Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Studying caste and occupational mobility in India: questioning “positionality” in ethnographic research

Studying caste and occupational mobility in India: questioning “positionality” in ethnographic... The purpose of this paper is to discuss the challenges the author had encountered and the counter-strategies she had adopted to overcome them while conducting ethnography for the first time during her doctoral research. In this paper, the author hopes to provide guidance for future researchers by discussing the role she played in her research, the experiences she gained as a result of it, the difficulties she faced and the strategies she employed to overcome these difficulties.Design/methodology/approachFollowing the social constructionist perspective, this paper analyses the experience that the author had gained during her field study. As a novice researcher, the author entered the field to study the relationship between caste and occupational mobility. The caste that she had selected was the Kansari caste to which the author belongs. Therefore, her position as a researcher while conducting ethnography became a crucial part of the methodological challenges the author faced. While insider ethnography has its advantages and disadvantages, this paper does not discuss these aspects of the methodology. Instead, it discusses how, as a novice researcher, the author had to negotiate her position as an insider and outsider.FindingsWhile analysing her experience as a novice researcher, the author found that her journey of conducting insider ethnography was of rediscovering herself as a Kansari as well as a researcher. Through this research, the author found that as an insider ethnographer, certain strategies had to be adopted in the field by the researcher to be objective and unbiased throughout the research process. For example, whenever the author conducted an interview, she tried to try to say less, listen more and be as objective as possible, without allowing her preconceptions to influence the information she gathered from the field.Originality/valueThis is an original paper based on the primary data collected by the author. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Qualitative Research Journal Emerald Publishing

Studying caste and occupational mobility in India: questioning “positionality” in ethnographic research

Sahoo, Barsa Priyadarsinee
Qualitative Research Journal , Volume 23 (1): 12 – Jan 4, 2023
Download PDF
12 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/studying-caste-and-occupational-mobility-in-india-questioning-St2YOeoKku
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
1443-9883
DOI
10.1108/qrj-04-2022-0059
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to discuss the challenges the author had encountered and the counter-strategies she had adopted to overcome them while conducting ethnography for the first time during her doctoral research. In this paper, the author hopes to provide guidance for future researchers by discussing the role she played in her research, the experiences she gained as a result of it, the difficulties she faced and the strategies she employed to overcome these difficulties.Design/methodology/approachFollowing the social constructionist perspective, this paper analyses the experience that the author had gained during her field study. As a novice researcher, the author entered the field to study the relationship between caste and occupational mobility. The caste that she had selected was the Kansari caste to which the author belongs. Therefore, her position as a researcher while conducting ethnography became a crucial part of the methodological challenges the author faced. While insider ethnography has its advantages and disadvantages, this paper does not discuss these aspects of the methodology. Instead, it discusses how, as a novice researcher, the author had to negotiate her position as an insider and outsider.FindingsWhile analysing her experience as a novice researcher, the author found that her journey of conducting insider ethnography was of rediscovering herself as a Kansari as well as a researcher. Through this research, the author found that as an insider ethnographer, certain strategies had to be adopted in the field by the researcher to be objective and unbiased throughout the research process. For example, whenever the author conducted an interview, she tried to try to say less, listen more and be as objective as possible, without allowing her preconceptions to influence the information she gathered from the field.Originality/valueThis is an original paper based on the primary data collected by the author.

Journal

Qualitative Research Journal – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jan 4, 2023

Keywords: Sociology; Ethnography; Methodology; Qualitative research; Insider ethnography; Interview; Social mobility; Outsider

References

  • Not in my backyard but in my front room: a review of insider ethnography
    Aarnikoivu, M.
  • Methodology for close up studies-struggling with closeness and closure
    Alvesson, M.
  • To fairly tell social mobility, life histories and anthropologist
    Benei, V.
  • Crafting Objects, crafting affinities, crafting selves: narratives of home and craft from Telangana India
    Bose, C.
  • Conceptualizing from the inside: advantages, complications, and demands on insider positionality
    Charvez, C.
  • The past we were a bit ‘Chamar': education as a self- and community engineering process in Northern India
    Ciotti, M.
  • An insider/outsider team approach in research with migrant farmworker women
    Clingerman, E.
  • Learning from the outsider within: the sociological significance of black feminist thought
    Collins, P.
  • Occupational mobility: how much does caste matter
    Despande, R.; Palshikar, S.
  • Caste and occupational structure in Central India
    Driver, E.D.
  • Occupational changes among Hindu temple servants
    Freeman, J.
  • The politics of location: doing feminist research at home
    Gilbert, M.R.
  • On the inside looking in: methodological insights and challenges in conducting qualitative insider research
    Greene, M.J.
  • The Insider/outsider dilemma of ethnography: working with young children and their families in cross-cultural contexts
    Gregory, E.; Ruby, M.
  • The reality of anthropology
    Hastrup, K.
  • Managing qualitative research as insider-research in small rural communities
    Heslop, C.; Burns, S.; Lobo, R.
  • Wait a second. Who are you anyway? The insider/outsider debate and American Indian Studies
    Innes, R.A.
  • Occupational mobility among urban bhangis
    Lal, S.
  • Insiders and outsiders: a Chapter in the Sociology of knowledge
    Merton, R.K.
  • Social mobility trends in an Andhra Village: a study in occupational change
    Mohan, U.
  • Tradition and change: artisan producers in Gujarat
    Parthasarathy, R.
  • Insider Ethnography: tinker, tailor, researcher, or spy?
    Simmons, M.
  • Prison Research: challenges in securing permission and data collection
    Sivakumar, V.
  • Reflexivity, positionality and participatory ethics: negotiating fieldwork dilemmas in international research
    Sultana, F.
  • Editorial: medical anthropology at home: creating distance
    Van Dongen, E.; Fainzang, S.
  • Navigating multipositionality in ‘insider’ ethnography
    Vernooij, E.