Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

McGregor's legacy: thoughts on what he left, what transpired, and what remains to pursue

McGregor's legacy: thoughts on what he left, what transpired, and what remains to pursue Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to advance that a significant part of McGregor's legacy was from considering human behavior as important to organizational life and management, and to step outside thinking of the time to incorporate social science research and thinking. While others have followed his lead, the idea of looking beyond those fields for useful frameworks for additional insights – as he did by incorporating psychology – has been largely overlooked. This paper seeks to propose such an approach as adding to the breadth and depth of organizational/managerial understanding. Design/methodology/approach – There is no methodology, per se , other than reading. The approach is to trace highlights of McGregor's thinking, influences on him and by him, and to introduce fields of thought that can further those aims of better informing the “human” side. Findings – Spiral dynamics (SDi) and finite and infinite games provide well developed frameworks for better understanding “human” aspects of organized behavior both socially, and in the management and research of organizational behavior. Considering them is also in line with McGregor's legacy of stepping outside traditional management theory to inform his thinking and arguments. Research limitations/implications – There has not been research on Finite dynamics, but there is documentation of work done with SDi. The implications of each include better understanding of culture components of organized behavior, especially in a global environment, comparing results of already occurring phenomena (e.g. mergers) in light of the ideas proposed. A key limitation is creating and using further operational measures for some studies. Practical implications – The practical implications are significant in terms of offering new ways to better analyze, understand, and act on socially (“human“) based factors that address issues within and across cultures. These include guidelines for balancing interests of corporations with national/global economies, post merger behavior, identifying other factors that affect issues of loyalty, commitment, motivation, alignment, etc. as issues of cultural diversity in organizations (especially global ones). Social implications – The first implication is that it takes recognition of dynamics advanced by both approaches for them to have conscious impact. They already conform to events known to have happened. SDi was used repeatedly to improve societal harmony by Mandela in post‐Aparheidt South Africa. Finite and (…) poses hyotheses and distinctions about factors that help explain recent global economic meltdown, and ways to prevent future occurrence. While “business” in nature, the social implications are vast. Originality/value – The originality here lies primarily in thinking outside the boxes that have emulated, evaluated, or expanded on the central thrust of McGregor's thinking. Other than placing finite and infinite games in a management/organizational context, and suggesting some questions for research and practice, the only other original thought was to consider the “meta” legacy of McGregor's example of going outside management thinking to inform what he believed to be valid, rather than stay strictly within the domains of social science and traditional management thinking. All this, of course, in the pursuit of advancing his concern for the human side of enterprise. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Management History Emerald Publishing

McGregor's legacy: thoughts on what he left, what transpired, and what remains to pursue

Arthur Lerner
Journal of Management History , Volume 17 (2): 21 – Apr 12, 2011
Download PDF
21 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/mcgregor-s-legacy-thoughts-on-what-he-left-what-transpired-and-what-UPN0TVeRKL
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © 2011 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
ISSN
1751-1348
DOI
10.1108/17511341111112613
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to advance that a significant part of McGregor's legacy was from considering human behavior as important to organizational life and management, and to step outside thinking of the time to incorporate social science research and thinking. While others have followed his lead, the idea of looking beyond those fields for useful frameworks for additional insights – as he did by incorporating psychology – has been largely overlooked. This paper seeks to propose such an approach as adding to the breadth and depth of organizational/managerial understanding. Design/methodology/approach – There is no methodology, per se , other than reading. The approach is to trace highlights of McGregor's thinking, influences on him and by him, and to introduce fields of thought that can further those aims of better informing the “human” side. Findings – Spiral dynamics (SDi) and finite and infinite games provide well developed frameworks for better understanding “human” aspects of organized behavior both socially, and in the management and research of organizational behavior. Considering them is also in line with McGregor's legacy of stepping outside traditional management theory to inform his thinking and arguments. Research limitations/implications – There has not been research on Finite dynamics, but there is documentation of work done with SDi. The implications of each include better understanding of culture components of organized behavior, especially in a global environment, comparing results of already occurring phenomena (e.g. mergers) in light of the ideas proposed. A key limitation is creating and using further operational measures for some studies. Practical implications – The practical implications are significant in terms of offering new ways to better analyze, understand, and act on socially (“human“) based factors that address issues within and across cultures. These include guidelines for balancing interests of corporations with national/global economies, post merger behavior, identifying other factors that affect issues of loyalty, commitment, motivation, alignment, etc. as issues of cultural diversity in organizations (especially global ones). Social implications – The first implication is that it takes recognition of dynamics advanced by both approaches for them to have conscious impact. They already conform to events known to have happened. SDi was used repeatedly to improve societal harmony by Mandela in post‐Aparheidt South Africa. Finite and (…) poses hyotheses and distinctions about factors that help explain recent global economic meltdown, and ways to prevent future occurrence. While “business” in nature, the social implications are vast. Originality/value – The originality here lies primarily in thinking outside the boxes that have emulated, evaluated, or expanded on the central thrust of McGregor's thinking. Other than placing finite and infinite games in a management/organizational context, and suggesting some questions for research and practice, the only other original thought was to consider the “meta” legacy of McGregor's example of going outside management thinking to inform what he believed to be valid, rather than stay strictly within the domains of social science and traditional management thinking. All this, of course, in the pursuit of advancing his concern for the human side of enterprise.

Journal

Journal of Management History – Emerald Publishing

Published: Apr 12, 2011

Keywords: Motivation (psychology); Social norms; Philosophical concepts; Management history; Organizational culture

References

  • History of division 32 (humanistic psychology) of the American Psychological Association
    Aanstoos, C.; Serlin, I.; Greening, T.
  • How to Solve the Mismanagement Crisis
    Adizes, I.
  • Dialectic of Enlightenment
    Adorno, T.; Horkheimer, M.
  • 2010 ASTD State of the Industry Report
    ASTD
  • Interaction Process Analysis
    Bales, R.
  • Paradigms: The Business of Discovering the Future
    Barker, J.
  • Spiral Dynamics: Mastering Values, Leadership and Change
    Beck, D.; Cowan, C.
  • The Crucible: Forging South Africa's Future
    Beck, D.; Linscott, G.
  • On Becoming a Leader
    Bennis, W.
  • The Managerial Grid: Key Orientations for Achieving Production Through People
    Blake, R.B.; Mouton, J.S.
  • The One Minute Manager
    Blanchard, K.; Johnson, S.
  • The third force in psychology
    Bugental, J.F.T.
  • First, Break All the Rules: What the World's Greatest Managers Do Differently
    Buckingham, M.; Coffman, C.
  • Large Group Interventions: Engaging the Whole System for Rapid Change
    Bunker, B.B.; Alban, B.
  • Finite and Infinite Games
    Carse, J.P.
  • The emergence of transpersonal psychiatry
    Chinen, A.B.
  • The story behind ‘Invictus’: man aided team now onscreen
    Denton Record‐Chronicle
  • Concept of the Corporation
    Drucker, P.F.
  • Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices
    Drucker, P.F.
  • On a heuristic viewpoint concerning the production and transformation of light
    Einstein, A.
  • Cosmological considerations in the general theory of relativity
    Einstein, A.
  • Spiral dynamics in the management of a prison system
    Gibb, B.
  • The Goal
    Goldratt, E.; Cox, J.
  • Social intelligence and the biology of leadership
    Goleman, D.; Boyatzis, R.
  • Management of Organizational Behavior – Utilizing Human Resources
    Hersey, P.; Blanchard, K.H.
  • Iacocca
    Iacocca, L.
  • Leading Change
    Kotter, J.P.
  • The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
    Kuhn, T.
  • Field Theory in Social Science
    Lewin, K.
  • Patterns of aggressive behavior in experimentally created social climates
    Lewin, K.; Lippitt, R.; White, R.K.
  • A technique for the measurement of attitudes
    Likert, R.
  • New Patterns of Management
    Likert, R.
  • The Human Organization: Its Management and Value
    Likert, R.
  • What They Don't Teach You at Harvard Business School
    McCormack, M.
  • John Adams
    McCullough, D.
  • The Human Side of Enterprise
    McGregor, D.
  • The Practical Theorist: The Life and Work of Kurt Lewin
    Marrow, A.J.
  • A theory of human motivation
    Maslow, A.H.
  • Social relations and innovation in the medical profession: the epidemiology of a new drug
    Menzel, H.; Katz, E.
  • Theory Z
    Ouchi, W.G.
  • Search of Excellence: Lessons from Americas Best Run Companies
    Peters, T.J.; Waterman, R.H.
  • The Lonely Crowd: A Study of the Changing American Character
    Riesman, D.; Glazer, N.; Denney, R.
  • Coaching with the Brain in Mind: Foundations for Practice
    Rock, D.; Page, L.
  • The Life of Reason, or the Phases of Human Progress
    Santayana, G.
  • Introduction to The Professional Manager by Douglas McGregor
    Schein, E.
  • Up the Organization How to Stop the Corporation from Stifling People and Strangling Profits
    Townsend, R.
  • Process wisdom for a new age
    Vaill, P.
  • The Organization Man
    Whyte, W.H.
  • Lincoln at Gettysburg: The Words That Remade America
    Wills, G.
  • The Reflexive Universe: Evolution of Consciousness
    Young, A.M.
  • Managers and leaders: are they different?
    Zaleznik, A.