Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Patenting as a competitive tactic in multipoint competition

Patenting as a competitive tactic in multipoint competition Purpose – The paper's aim is to build a model that predicts the optimum tactics for capitalizing on inventions within the context of competitive interaction among large firms. For patenting, the paper seeks to show how invention value and firm rivalry drive the tactics of competing, deterring competitors, retreating from markets, and cooperating. It also aims to explore the effects of the contingencies of patent bulking, technology complexity, spheres of influence, resource similarity, and complementary‐resource tacitness. Design/methodology/approach – The work is conceptual. Findings – The base model shows that patenting can be used to protect markets where there is high invention‐value and high rivalry. When both invention‐value and rivalry are low, the best tactic is to cooperate. When value is high and rivalry low, patenting can be used as a signaling and deterring mechanism, but when value is low and rivalry is high the best option is to let patents lapse and retreat from markets. The moderating effects of patent bulking, technology complexity, spheres of influence, resource similarity, and complementary‐resource tacitness affect rivalry and the amount of patenting that will be done. Research limitations/implications – The paper provides propositions for empirical testing that are predictive of firm performance, rivalry, and patent bulking. Despite the authors' attention to key contingencies, it is impossible to be completely comprehensive in addressing all contingencies. Practical implications – The framework provides tactics for competing and, consequently, maximizing income and minimizing costs. Originality/value – The work synthesizes extant thinking on patents and multipoint competition. While the base model should be valuable for managers, the overall work should be valuable for academics. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Strategy and Management Emerald Publishing

Patenting as a competitive tactic in multipoint competition

Download PDF
19 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/patenting-as-a-competitive-tactic-in-multipoint-competition-PzDilECcQR
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © 2011 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
ISSN
1755-425X
DOI
10.1108/17554251111181016
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Purpose – The paper's aim is to build a model that predicts the optimum tactics for capitalizing on inventions within the context of competitive interaction among large firms. For patenting, the paper seeks to show how invention value and firm rivalry drive the tactics of competing, deterring competitors, retreating from markets, and cooperating. It also aims to explore the effects of the contingencies of patent bulking, technology complexity, spheres of influence, resource similarity, and complementary‐resource tacitness. Design/methodology/approach – The work is conceptual. Findings – The base model shows that patenting can be used to protect markets where there is high invention‐value and high rivalry. When both invention‐value and rivalry are low, the best tactic is to cooperate. When value is high and rivalry low, patenting can be used as a signaling and deterring mechanism, but when value is low and rivalry is high the best option is to let patents lapse and retreat from markets. The moderating effects of patent bulking, technology complexity, spheres of influence, resource similarity, and complementary‐resource tacitness affect rivalry and the amount of patenting that will be done. Research limitations/implications – The paper provides propositions for empirical testing that are predictive of firm performance, rivalry, and patent bulking. Despite the authors' attention to key contingencies, it is impossible to be completely comprehensive in addressing all contingencies. Practical implications – The framework provides tactics for competing and, consequently, maximizing income and minimizing costs. Originality/value – The work synthesizes extant thinking on patents and multipoint competition. While the base model should be valuable for managers, the overall work should be valuable for academics.

Journal

Journal of Strategy and Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: Oct 25, 2011

Keywords: Patents; Multipoint competition; Patent thickets; Patent fences; Spheres of influence; Resource similarity; Innovation; Competitive strategy

References

  • Innovation Management: Strategies, Implementation, and Profits
    Afuah, A.
  • An empirical test of the mutual forbearance hypothesis: the case of bank holding companies
    Alexander, D.L.
  • Competitive intensity and collaboration: impact on firm growth across technological environments
    Ang, S.H.
  • Patents, invalidity, and the strategic transmission of enabling information
    Anton, J.J.; Yao, D.A.
  • Innovative clusters and the industry life cycle
    Audretsch, D.B.; Feldman, M.P.
  • The value of giving away secrets
    Bar‐Gill, O.; Parchomovsky, G.
  • Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage
    Barney, J.B.
  • Competitive dynamics of interfirm rivalry
    Baum, J.A.C.; Korn, H.J.
  • Dynamics of dyadic competitive interaction
    Baum, J.A.C.; Korn, H.J.
  • Multimarket contact and collusive behavior
    Bernheim, B.D.; Whinston, M.D.
  • Financial returns and strategic interaction: the case of instant photography
    Bettis, R.; Weeks, D.
  • Order of entry as a moderator of the effect of marketing mix on market share
    Bowman, D.; Gatignon, H.
  • Performance implications of delayed competitive responses: evidence from the US retail industry
    Boyd, J.L.; Bresser, R.K.F.
  • Multimarket oligopoly: strategic substitutes and complements
    Bulow, J.I.; Geanakoplos, J.D.; Klemperer, P.D.
  • Toward a strategic theory of risk premium: moving beyond the CAPM
    Chatterjee, S.; Lubatkin, M.H.; Schulze, W.S.
  • Competitor analysis and interfirm rivalry: toward a theoretical integration
    Chen, M‐J.
  • Competitive attack, retaliation and performance: an expectancy‐valence framework
    Chen, M‐J.; Miller, D.
  • Action characteristics as predictors of competitive response
    Chen, M‐J.; Smith, K.G.; Grimm, C.M.
  • Latecomer strategies: evidence from the semiconductor industry in Japan and Korea
    Cho, D‐S.; Kim, D‐J.; Rhee, D.K.
  • Dynamic R&D competition under ‘hazard rate’ uncertainty
    Choi, J.P.
  • ‘Keep out’ signs: the role of deterrence in the competition for resources
    Clarkson, G.; Toh, P.K.
  • Protecting their intellectual assets: appropriability conditions and why us manufacturing firms patent (or not)
    Cohen, W.M.; Nelson, R.R.; Walsh, J.P.
  • Service Management: The Automation of Services
    Collier, D.A.
  • Competitive pressure systems: mapping and managing multimarket contact
    D'Aveni, R.A.
  • Entry order and pricing over the product cycle: the transition from the 486 to the Pentium processor
    Deltas, G.; Zacharias, E.
  • Rethinking the prospect theory of patents
    Duffy, J.F.
  • Economist knowledge monopolies: patent wars
    Economist
  • Technological diversity and Jacobs' externality hypothesis revisited
    Ejermo, O.
  • Living by the ‘golden rule’: multimarket contact in the US airline industry
    Evans, W.N.; Kessides, I.N.
  • Navigating the competitive landscape: the drivers and consequences of competitive aggressiveness
    Ferrier, W.J.
  • Strategic aggressiveness, variation, and surprise: how the sequential pattern of competitive rivalry influences stock market returns
    Ferrier, W.J.; Lee, H.
  • The role of competitive action in market share erosion and industry dethronement: a study of industry leaders and challengers
    Ferrier, W.; Smith, K.G.; Grimm, C.
  • The market for patents in Europe
    Gambardella, A.; Giuri, P.; Luzzi, A.
  • Reciprocal threats in multimarket rivalry: staking out ‘spheres of influence’ in the US airline industry
    Gimeno, J.
  • The performance effects of unintended and multimarket contact
    Gimeno, J.
  • Hypercompetition in a multimarket environment: the role of strategic similarity and multimarket contact in competitive de‐escalation
    Gimeno, J.; Woo, C.N.
  • Multimarket contact, economies of scope, and firm performance
    Gimeno, J.; Woo, C.N.
  • Cooperation versus competition in product innovation
    Gonzalez‐Maestra, M.; Penarrubia, D.
  • Patent law and rent dissipation; commentaries
    Grady, M.F.; Alexander, J.I.; Martin, D.L.; Merges, R.P.
  • Can post‐grant reviews improve patent system design? A twin study of US and European patents
    Graham, S.J.H.; Harhoff, D.
  • Multimarket contact and sales growth: evidence from insurance
    Greve, H.R.
  • Managing intellectual capital: licensing and cross‐licensing in semiconductors and electronics
    Grindley, P.C.; Teece, D.J.
  • The strategic analysis of intangible resources
    Hall, R.
  • Profiting from voluntary information spillovers: how users benefit by freely revealing their innovations
    Harhoff, D.; Henkel, J.; von Hippel, E.
  • Multimarket independence and local market competition in banking
    Heggestad, A.A.; Rhoades, S.A.
  • Diversification, multimarket contact and profitability
    Hughes, K.; Oughton, C.
  • The theory of multimarket competition: a synthesis and implications for marketing strategy
    Jayachandran, S.; Gimeno, J.; Varadarajan, P.R.
  • Product introduction with network externalities
    Katz, M.; Shapiro, C.
  • Firm size and capabilities, regional agglomeration, and the adoption of new technology
    Kelly, M.; Hageman, A.
  • Accounting for the recent surge in US patenting: changes in R&D expenditures, patent yields, and the high tech sector
    Kim, J.; Marschke, G.
  • Chance, imitative, and strategic antecedents to multimarket contact
    Korn, H.J.; Baum, J.A.
  • Appropriating the returns from industrial research and development
    Levin, R.C.; Klevorick, A.K.; Nelson, R.R.; Winter, S.G.
  • The effect of within industry diversification on firm performance: synergy creation, multimarket contact and market saturation
    Li, X.L.; Greenwood, R.
  • Dropout behavior in R&D races with learning
    Lippman, S.A.; McCardle, K.F.
  • Patent signals
    Long, C.
  • Profiting from technological innovation by others: the effect of competitor patenting on firm value
    McGahan, A.M.; Silverman, B.S.
  • Multimarket maneuvering in uncertain spheres of influence: resource diversion strategies
    McGrath, R.; Chen, M‐J.; MacMillan, I.C.
  • Global gamesmanship
    MacMillan, I.C.; van Putten, A.B.; McGrath, R.
  • Patents and product development strategies: a model of antecedents and consequences of patent value
    Malewicki, D.; Sivakumar, K.
  • How rapidly does new industrial technology leak out?
    Mansfield, E.
  • Patents and innovation: an empirical study
    Mansfield, E.
  • Imitation costs and patents: an empirical study
    Mansfield, E.; Schwartz, M.; Wagner, S.
  • The linked oligopoly concept: recent evidence from banking
    Martinez, J.E.
  • Multimarket contact between savings and loan
    Mester, L.J.
  • The simplicity of competitive repertoires
    Miller, D.; Chen, M‐J.
  • How do patents influence innovation? Evidence from nineteenth‐century World's Fair
    Moser, P.
  • An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change
    Nelson, R.; Winter, S.
  • Global strategic linkages and industry structure
    Nohria, N.; Garcia‐Pont, C.
  • The patent epidemic
    Orey, M.
  • Collusive conduct in duopolies: multimarket contact and cross ownership in the mobile telephone industry
    Parker, P.M.; Roller, L‐H.
  • Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors
    Porter, M.E.
  • Signaling strategies in competitive interaction: building reputations and hiding truth
    Prabhu, J.; Stewart, D.W.
  • Causal ambiguity, barriers to imitation, and sustainable competitive advantage
    Reed, R.; DeFillippi, R.J.
  • Multimarket interdependence and performance in banking: two tests
    Rhoades, S.A.; Heggestad, A.A.
  • New product announcement signals and incumbent reactions
    Robertson, T.S.; Eliasburg, J.; Rymon, T.
  • Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy
    Schumpeter, J.A.
  • Multimarket contact and economic performance
    Scott, J.T.
  • Late mover advantage: how innovative late entrants outsell pioneers
    Shankar, V.; Carpenter, G.S.; Krishnamurthi, L.
  • Navigating the patent thicket: cross licenses, patent pools, and standard‐setting
    Shapiro, C.
  • Competing through innovation in network markets: strategies for challengers
    Sheremata, W.A.
  • Strategic determinants of decisions not to settle patent litigations
    Somaya, D.
  • Profiting from technological innovation: implications for integration, collaboration, licensing and public policy
    Teece, D.J.
  • US patent statistics chart: calendar years 1963‐2006
    US Patent and Trademark Office
  • Strategic choice and performance in late movers: influence of the top management team's external ties
    Yoo, J‐W.; Reed, R.; Shin, S‐J.
  • Multimarket contact and resource dissimilarity: a competitive dynamics perspective
    Young, G.; Smith, K.G.; Grimm, C.M.; Simon, D.
  • Don't fence me in: fragmented markets for technology and the patent acquisition strategies of firms
    Ziedonis, R.H.