Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Valuing green building certificates as real options

Valuing green building certificates as real options Purpose – The purpose of this study is first to evaluate whether real options analysis (ROA) is suitable for valuing green building certificates, and second to calculate the real option value of a green certificate in a typical office building setting. Green buildings are demonstrated as one of the most profitable climate mitigation actions. However, no consensus exists among industry professionals about how green buildings and specifically green building certificates should be valued. Design/methodology/approach – The research design of the study involves a theoretical part and an empirical part. In the theoretical part, option characteristics of green building certificates are identified and a contemporary real option valuation method is proposed for application. In the empirical part, the application is demonstrated in an embedded multiple case study design. Two different building cases (with and without green certificate) with eight independent cash flow valuations by eight industry professionals are used as data set for eight valuation case studies and analyses. Additionally, cross‐case analysis is executed for strengthening the analysis. Findings – The paper finds that green certificates have several characteristics similar to real options and supports the idea of using ROA in valuing a green certificate. The paper also explains how option pricing theory and discounted cash flow (DCF) method deal with uncertainty and what shortcomings of DCF could be overcome by ROA. The results show that a mean real option value of €985,000 (or 8.8 per cent premium to the mean property value) was found for a Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design Platinum certificate in the Finnish property market. The main finding of the paper suggests that the contemporary real option valuation methods are appropriate to assess the monetary value and the uncertainty of a green building certificate. Originality/value – This is the first study to argue that option‐pricing theory can be used for valuing green building certificates. The identification of the option characteristics of green building certificates and demonstration of the ROA in an empirical case makes questions whether the current mainstream investment analysis approaches are the most suitable methods for valuing green building certificates. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of European Real Estate Research Emerald Publishing

Valuing green building certificates as real options

Jussi Vimpari
Journal of European Real Estate Research , Volume 7 (2): 18 – Jul 29, 2014
Download PDF
18 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/valuing-green-building-certificates-as-real-options-PqowdpVvRq
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © 2014 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
ISSN
1753-9269
DOI
10.1108/JERER-06-2013-0012
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Purpose – The purpose of this study is first to evaluate whether real options analysis (ROA) is suitable for valuing green building certificates, and second to calculate the real option value of a green certificate in a typical office building setting. Green buildings are demonstrated as one of the most profitable climate mitigation actions. However, no consensus exists among industry professionals about how green buildings and specifically green building certificates should be valued. Design/methodology/approach – The research design of the study involves a theoretical part and an empirical part. In the theoretical part, option characteristics of green building certificates are identified and a contemporary real option valuation method is proposed for application. In the empirical part, the application is demonstrated in an embedded multiple case study design. Two different building cases (with and without green certificate) with eight independent cash flow valuations by eight industry professionals are used as data set for eight valuation case studies and analyses. Additionally, cross‐case analysis is executed for strengthening the analysis. Findings – The paper finds that green certificates have several characteristics similar to real options and supports the idea of using ROA in valuing a green certificate. The paper also explains how option pricing theory and discounted cash flow (DCF) method deal with uncertainty and what shortcomings of DCF could be overcome by ROA. The results show that a mean real option value of €985,000 (or 8.8 per cent premium to the mean property value) was found for a Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design Platinum certificate in the Finnish property market. The main finding of the paper suggests that the contemporary real option valuation methods are appropriate to assess the monetary value and the uncertainty of a green building certificate. Originality/value – This is the first study to argue that option‐pricing theory can be used for valuing green building certificates. The identification of the option characteristics of green building certificates and demonstration of the ROA in an empirical case makes questions whether the current mainstream investment analysis approaches are the most suitable methods for valuing green building certificates.

Journal

Journal of European Real Estate Research – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jul 29, 2014

Keywords: Uncertainty; Investment valuation; Green building certificate; Real options analysis (ROA)

References

  • Real Options: Managing Strategic Investment in an Uncertain World
    Amram, M.; Kulatilaka, N.
  • Valuation of flexible leases for corporate tenants facing uncertainty in their required workspace
    Ashuri, B.
  • The pricing of options and corporate liabilities
    Black, F.; Scholes, M.
  • Irreversible investment, real options, and competition: evidence from real estate development
    Bulan, L.; Mayer, C.; Somerville, C.T.
  • Risk, Uncertainty and Decision‐Making in Property Development
    Byrne, P.; Cadman, D.
  • On possibilistic mean value and variance of fuzzy numbers
    Carlsson, C.; Fullér, R.
  • Supply, Demand, and the Value of Green Buildings
    Chegut, A.; Eichholtz, P.; Kok, N.
  • Real option premium in Hong Kong land prices
    Chiang, Y.H.; So, C.K.; Yeung, C.S.
  • Mixed uses and the redevelopment option
    Childs, P.D.; Riddiough, T.J.; Triantis, A.J.
  • Empirical estimation of the option premium for residential development
    Clapp, J.M.; Bardos, K.S.; Wong, S.K.
  • The Pay‐off Method: Re‐inventing Investment Analysis: With Numerical Application Examples from Different Industries
    Collan, M.
  • A fuzzy pay‐off method for real option valuation
    Collan, M.; Fullér, R.; Mezei, J.
  • Investment Valuation – Tools and Techniques for Determining the Value of Any Asset
    Damodaran, A.
  • European real options: an intuitive algorithm for the black‐scholes formula
    Datar, V.; Mathews, S.
  • A practical method for valuing real options: the Boeing approach
    Datar, V.; Mathews, S.
  • Real options by spreadsheet: parking garage case example
    de Neufville, R.; Scholtes, S.; Wang, T.
  • The markets for real estate assets and space: a conceptual framework
    DiPasquale, D.; Wheaton, W.
  • The options approach to capital investment
    Dixit, A.; Pindyck, S.
  • Theory building from cases: opportunities and challenges
    Eisenhardt, K.; Graebner, M.
  • A real options approach to valuing strategic flexibility in uncertain construction project
    Ford, D.N.; Lander, D.M.; Voyer, J.
  • The uncertainty of valuation
    French, N.; Gabrielli, L.
  • Discounted cash flow: accounting for uncertainty
    French, N.; Gabrielli, L.
  • Green noise or green value? Measuring the price effects of environmental certification in commercial buildings
    Fuerst, F.; McAllister, P.
  • New evidence on the green building rent and price premium
    Fuerst, F.; McAllister, P.
  • An investigation of the effect of eco‐labeling on office occupancy rates
    Fuerst, F.; McAllister, P.
  • Uncertainty, flexibility, valuation & design: how 21st century information and knowledge can improve 21st century urban development
    Geltner, D.; de Neufville, R.
  • A real options model for valuing flexible space
    Greden, L.V.; Glicksman, L.R.
  • Management of technology investment risk with real options‐based design: a case study of an innovative building technology
    Greden, L.; de Neufville, R.; Glicksman, L.
  • Investment in technological innovations: an option pricing approach
    Grenadier, S.; Weiss, A.M.
  • Managing our way to economic decline
    Hayes, R.; Abernathy, W.
  • Managing as if tomorrow mattered
    Hayes, R.; Garvin, D.
  • Options, futures, and other derivatives
    Hull, J.
  • Green Building Costs and Financial Benefits
    Kats, G.
  • Case studies on real options
    Kemna, A.
  • Today’s options for tomorrow’s growth
    Kester, W.C.
  • Property valuation in the Nordic countries
    KTI and IPD
  • cost optimal and nearly zero (nzeb) energy performance calculations for residential buildings with rehva definition for nzeb national implementation
    Kurnitski, J.; Saari, A.; Kalamees, T.; Vuolle, M.; Niemelä, J.; Tark, T.
  • Sale before completion of development: pricing and strategy
    Lai, R.N.; Wang, K.; Zhou, Y.
  • Challenges to the practical implementation of modeling and valuing real options
    Lander, D.; Pinches, G.
  • Costing Green: A Comprehensive Cost Database and Budgeting Methodology
    Matthiessen, L.F.; Morris, P. (2004), in; Langdon, ; D.
  • Finance theory and financial strategy
    Myers, S.C.
  • A critique of using real options pricing models in valuing real estate project and contracts
    Oppenheimer, P.
  • A review of the practical uses of real property options
    Patel, K.; Paxson, D.; Sing, T.F.
  • Investment returns from responsible property investments: energy efficient, transit‐oriented and Urban regeneration office properties in the US from 1998‐2007
    Pivo, G.; Fisher, J.
  • Empirical testing of real option‐pricing models
    Quigg, L.
  • Sustainable building certification and the rent premium: a panel data approach
    Reichardt, A.; Fuerst, F.; Rottke, N.B.; Zietz, J.
  • Justifying sustainable buildings – championing green operations
    Roper, K.; Beard, J.
  • Modern Methods of Valuation
    Shapiro, E.; Mackmin, D.; Sams, G.
  • Valuing leasing risk in commercial property with a discrete‐time binomialtree option model
    Sing, T.; Tang, W.
  • Urban land prices under uncertainty
    Titman, S.
  • A Conceptual options framework for capital budgeting
    Trigeorgis, L.
  • A real options application in natural resource investments
    Trigeorgis, L.
  • Real Option: Managerial Flexibility and Strategy in Resource Allocation
    Trigeorgis, L.
  • Valuing managerial flexibility
    Trigeorgis, L.; Mason, S.P.
  • US Green Building Council
    USGBC
  • Uncertainty, real option valuation, and policies toward a sustainable built environment
    Van Der Maaten, E.
  • Value influencing mechanism of green certificates in the discounted cash flow valuation
    Vimpari, J.; Junnila, S.
  • Case Study Research: Design and Methods
    Yin, R.K.
  • Fuzzy sets
    Zadeh, L.A.