Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

“It's funny I feel much more stigmatized by my own home community”: investigating visually impaired migrants' experiences of unsupportive ethnic community

“It's funny I feel much more stigmatized by my own home community”: investigating visually... Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to present the unreported phenomenon of migrants with sight loss who experience unsupportive behaviour and attitudes from their own ethnic community due to their disability. In presenting specific case studies from a wider PhD study which investigated the previously undocumented experiences of migrants with sight loss in Ireland, the intention is to raise awareness among service providers of the additional vulnerability of this minority group. Design/methodology/approach – Migrants representing diverse ethnicities (Angolan, Algerian Nigerian, Zambian, Polish, Czech Republic, Malaysia Bangladeshi) described their experiences accessing disability services Ireland and discussed comparative attitudes towards disability in their home and host country. Service providers from the national organization working with people with sight loss were interviewed to gain an understanding of their attitudes and views on access and provision for migrants. By adopting a qualitative method following a constructivist grounded theory approach, migrants' own perceptions, beliefs, views and experiences of the sensitive subject of adjusting to sight loss while away from home were prioritised. Analysis of data was facilitated through qualitative software Atlas.ti and three core interrelated categories emerged most prominently: cultural perceptions of disability; support networks; and cultural barriers. The focus for this paper draws most significantly from the second category, support networks, most specifically the impact of absence or withdrawal of support for the migrant at the most vulnerable time of sight loss away from home. Findings – From grounded theory data analysis, three core interrelated categories emerged most prominently. They are: cultural perceptions of disability; support networks; and cultural barriers. This paper focuses most directly from findings related to support networks specifically highlighting two migrant case studies to report the impact of absence or withdrawal of support for migrant at the most vulnerable time of sight loss away from home. Service providers interviewed report inadequate information about migrants with sight loss. Evidence of stigma related to cultural perception of disability in the home community as trigger for discrimination from migrant's own network is reported by service providers. Findings are examined within an interdisciplinary theoretical framework, combining intercultural studies theories with disability models to facilitate a holistic understanding of the migrants' experience. Practical implications – The challenge of coping with disability for a migrant whose ethnic community network is absent, or withdraws its support owing to an individual's disability, have implications for alerting service providers to increased vulnerability of migrant service users. Consequently, this study has implications for programs and policies and can inform the development of culturally sensitive and appropriate services. Social implications – This study raises awareness of the compounded challenge for migrants with sight loss who are unsupported by their own ethnic group while living in a host country. Originality/value – This study reveals the previously unreported case of migrants who experience unsupportive behaviour from their own ethnic community following acquired disability. Evidence from migrants and their service providers demonstrates the impact of cultural perceptions of disability to influence the level of ethnic community support offered. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png International Journal of Migration, Health and Social Care Emerald Publishing

“It's funny I feel much more stigmatized by my own home community”: investigating visually impaired migrants' experiences of unsupportive ethnic community

Download PDF
13 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/it-s-funny-i-feel-much-more-stigmatized-by-my-own-home-community-SiYHVFoqwF
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © 2013 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
ISSN
1747-9894
DOI
10.1108/17479891311318548
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to present the unreported phenomenon of migrants with sight loss who experience unsupportive behaviour and attitudes from their own ethnic community due to their disability. In presenting specific case studies from a wider PhD study which investigated the previously undocumented experiences of migrants with sight loss in Ireland, the intention is to raise awareness among service providers of the additional vulnerability of this minority group. Design/methodology/approach – Migrants representing diverse ethnicities (Angolan, Algerian Nigerian, Zambian, Polish, Czech Republic, Malaysia Bangladeshi) described their experiences accessing disability services Ireland and discussed comparative attitudes towards disability in their home and host country. Service providers from the national organization working with people with sight loss were interviewed to gain an understanding of their attitudes and views on access and provision for migrants. By adopting a qualitative method following a constructivist grounded theory approach, migrants' own perceptions, beliefs, views and experiences of the sensitive subject of adjusting to sight loss while away from home were prioritised. Analysis of data was facilitated through qualitative software Atlas.ti and three core interrelated categories emerged most prominently: cultural perceptions of disability; support networks; and cultural barriers. The focus for this paper draws most significantly from the second category, support networks, most specifically the impact of absence or withdrawal of support for the migrant at the most vulnerable time of sight loss away from home. Findings – From grounded theory data analysis, three core interrelated categories emerged most prominently. They are: cultural perceptions of disability; support networks; and cultural barriers. This paper focuses most directly from findings related to support networks specifically highlighting two migrant case studies to report the impact of absence or withdrawal of support for migrant at the most vulnerable time of sight loss away from home. Service providers interviewed report inadequate information about migrants with sight loss. Evidence of stigma related to cultural perception of disability in the home community as trigger for discrimination from migrant's own network is reported by service providers. Findings are examined within an interdisciplinary theoretical framework, combining intercultural studies theories with disability models to facilitate a holistic understanding of the migrants' experience. Practical implications – The challenge of coping with disability for a migrant whose ethnic community network is absent, or withdraws its support owing to an individual's disability, have implications for alerting service providers to increased vulnerability of migrant service users. Consequently, this study has implications for programs and policies and can inform the development of culturally sensitive and appropriate services. Social implications – This study raises awareness of the compounded challenge for migrants with sight loss who are unsupported by their own ethnic group while living in a host country. Originality/value – This study reveals the previously unreported case of migrants who experience unsupportive behaviour from their own ethnic community following acquired disability. Evidence from migrants and their service providers demonstrates the impact of cultural perceptions of disability to influence the level of ethnic community support offered.

Journal

International Journal of Migration, Health and Social Care – Emerald Publishing

Published: Mar 22, 2013

Keywords: Ireland; Immigrants; National cultures; Ethnic communities; Disabled people; Blind people; Visual disability; Unsupportive migrant networks; Health and social care

References

  • Living on the margin: disabled Iranians in Belgium
    Albrecht, G.L.; Devlieger, P.J.; Van Hove, G.
  • Disabled women and the feminist agenda
    Begum, N.
  • Acculturation as varieties of adaptation
    Berry, J.W.
  • Immigration, acculturation, and adaptation
    Berry, J.W.
  • Emics and etics: a symbiotic relationship
    Berry, J.W.
  • Family and personal networks in international migration: recent developments and new agendas
    Boyd, M.
  • A communication model of personal space violations: explication and an initial test
    Burgoon, J.K.
  • A review of J.L. Ellyson, J.F. Dovidio's power, dominance, and nonverbal behavior
    Burgoon, J.K.
  • Applying a comparative approach to nonverbal expectancy violations theory
    Burgoon, J.K.
  • The fundamental topoi of relational communication
    Burgoon, J.K.; Hale, J.L.
  • The Age of Migration: International Population Movements in the Modern World
    Castles, S.; Miller, M.
  • Constructing Grounded Theory: A Practical Guide Through Qualitative Analysis
    Charmaz, K.
  • Including all our lives: renewing the social model of disability
    Crow, L.
  • Cross cultural differences in attitudes towards people towards disabled people: a study of Israeli Jewish and Arab youth in Israel
    Florian, V.
  • Intercultural friendship: five case studies of German students in the USA
    Gareis, E.
  • Migration networks and migration decision making
    Haug, S.
  • Culture's Consequences: Comparing Values, Behaviors, Institutions, and Organizations Across Nations
    Hofstede, G.
  • Stigma: The Experience of Disability
  • Our vision too: improving the access of ethnic minority visually impaired people to appropriate services
    Johnston, M.
  • Communication and Cross‐Cultural Adaptation
    Kim, Y.Y.
  • Becoming Intercultural: An Integrative Theory of Communication and Cross‐Cultural Adaptation
    Kim, Y.Y.
  • Disability as a Social Construct: Legislative Roots
    Liachowitz, C.H.
  • Social support and depressed mood: a structural analysis
    Lin, N.; Ye, X.; Ensel, W.
  • Birds of a feather: homophily in social networks
    McPherson, M.; Smith‐Lovin, L.; Cook, J.M.
  • The Politics of Disablement
    Oliver, M.
  • Highlights from the CAR study in Ibadan
    Omigbodun, O.O.; Odejide, O.O.; Morakinyo, J.J.
  • The Social System
    Parsons, T.
  • Making Sense of Illness: The Social Psychology of the Social Psychology of Health and Disease
    Radley, A.
  • Effects of positive and negative support received and provided on adaptation to chronic visual impairment
    Reinhardt, J.P.
  • Social networks, social support and social capital: the experiences of recent polish migrants in London
    Ryan, L.; Sales, R.; Tilka, M.; Sira, B.
  • Disability, identity and difference
    Shakespeare, T.
  • Tracing the journey of cross‐cultural adaptation of Polish migrant women in Ireland – a process of creating home when home is away
    Storch, K.
  • Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques
    Strauss, A.; Corbin, J.
  • Case Study Research: Design and Methods
    Yin, R.