Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Underpinning theories: order‐of‐use in information systems research

Underpinning theories: order‐of‐use in information systems research Purpose – The paper was intended to demonstrate the use and order of a combined lenses of two theories in IS research. It helps to understand how theories could be adopted in the order of methodological value. The way data are collected, organised and analysed is influenced and shaped by the order of use of the underpinning theories. The importance of the order is to create consistency, predictability, and uniformity of analysis, which have impact on the findings. Design/methodology/approach – Review of literature, and teaching and supervision experiences were used in the approach. Findings – The result of a combined use of both ST and ANT in the same study has been less than expected. The application of theories helps exhume findings. This makes the order‐of‐use of application of the theories significant. Some studies applied ST before ANT, and vice versa. There has never been a model or framework which defines the order‐of‐use of the theories. It could be argued that it depend on the nature and objectives of the study. This paper focuses on order‐of‐use of combined theories in information systems studies. No organisation has total power to determine what the choice(s) of an actor will be in a particular situation. Actor and structure by virtue of their interaction recursively produces and reproduces, on the one hand and on another, the actor and structure enable and at the same time there are constraints. Originality/value – Both theories can be used as a way of thinking and speaking about the phenomena being studied and also, as a “lens” through which the data is viewed and interpreted. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Systems and Information Technology Emerald Publishing

Underpinning theories: order‐of‐use in information systems research

Tiko Iyamu
Journal of Systems and Information Technology , Volume 15 (3): 15 – Aug 9, 2013
Download PDF
15 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/underpinning-theories-order-of-use-in-information-systems-research-UGnDKFNhpP
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © 2013 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
ISSN
1328-7265
DOI
10.1108/JSIT-11-2012-0064
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Purpose – The paper was intended to demonstrate the use and order of a combined lenses of two theories in IS research. It helps to understand how theories could be adopted in the order of methodological value. The way data are collected, organised and analysed is influenced and shaped by the order of use of the underpinning theories. The importance of the order is to create consistency, predictability, and uniformity of analysis, which have impact on the findings. Design/methodology/approach – Review of literature, and teaching and supervision experiences were used in the approach. Findings – The result of a combined use of both ST and ANT in the same study has been less than expected. The application of theories helps exhume findings. This makes the order‐of‐use of application of the theories significant. Some studies applied ST before ANT, and vice versa. There has never been a model or framework which defines the order‐of‐use of the theories. It could be argued that it depend on the nature and objectives of the study. This paper focuses on order‐of‐use of combined theories in information systems studies. No organisation has total power to determine what the choice(s) of an actor will be in a particular situation. Actor and structure by virtue of their interaction recursively produces and reproduces, on the one hand and on another, the actor and structure enable and at the same time there are constraints. Originality/value – Both theories can be used as a way of thinking and speaking about the phenomena being studied and also, as a “lens” through which the data is viewed and interpreted.

Journal

Journal of Systems and Information Technology – Emerald Publishing

Published: Aug 9, 2013

Keywords: Information systems; Structuration theory; Actor network theory; Underpinning theory

References

  • The description of technical objects
    Akrich, M.
  • StructuANTion: a theoretical framework for integrating human and IS research and development
    Atkinson, C.; Brooks, L.
  • Technology as an occasion for structuring: evidence from observations of CT scanners and the social order of radiology departments
    Barley, S.R.
  • Empirical research in information systems: the practice of relevance
    Benbasat, I.; Zmud, R.W.
  • Visions of organization and organizations of vision
    Bloomfield, B.; Vurdubakis, T.
  • From work to activity: technology and the narrative of progress
    Boland, R.J.; Schultze, U.
  • How things (actor‐net) work: classification, magic and the ubiquity of standards
    Bowker, G.; Star, S.
  • Structurantion in research and practice: representing actor networks, their structurated orders and translations
    Brooks, L.; Atkinson, C.
  • Some elements of the sociology of translation: domestication of the scallops and the fisherman of St Brieuc Bay
    Callon, M.
  • Techno‐economic networks and irreversibility
    Callon, M.
  • On the construction of sociotechnical networks: content and context revisited
    Callon, M.; Law, J.
  • The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of Structuration
    Giddens, A.
  • Special issue on relevance
  • Developing information infrastructure: the tension between standardization and flexibility
    Hanseth, O.; Monteiro, E.
  • Geographic information technologies, structuration theory, and the world trade center crisis
    Harrison, T.; Pardo, T.; Gil‐Garcia, J.; Thompson, F.; Juraga, D.
  • Organization Theory: Modern, Symbolic, and Postmodern Perspectives
    Hatch, M.J.
  • Components of the computing environment
    Iyamu, T.; Obe, O.
  • The use of structuration and actor network theory for analysis: a case study of a financial institution in South Africa
    Iyamu, T.; Roode, D.
  • Situated action, structuration and actor‐network theory: an integrative theoretical perspective
    Johnston, R.
  • On the rhetoric and relevance of IS research paradigms: a conceptual framework and some propositions
    Khazanchi, D.; Munkvold, B.E.
  • Structuration theory and conception‐reality gaps: addressing cause and effect of implementation outcomes in health care information systems
    Kouroubali, A.
  • Technology is society made durable
    Latour, B.
  • Social theory and the study of computerised work sites
    Latour, B.
  • Notes on the theory of the actor‐network: ordering, strategy, and heterogeneity
    Law, J.
  • Rigor and relevance in MIS research: beyond the approach of positivism alone
    Lee, A.S.
  • Enhancing the design of e‐government: identifying structures and modelling concepts in contemporary platforms
    Meneklis, V.; Douligeris, C.
  • Social shaping of information infrastructure: on being specific about the technology
    Monteiro, E.; Hanseth, O.
  • A process oriented framework for assessing the business value of information technology
    Mooney, G.H.; Gurbaxani, V.; Kraemer, L.K.
  • The duality of technology: rethinking the concept of technology in organizations
    Orlikowski, W.
  • Technological frames: making sense of information technology in organisations
    Orlikowski, W.; Gash, D.
  • Information technology and the structuring of organizations
    Orlikowski, W.; Robey, D.
  • Structuration theory in the IS field: an assessment of research strategies
    Pozzebon, M.; Pinsonneault, A.
  • The problem of human agency in organizational analysis
    Reed, M.
  • Actor‐network theory and information systems research
    Tatnall, A.; Gilding, A.
  • Black‐boxes, non‐human stakeholders and the translation of IT through mediation
    Vidgen, R.; McMaster, T.
  • Actor network theory and IS research: current status and future prospects
    Walsham, G.
  • Structuration theory and information systems research
    Walsham, G.; Han, C.K.
  • GIS for district‐level administration in India: problems and opportunities
    Walsham, G.; Sahay, S.
  • Information systems strategy and implementation: a case study of a building society
    Walsham, G.; Waema, T.
  • An actor‐network approach to leading technological change: implementing a new technology at a prominent US research university
    Warzynski, C.