Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Revisiting the concept of competitive advantage Problems and fallacies arising from its conceptualization

Revisiting the concept of competitive advantage Problems and fallacies arising from its... Purpose – Although competitive advantage is the cornerstone concept in strategic management it still remains a poorly defined and operationalized construct. The purpose of this paper is to revisit the concept of competitive advantage, to identify the problems that stem from its current conceptualization from the majority of the literature. Design/methodology/approach – The paper undertakes an extensive literature review, audit of logical inference, syllogistic reasoning and Bayesian expressions in order to examine the problems associated with the current conceptualizations of competitive advantage. Findings – Several drawbacks and fallacies relating to current conceptualizations of competitive advantage were identified that create an urgent need for a more robust definition which could better serve the needs of both empirical research and management practice. Research limitations/implications – The authors by no means claim that the literature review undertaken in this paper on the concept of competitive advantage and on the problems derived from its conceptualization was exhaustive or absolute. Rather, this paper constitutes an attempt to stimulate efforts and provide directions on the further conceptual development of competitive advantage. Practical implications – The findings allow practising managers to not necessarily associate competitive advantage with its sources and with the determinants of superior performance. Originality/value – The findings contribute to the evolution of the strategic management field by identifying, categorizing and mapping potential problems, drawbacks and fallacies, associated with the conceptualization of competitive advantage as currently delineated in the literature, and by suggesting some criteria for the development of a conceptually more robust definition. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Strategy and Management Emerald Publishing

Revisiting the concept of competitive advantage Problems and fallacies arising from its conceptualization

Download PDF
20 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/revisiting-the-concept-of-competitive-advantage-problems-and-fallacies-wFoKETHIqO
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © 2013 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
ISSN
1755-425X
DOI
10.1108/17554251311296567
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Purpose – Although competitive advantage is the cornerstone concept in strategic management it still remains a poorly defined and operationalized construct. The purpose of this paper is to revisit the concept of competitive advantage, to identify the problems that stem from its current conceptualization from the majority of the literature. Design/methodology/approach – The paper undertakes an extensive literature review, audit of logical inference, syllogistic reasoning and Bayesian expressions in order to examine the problems associated with the current conceptualizations of competitive advantage. Findings – Several drawbacks and fallacies relating to current conceptualizations of competitive advantage were identified that create an urgent need for a more robust definition which could better serve the needs of both empirical research and management practice. Research limitations/implications – The authors by no means claim that the literature review undertaken in this paper on the concept of competitive advantage and on the problems derived from its conceptualization was exhaustive or absolute. Rather, this paper constitutes an attempt to stimulate efforts and provide directions on the further conceptual development of competitive advantage. Practical implications – The findings allow practising managers to not necessarily associate competitive advantage with its sources and with the determinants of superior performance. Originality/value – The findings contribute to the evolution of the strategic management field by identifying, categorizing and mapping potential problems, drawbacks and fallacies, associated with the conceptualization of competitive advantage as currently delineated in the literature, and by suggesting some criteria for the development of a conceptually more robust definition.

Journal

Journal of Strategy and Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: Feb 15, 2013

Keywords: Competitive advantage; Strategic management; Superior performance; Conceptualization of competitive advantage; Definitional problem; Tautology problem; Dependent variable problem

References

  • Corporate Strategy
    Ansoff, H.I.
  • Revisiting the logical and research considerations of competitive advantage
    Arend, R.J.
  • Patterns of sustained performance: beginnings, paths and ends
    Arend, R.J.
  • Persistent superior economic performance, sustainable competitive advantage, and Schumpeterian innovation: leading established computer firms, 1954‐2000
    Baaij, M.; Greevena, M.; Dalen, J.V.
  • Barriers to New Competition
    Bain, J.S.
  • Industrial Organization
    Bain, J.S.
  • Organizational culture: can it be a source of sustainable competitive advantage?
    Barney, J.B.
  • Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage
    Barney, J.B.
  • Gaining and Sustaining Competitive Advantage
    Barney, J.B.
  • Is the resource‐based ‘view’ a useful perspective for strategic management research? Yes
    Barney, J.B.
  • Organizational economics: understanding the relationship between organizations and economic analysis
    Barney, J.B.; Hesterly, W.
  • The Economics of Strategy
    Besanko, D.; Dranove, D.; Shanley, M.
  • Economics of Strategy
    Besanko, D.; Dranove, D.; Shanley, M.
  • Stakeholders, reciprocity and firm performance
    Bosse, D.A.; Phillips, R.A.; Harrison, J.S.
  • From entry barriers to mobility barriers: conjectural decisions and contrived deterrence to new competition
    Caves, R.E.; Porter, M.E.
  • Appropriability, preemption, and firm performance
    Ceccagnoli, M.
  • When competitive advantage doesn’t lead to performance: the resource‐based view and stakeholder bargaining power
    Coff, R.W.
  • Competencies and imitability in the pharmaceutical industry: an analysis of their relationship with firm performance
    De Carolis, D.M.
  • Media reputation as a strategic resource: an integration of mass communication and resource‐based theories
    Deephouse, D.L.
  • Asset stock accumulation and sustainability of competitive advantage
    Dierickx, I.; Cool, K.
  • Competitive advantages exist: a critique of Powell
    Durand, R.
  • Causation, counterfactuals and competitive advantage
    Durand, R.; Vaara, E.
  • Dynamic capabilities: what are they?
    Eisenhardt, K.M.; Martin, J.A.
  • The resource‐based tangle: towards a sustainable explanation of competitive advantage
    Foss, N.J.; Knudsen, T.
  • An exploration of common ground: integrating evolutionary and strategic theories of the firm
    Foss, N.J.; Knudsen, C.; Montgomery, C.A.
  • Commitment: The Dynamic of Strategy
    Ghemawat, P.
  • Creating competitive advantage
    Ghemawat, P.; Rivkin, J.
  • The problem of unobservables in strategic management research
    Godfrey, P.C.; Hill, C.W.L.
  • Competitive advantage and performance: the impact of value creation and costliness of imitation
    Grahovac, J.; Miller, D.J.
  • Contemporary Strategy Analysis
    Grant, R.
  • Direct and moderating effects of human capital on strategy and performance in professional service firms: a resource‐based perspective
    Hitt, M.A.; Bierman, L.; Shimizu, K.; Kochhar, R.
  • Modern Marketing Theory: Critical Issues in the Philosophy of Marketing Science
    Hunt, S.D.
  • Foundations of Behavioral Research
    Kerlinger, F.N.; Lee, H.B.
  • The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
    Kuhn, T.S.
  • Uncertain imitability: an analysis of interfirm differences in efficiency under competition
    Lippman, S.; Rumelt, R.
  • Competitive advantage and firm performance
    Ma, H.
  • Causes and conditions
    Mackie, J.L.
  • Cross talk: strategy and management: Constantinos Markides discusses strategic innovation, an interview by Peter Mang
    Markides, C.
  • Price and production policies of large‐scale enterprise
    Mason, E.S.
  • What is strategy's distinctive competence?
    Meyer, A.D.
  • Organizational Strategy, Structure, and Process
    Miles, R.E.; Snow, C.C.
  • Predicting rent generation in competence‐based competition
    Mosakowski, E.; McKelvey, B.
  • Empirical research on the resource based view of the firm: an assessment and suggestions for future research
    Newbert, S.L.
  • Value, rareness, competitive advantage, and performance: a conceptual‐level empirical investigation of the resource‐based view of the firm
    Newbert, S.L.
  • Sustainable competitive advantage or temporary competitive advantage: improving understanding of an important strategy construct
    O'Shannassy, T.
  • Modern Competitive Analysis
    Oster, S.M.
  • The cornerstones of competitive advantage: a resource‐based view
    Peteraf, M.A.
  • Unraveling the resource based tangle
    Peteraf, M.A.; Barney, J.B.
  • The Logic of Scientific Discovery
    Popper, K.R.
  • Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors
    Porter, M.E.
  • Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance
    Porter, M.E.
  • Competitive advantage: logical and philosophical considerations
    Powell, T.C.
  • The philosophy of strategy
    Powell, T.C.
  • Information technology as competitive advantage: the role of human, business, and technology resources
    Powell, T.C.; Dent‐Micallef, A.
  • Is the resource‐based ‘view’ a useful perspective for strategic management research?
    Priem, R.L.; Butler, J.E.
  • Tautology in the resource‐based view and the implications of externally determined resource value: further comments
    Priem, R.L.; Butler, J.E.
  • Product innovation, product‐market competition, and persistent profitability in the US pharmaceutical industry
    Roberts, P.
  • Fundamental Issues in Strategy
    Rumelt, R.; Schendel, D.; Teece, D.
  • What in the world is competitive advantage?
    Rumelt, R.P.
  • Strategy, complexity and economic rent
    Schoemaker, P.J.H.
  • A resource‐based view of manufacturing strategy and the relationship to manufacturing performance
    Schroeder, R.G.; Bates, K.A.; Junttila, M.A.
  • Searching for a new paradigm in competitive strategy: the use of financial statements in mapping strategy
    Sigalas, C.; Pekka Economou, V.
  • Competitive advantage: the cornerstone of strategic thinking
    South, S.E.
  • Competing on capabilities: the new rules of corporate strategy
    Stalk, G.; Evans, P.; Shulman, L.E.
  • Does firm performance reveal its own causes? The role of Bayesian Inference
    Tang, Y.C.; Liou, F.M.
  • Dynamic capabilities and strategic management
    Teece, D.J.; Pisano, G.; Shuen, A.
  • The economics of strategic planning: a survey of the issues
    Thomas, L.G.
  • Construct measurement in organizational strategy research
    Venkatraman, N.; Grant, J.H.
  • A resource‐based view of the firm
    Wernerfelt, B.
  • Competitive advantage: temporal dynamics and the incidence and persistence of superior economic performance
    Wiggins, R.R.; Ruefli, T.W.
  • Knowledge and competence as strategic assets
    Winter, S.G.
  • Four Rs of profitability: rents, resources, routines and replication
    Winter, S.G.
  • Sources of capabilities, integration and technology commercialization
    Zahra, S.A.; Nielsen, A.P.
  • E‐commerce metrics for net‐enhanced organizations: assessing the value of e‐commerce to firm performance in the manufacturing sector
    Zhu, K.; Kraemer, K.L.
  • The fit between product market strategy and business model: implications for firm performance
    Zott, C.; Amit, R.