect resources for the next generations, and this is what visitor management their impacts to protect resources for the next generations, and this is what visitor management intends to achieve [36]. Jones [37] explored sustainable heritage tourism, and demonstrated the need intends to achieve [36]. Jones [37] explored sustainable heritage tourism, and demonstrated the need for landscape harmonisation to occur. His research reviewed the historical evolution of sustainable for landscape harmonisation to occur. His research reviewed the historical evolution of sustainable heritage landscape. In addition, Jones and Beza [38] proposed that good sustainability citizenship heritage landscape. In addition, Jones and Beza [38] proposed that good sustainability citizenship should depend on heritage tourism’s values and cultural perspectives. Therefore, space syntax should depend on heritage tourism’s values and cultural perspectives. Therefore, space syntax should be considered as a tool to help improve the quality of tourists’ experience of sustainability in should be considered as a tool to help improve the quality of tourists’ experience of sustainability in heritage tourism. heritage tourism. In this research, Beiyi Hutong in Nanyang has the lowest connectivity value and control value In this research, Beiyi Hutong in Nanyang has the lowest connectivity value and control value in the ancient town area, Kaiyang Street has the lowest mean depth value, and Matou Street has the in the ancient town area, Kaiyang Street has the lowest mean depth value, and Matou Street has the lowest local integration value. lowest local integration value. Based on the space syntax analysis results, and combined present situation of the streets, several Based on the space syntax analysis results, and combined present situation of the streets, several suggestions for improving tourists’ spatial cognition in historic districts in Nanyang are proposed in suggestions for improving tourists’ spatial cognition in historic districts in Nanyang are proposed in Table 6. Through a consideration of the road network integration of tourist sites and historic districts, Table 6. Through a consideration of the road network integration of tourist sites and historic districts, the findings suggest a conservative restoration to solve current negative tourist perceptions of Nanyang. the findings suggest a conservative restoration to solve current negative tourist perceptions of For example, if the Beiyi Hutong is rebuilt to raise its connectivity, the visiting time will be extended and Nanyang. For example, if the Beiyi Hutong is rebuilt to raise its connectivity, the visiting time will be the boring feeling of the tourist mentioned above might be diminished; two potential gathering centers extended and the boring feeling of the tourist mentioned above might be diminished; two potential in would also improve integration values of the town so as to prevent the overcrowded situations. gathering centers in would also improve integration values of the town so as to prevent the overcrowded situations. Table 6. Suggestions for improving tourists’ spatial cognition in historic districts in Nanyang. Name Present Situation Suggestions Dead-end road, two key cultural relics are in the Conservatively rebuild and enhance the conserving Beiyi Hutong Hutong. the historic buildings. Strengthen connections between the street and other Kaiyang Street Low spatial compactness. sites. Beiwu Hutong Repeat-visit often happens to tourists in this Hutong. Introducing new and di erent functions. There is no clear main tour destination and gathering Matou Street Raising the distinctive level. center. Kaishan Street There is no significant gathering center. A significant gathering center should be built. Heshen Hutong Tourists hardly visit this Hutong. Replacing the service function. Nearby Zhuangyuan Bridge, this Hutong has the Build a gathering center or increase the number of Songzi Hutong highest pedestrian flow. shops. Buildings 2020, 10, 29 16 of 18 While Nanyang’s overall block structure is clearly more regular than that of Wuzhen, it does not o er the opportunities to reduce intelligibility value, and hence the sense of perceived mystery that Wuzhen evokes on the first impression. The opportunities of applying VGA at a micro-scale or sub-block level, may allow designers to help establish a more intimate sequence of spaces at Nanyang between the Hutong and the Grand Canal, and the western sub-blocks between the Hutong and the lake. 5. Conclusions This paper presents on-going research that attempts to explore the potential of correlating space syntax analysis with an environmental psychology approach to help facilitate sustainable heritage tourism. The space syntax analysis approach to improve tourists’ spatial cognition in historic districts constructs a connection between urban tourism and urban space morphology. The proposed method is applied to the Nanyang ancient canal town, where a part of the streets needs to be rebuilt and conserved. Based on the analysis results, suggestions were provided to help improve tourists’ spatial cognition and encourage sustainable heritage tourism in this historic district. While the spatial experience-applied space syntax method is still being investigated, it would appear that preliminary correlations between spatial variables and the perceived experience of tourists may not only be pertinent to the current issues in Nanyang, but could also be applicable to a large number of historic towns throughout the world. However, limitations still exist in this research. Because space syntax in light of structuralism can accurately describe the spatial characteristics in an axial diagram model, but there are diculties in measuring three-dimensional urban space, this becomes an important issue to be considered in the application of the space syntax model. There may be some deviations in the spatial analysis. In addition, an analysis of tourists’ spatial cognition based on a questionnaire or interview research will be conducted to verify the analysis results of the proposed method. Future research will develop a questionnaire that will attempt to correlate key questions relating to tourists’ experience of the towns with the spatial variables in space syntax. Hence, this study will be carried out from both objective and subjective perspectives: the objective perspective of the research is using space syntactic analysis; the subjective perspective is using ethnographic research methods such as interviews, questionnaires, cognitive maps and indicator analysis, along with other subjective evaluation methods, to extract the indicators of tourist spatial cognition. This study will combine subjective and objective perspectives to explore the tourists’ spatial cognition of the Grand Canal towns. It will make original contributions to sustainable heritage tourism. Author Contributions: Conceptualization, Y.X. and J.R.; methodology, Y.X. and J.R.; software, Y.X.; validation, Y.X., J.R. and D.S.J.; investigation, Y.X., Q.M., H.T.; writing—original draft preparation, Y.X., J.R. and D.S.J.; writing—review and editing, Y.X., J.R., and D.S.J.; supervision, Y.X., J.R., D.S.J., and Y.E.; project administration, J.R. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript. Funding: This research received no external funding. Acknowledgments: The authors thank the support from Deakin University to conduct this research. Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest References 1. Turner, A. From axial to road-centre lines: A new representation for space syntax and a new model of route choice for transport network analysis. Environ. Plan. B Plan. Design 2007, 34, 539–555. [CrossRef] 2. Jiang, B. A Space Syntax Approach to Spatial Cognition in Urban Environments. In Position paper for NSF-funded research workshop Cognitive Models of Dynamic Phenomena and Their Representations; University of Pitts-burgh: Pittsburgh, PA, USA, 1998. 3. Turner, A.; Friedrich, E.; Varoudis, T.; Sailer, C.; Koutsolampros, P. depthmapX, 0.6.0; depthmapX development team: University College London, 2017. Available online: https://github.com/SpaceGroupUCL/depthmapX/ (accessed on 12 July 2019). Buildings 2020, 10, 29 17 of 18 4. Mishra, S.A.; Pandit, R.K. Space syntax spproach for analyzing crime preventive urban design: Concept review. J. Adv. Res. Constr. Urban Archit. 2016, 1, 30–35. 5. Heyman, A.; Manum, B. Distance, accessibilities and attractiveness; urban form correlates of willingness to pay for dwellings examined by space syntax based measurements in GIS. J. Space Syntax. 2016, 6, 213–224. 6. Li, X.; Lv, Z.; Zheng, Z.; Zhong, C.; Hijazi, I.H.; Cheng, S. Assessment of lively street network based on geographic information system and space syntax. Multimed. Tools Appl. 2017, 76, 17801–17819. [CrossRef] 7. Shahbazi, M.; Bemanian, M.R.; Lotfi, A. A comparative analysis of spatial configuration in designing residential houses using space dyntax method (Case Studies: Houses of isfahan and modern architecture styles). Int. J. Appl. Arts Stud. (IJAPAS) 2018, 3. Available online: http://www.ijapas.com/index.php/ijapas/ article/view/190 (accessed on 10 November 2019). 8. Gi ord, R. Environmental Psychology: Principles and Practice, 5th ed.; Optimal books: Colville, WA, USA, 2014. 9. Duan, J.; Hillier, B.; Shao, S.; Dai, X. Space Syntax and Urban Planning; Southeast University: Nanjing, China, 2007; pp. 38–46. 10. Hillier, B. Space is the Machine: A Configurational Theory of Architecture; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1996. 11. Duan, J.; Hillier, B. Urban. Space 3: Space Syntax and Urban. Planning; Southeast University Press: Nanjing, China, 2007. 12. Turner, A.; Penn, A.; Hillier, B. An algorithmic definition of the axial map. Environ. Plan. B Plan. Des. 2005, 32, 425–444. [CrossRef] 13. Rahman, J.I.; Ismail, H.N.; Wai, C.L. Inquiry into Tourists’ Movement Flow Pattern in the Melaka World Heritage Site: A Space Syntactic Analysis; APSA Congress, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia: Johor, Malaysia, 2011. 14. Turner, A.; Doxa, M.; O’sullivan, D.; Penn, A. From isovists to visibility graphs: A methodology for the analysis of architectural space. Environ. Plan. B Plan. Des. 2001, 28, 103–121. [CrossRef] 15. Shokouhi, M. Legible Cities: The Role of Visual Clues and Pathway Configuration in Legibility of Cities. In Proceedings of the 4th International Space Syntax Symposium, London, UK, 17–19 June 2013. 16. Tao, Y. Digital City and Space Syntax: A Digital Planning Approach. Planners 2012, 28, 24–29. 17. Koohsari, M.J.; Sugiyama, T.; Mavoa, S.; Villanueva, K.; Badland, H.; Giles-Corti, B.; Owen, N. Street network measures and adults’ walking for transport: Application of space syntax. Health Place 2016, 38, 89–95. [CrossRef] 18. Li, Y.; Xiao, L.; Ye, Y.; Xu, W.; Law, A. Understanding tourist space at a historic site through space syntax analysis: The case of Gulangyu, China. Tour. Manag. 2016, 52, 30–43. [CrossRef] 19. Kubat, A.; Rab, S.; Guney, Y.I.; Ozer, O.; Kaya, S. Application of Space Syntax in Developings: A Regeneration Framework for Sharjah’s Heritage Area. In Proceedings of the 8th International Space Syntax Symposium, Santiago, Chile, 3–6 January 2012. 20. Sheng, Q.; Zhou, C.; Karimi, K.; Lu, A.; Shao, M. The application of space syntax modeling in data-based urban desian: An example of Chaoyang square renewal in Jilin city. Landsc. Archit. Front. 2018, 6, 102–114. [CrossRef] 21. Lynch, K. The Image of the City; MIT press: Cambridge, MA, USA, 1960; Volume 11. 22. Montello, D.R. The Contribution of Space Syntax to a Comprehensive Theory of Environmental Psychology. In Proceedings of the 6th International Space Syntax Symposium, Istanbul, Turkey, 12–15 June 2007; Available online: http://www.spacesyntaxistanbul.itu.edu.tr/papers/invitedpapers/daniel_montello.pdf (accessed on 7 June 2019). 23. Rollo, J.; Barker, S. Perceptions of Place-evaluating experiential qualities of streetscapes. In Proceedings of the SOAC 2013 6th State of Australian Cities Conference, Sydney, Australia, 26–29 November 2013; pp. 1–11. 24. Hillier, B. Studying cities to learn about minds: Some possible implications of space syntax for spatial cognition. Environ. Plan. B Plan. Des. 2012, 39, 12–32. [CrossRef] 25. Burgess, N. Spatial cognition and the brain. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 2008, 1124, 77–97. [CrossRef] 26. Yearbook, C.S. Beijing: National Bureau of Statistics of China; China Statistics Press: Beijing, China, 2015. 27. Sun, J. Construction of industrial heritage corridor in the Jiangnan section of Beijing-Hangzhou Grand Canal. World Cult. 2000, 9, 21–23. 28. Cheung, S.W. Construction of the grand canal and improvement in transportation in late imperial china. Asian Soc. Sci. 2008, 4, 11–22. [CrossRef] Buildings 2020, 10, 29 18 of 18 29. Sun, B. Spatial development along Beijing-Hangzhou Grand Canal: A case study of Yangzhou section. Archit. Herit. China 2013, 10, 19–26. 30. Li, J.; Duan, J. Multi-scale representation of urban spatial morphology based on GIS and spatial syntax. J. Cent. China Norm. Univ. Nat. Sci. 2004, 38, 383–387. 31. Berghauser Pont, M.; Stavroulaki, G.; Marcus, L. Development of urban types based on network centrality, built density and their impact on pedestrian movement. Environ. Plan. B Urban Anal. City Sci. 2019, 46, 1549–1564. [CrossRef] 32. Lin, C.-H.; Morais, D.B.; Kerstetter, D.L.; Hou, J.-S. Examining the role of cognitive and a ective image in predicting choice across natural, developed, and theme-park destinations. J. Travel Res. 2007, 46, 183–194. [CrossRef] 33. Usui, H. Statistical distribution of building lot depth: Theoretical and empirical investigation of downtown districts in Tokyo. Environ. Plan. B Urban. Anal. City Sci. 2019, 46, 1499–1516. [CrossRef] 34. Noyman, A.; Doorley, R.; Xiong, Z.; Alonso, L.; Grignard, A.; Larson, K. Reversed urbanism: Inferring urban performance through behavioral patterns in temporal telecom data. Environ. Plan. B Urban Anal. City Sci. 2019, 46, 1480–1498. [CrossRef] 35. Kaplan, S. Perception and landscape: conceptions and misconceptions. In Proceedings of the our National landscape: A Conference on Applied Techniques for Analysis and Management of the Visual Resource, Incline Village, NV, USA, 23–25 April 1979. 36. Alazaizeh, M. Sustainable Heritage Tourism: A Tourist-Oriented Approach for Managing Petra Archaeological Park, Jordan. Ph.D. Thesis, School of Clemson University, Clemson, SC, USA, 2014. 37. Jones, D. Evolution and significance of the regeneration reserve heritage landscape of Broken Hill: History, values and significance. Hist. Environ. 2016, 28, 40–57. 38. Jones, D.; Beza, B.B. An Indigenous perspective on sustainability citizenship. In Sustainability Citizenship and Cities: Theory and Practice; Horne, R., Fien, J., Beza, B., Nelson, A., Eds.; Routledge: Abingdon, UK, 2016; pp. 150–162. © 2020 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Journal
Buildings – Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute
Published: Feb 14, 2020