Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

The population brain versus the population's brains: how entrepreneurs confound population planning

The population brain versus the population's brains: how entrepreneurs confound population planning The purpose of this paper is to examine the full opportunity cost of population policies by contrasting standard models of optimal population, which consider individuals to be homogeneous laborers, with a view that considers individuals' capacity for entrepreneurship. This paper therefore examines this relationship between population and economic growth with entrepreneurship considered.Design/methodology/approachThe paper draws on James Buchanan's dichotomy of the organismic theory of government finance vs the individualistic theory and applies this dichotomy to population planning. This framework reveals entrepreneurial capacity is only compatible with the open-ended individualistic view. Lastly, the paper utilizes considers the number of potential entrepreneurs lost to China's one child policy and considers the case of Jack Ma as a concrete example of the potential opportunity cost of policies which seek to curb population growth.FindingsThe analysis shows it is impossible for either natural scientists or economists to determine a welfare-enhancing population policy. Creative and entrepreneurial individuals contribute to the economy in ways not captured by standard models. The implication is policies seeking to curb population growth may inhibit economic growth by reducing potential entrepreneurs. Politicians cannot measure the opportunity cost of forgone entrepreneurs, and therefore the costs of such policies are unseen.Originality/valueWhile economists have examined the potential gains from creativity, this contribution is unique in that it highlights the inherent open-endedness involved in entrepreneurship means the opportunity cost of a forgone individual cannot be know because market conditions created by entrepreneurs do not exist absent the entrepreneurs. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Enterpreneurship and Public Policy Emerald Publishing

The population brain versus the population's brains: how entrepreneurs confound population planning

Jacobsen, Peter
Journal of Enterpreneurship and Public Policy , Volume 11 (4): 15 – Dec 12, 2022
Download PDF
15 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/the-population-brain-versus-the-population-s-brains-how-entrepreneurs-tNH8UaknJf
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
2045-2101
DOI
10.1108/jepp-05-2022-0061
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to examine the full opportunity cost of population policies by contrasting standard models of optimal population, which consider individuals to be homogeneous laborers, with a view that considers individuals' capacity for entrepreneurship. This paper therefore examines this relationship between population and economic growth with entrepreneurship considered.Design/methodology/approachThe paper draws on James Buchanan's dichotomy of the organismic theory of government finance vs the individualistic theory and applies this dichotomy to population planning. This framework reveals entrepreneurial capacity is only compatible with the open-ended individualistic view. Lastly, the paper utilizes considers the number of potential entrepreneurs lost to China's one child policy and considers the case of Jack Ma as a concrete example of the potential opportunity cost of policies which seek to curb population growth.FindingsThe analysis shows it is impossible for either natural scientists or economists to determine a welfare-enhancing population policy. Creative and entrepreneurial individuals contribute to the economy in ways not captured by standard models. The implication is policies seeking to curb population growth may inhibit economic growth by reducing potential entrepreneurs. Politicians cannot measure the opportunity cost of forgone entrepreneurs, and therefore the costs of such policies are unseen.Originality/valueWhile economists have examined the potential gains from creativity, this contribution is unique in that it highlights the inherent open-endedness involved in entrepreneurship means the opportunity cost of a forgone individual cannot be know because market conditions created by entrepreneurs do not exist absent the entrepreneurs.

Journal

Journal of Enterpreneurship and Public Policy – Emerald Publishing

Published: Dec 12, 2022

Keywords: Economic growth; Entrepreneurship; Public policy; Environmental economics; Population; Market process

References

  • Information costs, pricing and resource unemployment
    Alchian, A.A.
  • Form 20-F 2019
  • Capital as embodied knowledge: some implications for the theory of economic growth
    Baetjer, H.
  • Fertility choice in a model of economic growth
    Barro, R.J.; Becker, G.A.
  • Population growth: disaster or blessing?
    Bauer, P.T.
  • Entrepreneurship: productive, unproductive, and destructive
    Baumol, W.J.
  • A reformulation of the economic theory of fertility
    Becker, G.S.; Barro, R.J.
  • Entrepreneurship and development: cause or consequence?
    Boettke, P.J.; Coyne, C.J.
  • Calculation of a population externality
    Bohn, H.; Stuart, C.
  • The pure theory of government finance: a suggested approach
    Buchanan, J.M.
  • The market as a creative process
    Buchanan, J.M.; Vanberg, V.J.
  • China's below‐replacement fertility: government policy or socioeconomic development?
    Cai, Y.
  • Calculation and corporate tax incentives
    Candela, R.A.; Jacobsen, P.J.
  • Economic calculation and transaction costs: the case of the airline oversales auction system
    Candela, R.A.; Jacobsen, P.J.; Reeves, K.
  • Optimum growth in an aggregative model of capital accumulation
    Cass, D.
  • State-provided defense as non-comprehensive planning
    Coyne, C.J.; Hall, A.R.
  • The plight of underdeveloped countries
    Coyne, C.J.; Leeson, P.T.
  • The political economy of state-provided targeted benefits
    Coyne, C.J.; Moberg, L.
  • On the concept of optimum population
    Dasgupta, P.S.
  • How to cure cancer: unbinding entrepreneurs in medicine
    Diamond, A.M.
  • The overlooked costs of the permanent war economy: a market process approach
    Duncan, T.K.; Coyne, C.J.
  • Population, policy, and politics: how will history judge China's one-child policy?
    Feng, W.; Cai, Y.; Gu, B.
  • Is demography just a numerical exercise? Numbers, politics, and legacies of China's one-child policy
    Feng, W.; Cai, Y.; Shen, K.; Gietel-Basten, S.
  • Assessing the impact of the ‘one-child policy’ in China: a synthetic control approach
    Gietel-Basten, S.; Han, X.; Cheng, Y.
  • Estimates of averted Chinese births, 1971-1990: comparisons of fertility decline, family planning policy, and development in six Confucian societies
    Goodkind, D.
  • The astonishing population averted by China's birth restrictions: estimates, nightmares, and reprogrammed ambitions
    Goodkind, D.
  • If science had come first: a billion person fable for the ages (A reply to comments)
    Goodkind, D.
  • Formal comment on ‘assessing the impact of the ‘one-child policy’ in China: a synthetic control approach’
    Goodkind, D.
  • Stock pollution, child-bearing externalities, and the social discount rate
    Harford, J.D.
  • Advancing economic analysis beyond the equilibrium framework
    Holcombe, R.G.
  • Jack Ma steps down as Alibaba's Chairman. Here are key moments in the company's history
    Kharpal, A.
  • Creativity and/or alertness: a reconsideration of the Schumpeterian entrepreneur
    Kirzner, I.M.
  • The alert and creative entrepreneur: a clarification
    Kirzner, I.M.
  • Optimal population and exhaustible resource constraints
    Lawson, N.; Spears, D.
  • Visions of entrepreneurship policy
    Lucas, D.S.; Fuller, C.S.; Piano, E.E.; Coyne, C.J.
  • State development planning: did it create an east Asian miracle?
    Powell, B.
  • A model for value-added e-market provisioning: case study from Alibaba.com
    Qing, H.
  • A mathematical theory of saving
    Ramsey, F.P.
  • World scientists’ warning of a climate emergency
    Ripple, W.J.; Wolf, C.; Newsome, T.M.; Barnard, P.; Moomaw, W.R.
  • Endogenous technological change
    Romer, P.M.
  • Robinson Crusoe was not mainly a resource allocator
    Simon, J.L.
  • What can aid do?
    Skarbek, D.B.; Leeson, P.T.
  • Leveraging digital business ecosystems for enterprise agility: the tri-logic development strategy of Alibaba.com
    Tan, B.; Pan, S.L.; Lu, X.; Huang, L.
  • The role of IS capabilities in the development of multi-sided platforms: the digital ecosystem strategy of Alibaba.com
    Tan, B.; Pan, S.L.; Lu, X.; Huang, L.
  • Challenging myths about China's one-child policy
    Whyte, M.K.; Feng, W.; Cai, Y.