Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

The Knack of Selling: scientific salesmanship, relational themes and military metaphors in early marketing thought

The Knack of Selling: scientific salesmanship, relational themes and military metaphors in early... The purpose of this paper is to provide an historical analysis of an important early contribution to the history of marketing thought literature – the six-book series titled The Knack of Selling – which was published in 1913 and intended as an early training course for salesmanship.Design/methodology/approachThis research utilized a close, systematic reading of The Knack of Selling series and places it in the professional and intellectual context of the early twentieth century. Books published about marketing are primary source materials for any study of the history of marketing thought. In this case, The Knack series constitutes significant primary source material for a study of early thinking about personal selling.FindingsEchoing A.W. Shaw, Watson offers a more sophisticated interpretation of the “one best way” approach associated with Frederick Taylor. Watson’s advice did not entail the repetition of canned sales talks to each customer. His vision of practice was more complicated. Sales presentations were temporally and locationally relative. They were subject to ongoing evolution. As the marketplace changed, as customer needs and interests shifted, so did organizational and salesperson performances. To keep sales talks relevant to the consumer, personnel were encouraged to undertake rudimentary ethnographic research and interviews. Unusually, there is oscillation in the way power relations between marketer and customer were described. While relational themes are present, so are military metaphors.Originality/valueThis is the first systematic reading of The Knack of Selling that has been produced. It is an important contribution to the literature inasmuch as this book set is not in wide circulation. The material itself was significant as an input into scholarship subsequently hailed as seminal within sales management. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Historical Research in Marketing Emerald Publishing

The Knack of Selling: scientific salesmanship, relational themes and military metaphors in early marketing thought

Download PDF
24 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/the-knack-of-selling-scientific-salesmanship-relational-themes-and-5getG9SU2c
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
1755-750X
DOI
10.1108/jhrm-10-2019-0035
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to provide an historical analysis of an important early contribution to the history of marketing thought literature – the six-book series titled The Knack of Selling – which was published in 1913 and intended as an early training course for salesmanship.Design/methodology/approachThis research utilized a close, systematic reading of The Knack of Selling series and places it in the professional and intellectual context of the early twentieth century. Books published about marketing are primary source materials for any study of the history of marketing thought. In this case, The Knack series constitutes significant primary source material for a study of early thinking about personal selling.FindingsEchoing A.W. Shaw, Watson offers a more sophisticated interpretation of the “one best way” approach associated with Frederick Taylor. Watson’s advice did not entail the repetition of canned sales talks to each customer. His vision of practice was more complicated. Sales presentations were temporally and locationally relative. They were subject to ongoing evolution. As the marketplace changed, as customer needs and interests shifted, so did organizational and salesperson performances. To keep sales talks relevant to the consumer, personnel were encouraged to undertake rudimentary ethnographic research and interviews. Unusually, there is oscillation in the way power relations between marketer and customer were described. While relational themes are present, so are military metaphors.Originality/valueThis is the first systematic reading of The Knack of Selling that has been produced. It is an important contribution to the literature inasmuch as this book set is not in wide circulation. The material itself was significant as an input into scholarship subsequently hailed as seminal within sales management.

Journal

Journal of Historical Research in Marketing – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jul 7, 2020

Keywords: Marketing; Marketing Theory; Sales; Salesmanship; Power

References

  • The market and the housewife
    Andrews, B.R.
  • Sales management and prosperity
    Bader, L.
  • A study of the management of the farm home
    Bailey, I.
  • Clothes and the body
    Baker, C.G.
  • A triumph of scientific housekeeping
    Barrows, S.T.
  • As prophets are your salesmen a loss?
    Barton, B.
  • A time-study in dishwashing
    Carruth, E.K.
  • A revaluation of business motives and their relations to selling and advertising
    Cherington, P.T.
  • Standardizing the home
    Commons, J.R.
  • Buying motives for industrial goods
    Copeland, M.T.
  • Tendencies in sales management: a consideration of the influence of the scientific management attitude of mind on selling and advertising
    Cowan, S.
  • Driving forces in the sales plan: illustrating the importance of building a sales plan around some central driving force
    Cowan, S.D.
  • Toward a new concept of sales management
    Dawson, L.M.
  • How snapple got its juice back
    Deighton, J.D.
  • Establishing the scope of marketing practice: insights from practitioners
    Dibb, S.; Simões, C.
  • A feminist poststructuralist analysis of the rhetoric of marketing relationships
    Fischer, E.; Bristor, J.
  • Points in efficiency
    Frederick, C.
  • John H. Patterson and the sales strategy of the national cash register company, 1884-1922
    Friedman, W.A.
  • And how does it look in America?’: H.F.J. Kropff’s Historic Report on US marketing
    Fullerton, R.A.
  • Historical methodology: the perspective of a professionally trained historian turned marketer
    Fullerton, R.A.
  • We are all customers now…’ rhetorical strategy and ideological control in marketing management texts
    Hackley, C.
  • The evolution of marketing research technique
    Haring, A.
  • The myth of the marketing revolution
    Jones, D.G.B.; Richardson, A.J.
  • Forces impinging on long-term business-to-business relationships in the United States: an historical perspective
    Keep, W.W.; Hollander, S.C.; Dickinson, R.
  • Principles of management applied to scientific management
    Keeley, R.R.
  • The marketing revolution
    Keith, R.J.
  • Marketing practices used by the emerging American public library system from inception to 1930
    Kleindl, B.
  • The psychology of advertising, 1896-1916
    Kuna, D.P.
  • Notes on the history of marketing research
    Lockley, L.C.
  • Salesmanship: rule-of-thumb science – part two
    Maxwell, W.
  • An empirical method of analyzing a sales interview
    McKinney, F.
  • The evolution of the seven steps of selling
    Moncrief, W.C.; Marshall, G.W.
  • A good beginning in the principles of advertising
    Newcomb, A.
  • Relational marketing: development, debates and directions
    O’Malley, L.
  • Vocational tests for retail saleswomen
    Oschrin, E.A.B.
  • Selling from 1900-1959: a historical perspective
    Powers, T.L.; Koehler, W.F.; Martin, W.S.
  • Instructive inspection
    Richards, E.H.
  • Machines made of words: the influence of engineering metaphor on marketing thought and practice, 1900-1929
    Scully, J.I.
  • The handling of salesmen
    Searles, P.W.
  • System in selling
    Selz, J.H.
  • Scientific management’ in business
    Shaw, A.W.
  • Behavioral principles in salesmanship courses
    Shaw, S.
  • The personal selling process: a critical review and model
    Spiro, R.L.; Perreault, W.D.; Reynolds, F.D.
  • The work of the visiting housekeeper
    Stern, F.
  • Theories of selling
    Strong, E.K.
  • American sales management practice and thought: developments to World War II
    Strong, J.T.; d’Amico, M.F.
  • The Knack of Selling
  • Remembering motivation research: toward an alternative genealogy of interpretive consumer research
    Tadajewski, M.
  • Relationship marketing at wanamaker’s in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries
    Tadajewski, M.
  • The foundations of relationship marketing: reciprocity and trade relations
    Tadajewski, M.
  • Correspondence sales education in the early twentieth century: the case of the sheldon school (1902-39)
    Tadajewski, M.
  • Focus groups: history, epistemology and non-individualistic consumer research
    Tadajewski, M.
  • Habit as a central concept in marketing
    Tadajewski, M.
  • The discourses of marketing and development: towards ‘critical transformative marketing research
    Tadajewski, M.; Chelekis, J.; Deberry-Spence, B.; Figueiredo, B.; Kravets, O.; Nuttavuthisit, K.; Peñaloza, L.; Moisander, J.
  • Scientific marketing management and the emergence of the ethical marketing concept
    Tadajewski, M.; Jones, D.G.B.
  • Hyper-power, the marketing concept and consumer as ‘boss
    Tadajewski, M.; Jones, D.G.B.
  • Rethinking the emergence of relationship marketing
    Tadajewski, M.; Saren, M.
  • Reciprocity – The Aimesbury Company
  • The human factor in marketing
    Tosdal, H.R.
  • Topics for marketing research
    White, W.L.
  • Qualitative historical research in marketing
    Witkowski, T.; Jones, D.G.B.; Belk, R.W.
  • Preface
    Zimmerman, W.S.; Watson, H.