Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Historic urban landscape

Historic urban landscape The main aim of this paper is to determine how well the UNESCO 2011 Recommendation on Historic Urban Landscape (hereafter, the HUL approach) is understood by the academic community today. It will review relevant research, highlight shortcomings regarding the HUL concept and approach and explore how well the six proposed steps are being considered when implementing the HUL approach.Design/methodology/approachThis paper presents and discusses the results of a systematic review of 140 peer-reviewed publications, published in international academic journals between 2008 and 2019 and available in databases such as WoS and Scopus, such as journal articles, book chapters and books. More specifically, this research takes the six-step process as its theoretical framework in order to understand if the six steps are being followed in the case studies where the HUL approach has been implemented. Following this, it assesses gaps in the HUL concept and approach. The paper explores the HUL implementation management process, investigating what is being done, how it is being done and who is involved.FindingsThe concept ‘Historic Urban Landscape’ has been used in research since 2008. However, the first case studies implementing the HUL approach were not published until 2013. While there is an abundance of theoretical research in relation to the HUL concept and approach from different perspectives and to varying degrees of depth, the case studies which practically demonstrate the HUL approach and its six steps are scarce. This paper will also show how feasible the steps are and which are used the most.Originality/valueThis research demonstrates if the HUL approach is being understood in the academic field and if the implementation of the six steps is being reflected in the literature. This approach will reveal how these steps are being implemented and if this is having an effect on the heritage planning process. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Cultural Heritage Management and Sustainable Development Emerald Publishing

Historic urban landscape

Download PDF
26 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/historic-urban-landscape-O03HVBfCn0
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
2044-1266
DOI
10.1108/jchmsd-05-2018-0036
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The main aim of this paper is to determine how well the UNESCO 2011 Recommendation on Historic Urban Landscape (hereafter, the HUL approach) is understood by the academic community today. It will review relevant research, highlight shortcomings regarding the HUL concept and approach and explore how well the six proposed steps are being considered when implementing the HUL approach.Design/methodology/approachThis paper presents and discusses the results of a systematic review of 140 peer-reviewed publications, published in international academic journals between 2008 and 2019 and available in databases such as WoS and Scopus, such as journal articles, book chapters and books. More specifically, this research takes the six-step process as its theoretical framework in order to understand if the six steps are being followed in the case studies where the HUL approach has been implemented. Following this, it assesses gaps in the HUL concept and approach. The paper explores the HUL implementation management process, investigating what is being done, how it is being done and who is involved.FindingsThe concept ‘Historic Urban Landscape’ has been used in research since 2008. However, the first case studies implementing the HUL approach were not published until 2013. While there is an abundance of theoretical research in relation to the HUL concept and approach from different perspectives and to varying degrees of depth, the case studies which practically demonstrate the HUL approach and its six steps are scarce. This paper will also show how feasible the steps are and which are used the most.Originality/valueThis research demonstrates if the HUL approach is being understood in the academic field and if the implementation of the six steps is being reflected in the literature. This approach will reveal how these steps are being implemented and if this is having an effect on the heritage planning process.

Journal

Journal of Cultural Heritage Management and Sustainable Development – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jun 15, 2020

Keywords: Literature review; Urban development; UNESCO; Heritage conservation; Historic urban landscape; Integrated tools; Six steps

References

  • Affordances of historic urban landscapes: an ecological understanding of human interaction with the past
    Alves, S.
  • Inheriting the city: historic urban landscape of George town UNESCO world heritage site
    Amat, R.C.
  • The image of historic urban landscapes: representation codes
    Amoruso, G.; Brusaporci, S.
  • Durand neighbourhood heritage inventory: toward a digital citywide survey approach to heritage planning in Hamilton
    Angel, V.; Garvey, A.; Sydor, M.
  • Towards operationalizing UNESCO recommendations on “historic urban landscape”: a position paper
    Angrisano, M.; Biancamano, P.F.; Bosone, M.; Carone, P.; Daldanise, G.; De Rosa, F.; Girard, L.F.
  • Balancing heritage conservation and sustainable development - the case of Bordeaux
    Appendino, F.
  • Towards a cultural ecology in urban environments: new challenges for environmental impact assessment
    Appendino, F.; Giliberto, F.; Mondini, G.; Fattinnanzi, E.; Oppio, A.; Bottero, A.; Stanghellini, S.
  • From paradox to paradigm? Historic urban landscape as an urban conservation approach
    Bandarin, F.; Taylor, K.; Lennon, J.
  • Conditional values of urban heritage: context and scale
    Berg, S.K.
  • A heritage gem sits in the heart of a city, unacknowledged, incognito: the case for recognizing Kolkata Chinatown as a historic urban landscape
    Bhowmik, R.; Sharma, A.
  • Morphology as the study of city form and layering
    Bianca, S.; Bandarin, F.; Oers, R. Van
  • Historic cities and climate change
    Bigio, A.G.; Bandarin, F.; Oers, R. Van
  • City walls as historic urban landscape: a case study on participatory education
    Bonadei, R.; Cisani, M.; Viani, E.
  • Historic urbanscapes for tomorrow, two Italian cases: Genoa and Bologna
    Bonfantini, G.B.
  • The historical image of the landscape of the Mediterranean city and the role of urban iconography [Article@L’immagine storica del paesaggio della città mediterranea e il ruolo dell'iconografia urbana]
    Buccaro, A.
  • Using the historic urban landscape to re-imagine Ballarat. The local context
    Buckley, K.; Cooke, S.; Fayad, S.; Labadi, S.; Logan, W.
  • The role of natural resources in the historic urban landscape approach
    Caballero, G.V.A.
  • Evaluation of urban processes on health in historic urban landscape approach: experimentation in the metropolitan area of Naples (Italy)
    Carone, P.; De Toro, P.; Franciosa, A.
  • International regulation of historic buildings and nationalism: the role of UNESCO
    Casini, L.
  • GIS-based visual analysis for planning and designing historic urban landscapes: the case of Turin
    Cassatella, C.; Carlone, G.
  • Innovative strategies for the recovering of historical cities
    Caterina, G.
  • Restoring Minarets as A dominant part of urban landscape restoration of stone and wooden Minarets in Bosnia and Herzegovina-materials, structure and urban form
    Causevic, A.; Idrizbegovic-Zgonic, A.; Rustempasic, N.; Handzic, L.K.
  • Applying the HUL approach to walled towns of Mediterranean seaport cities: lessons and guidelines through the experience of four UNESCO walled towns
    Colavitti, A.M.; Usai, A.
  • ROCK project. Regeneration and optimisation of cultural heritage in creative and knowledge cities
    Comune di Bologna
  • CLIC project - circular models leveraging investments in cultural heritage adaptive reuse
    Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche
  • Specifying the significance of historic sites in heritage planning
    Dastgerdi, A.S.; De Luca, G.
  • Circular economy and the role of universities in urban regeneration: the case of Ortigia, Syracuse
    De Medici, S.; Riganti, P.; Viola, S.
  • Historic urban landscape approach and port cities regeneration: Naples between identity and outlook
    De Rosa, F.; Di Palma, M.
  • Aportes desde la teoría del actor red para implementar la aproximación del Paisaje Histórico Urbano
    De Urbina, A.
  • The integrated evaluation as a driving tool for cultural-heritage enhancement strategies
    Della Spina, L.; Mondini, G.; Fattinnanzi, E.; Oppio, A.; Bottero, A.; Stanghellini, S.
  • Asmara: Africa’s modernist city (UNESCO world heritage nomination)
    Denison, E.; Teklemariam, M.; Abraha, D.
  • Macro level characterization of historic urban landscape: case study of alwar walled city
    Dhingra, M.; Singh, M.K.; Chattopadhyay, S.
  • Architectural design studio on sustainable tourism alternatives in the san Antonio missions historic District
    Doganer, S.
  • Participatory management of an urban world heritage site: the Table de Concertation du Vieux-Québec
    Dormaels, M.
  • The historic urban landscape”, managing heritage in an urban century
    du Cros, H.
  • Viewpoint: historic urban landscape approach for sustainable urban development
    Erkan, Y.
  • Circular economy and resilience Thinking for historic urban landscape regeneration: the case of Torre Annunziata, Naples
    Fabbricatti, K.; Biancamano, P.F.
  • The historic urban landscape of Old Dhaka, Bangladesh
    Ferdous, F.; Silva, K.D.; Sinha, A.
  • Historic ensemble and environment, instruments for the protection of urban and territorial dimension of historic cities. The case of Alhama de Granada
    Fernández Adarve, G.J.
  • Paisaje urbano histórico y cultural de Santa Cruz de Mompox y el río grande de la Magdalena
    Franco Ossa, L.V.
  • The Dresden Elbe valley, first cultural property to be delisted from the world heritage list: why and how? Exception or future tendency?
    Gaillard, B.
  • A failure of process? Comprehending the issues fostering heritage conflict in Dresden Elbe valley and liverpool — Maritime Mercantile city world heritage sites
    Gaillard, B.; Rodwell, D.
  • Cultural heritage and urban tourism: historic city centres under pressure
    García-Hernández, M.; de la Calle-Vaquero, M.; Yubero, C.
  • The rediscovery of the via Annia - Popilia from Capua to Reggio Calabria for knowledge and enhancement of the cultural route
    Genovese, R.A.; Calabró, F.; Della Spina, L.; Bevilacqua, C.
  • Toward the “Smart Polis”: methods, tools and strategies of intervention for the sustainable regeneration of historic urban centres
    Gigliarelli, E.; Lu, B.; Cessari, L.; Gambardella, C.
  • Eliciting cultural heritage values: landscape preferences vs representative images of the city
    Ginzarly, M.; Teller, J.
  • The Historic Urban Landscape approach to urban management: a systematic review
    Ginzarly, M.; Houbart, C.; Teller, J.
  • Mapping historic urban landscape values through social media
    Ginzarly, M.; Pereira Roders, A.; Teller, J.
  • Toward a smart sustainable development of port cities/areas: the role of the ‘historic urban landscape’ approach
    Girard, L.F.
  • The venice charter and cultural landscapes: evolution of heritage concepts and conser vation over time
    Goetcheus, C.; Mitchell, N.
  • Urban authenticity at stake: a new framework for its definition from the perspective of heritage at the Shanghai Music Valley
    González Martínez, P.
  • Multicriteria tools for the implementation of historic urban landscape
    Gravagnuolo, A.; Girard, L.F.
  • Territorial seismic safety evaluation and appropriate survey: liberty buildings in Naples
    Guadagnulo, M.; Paolillo, A.; Gambardella, C.
  • Conserving historic urban landscape and beautifying the city by means of its history
    Guoping, W.
  • Impacts of common urban development factors on cultural conservation in world heritage cities: an indicators-based analysis
    Guzmán, P.; Pereira Roders, A.; Colenbrander, B.
  • Entrepreneurial heritage: historic urban landscapes and the politics of ‘comprehensive development’ in post-Soviet Cuba
    Hill, M.J.; Tanaka, M.; Labadi, S.; Logan, W.
  • Knowledge and planning tools
    Hosagrahar, J.; Bandarín, F.; van Oers, R.
  • Designing public toilets in the historic urban landscape. Analysis based on the polish cities
    Jaglarz, A.
  • Challenges for implementing UNESCO’s historic urban landscape recommendation in Canada
    Jessiman, S.R.; Labadi, S.; Logan, W.
  • The intangible dimension of urban heritage
    Jigyasu, R.; Bandarín, F.; van Oers, R.
  • Evolution of the normative framework
    Jokilehto, J.; Bandarín, F.; van Oers, R.
  • Human–environment interactions in urban green spaces — a systematic review of contemporary issues and prospects for future research
    Kabisch, N.; Qureshi, S.; Haase, D.
  • The modernist historic urban landscape of Islamabad, Pakistan
    Karim, F.; Silva, K.D.; Sinha, A.
  • Visualising “ genius loci ” of built heritage
    Kepczynska-Walczak, A.; Walczak, B.; Morello, E.; Piga, B.
  • A proposal to apply the historic urban landscape approach to reconstruction in the world heritage context
    Khalaf, R.W.
  • Ornamented facades and panoramic views: the impact of tourism development on al-salt’s historic urban landscape
    Khirfan, L.
  • Haydarpaşa train station: present, past and future
    Kösebay Erkan, Y.
  • Toward historic urban landscape approach: serial properties along the Bosna river
    Kudumovic, L.
  • Cultural landscapes and prospects for extending Russia’s representation on the World Heritage List
    Kuleshova, M.E.
  • Conzenian tradition in polish urban historical morphology
    Kulesza, M.
  • From crisis to conservation: a critical review of the intertwined economic and political factors driving built heritage conservation policy in Hong Kong and a possible way forward
    Lee, H.Y.; Cummer, K.; DiStefano, L.D.
  • Study on the buffer zone of a Cultural Heritage site in an urban area: the case of Shenyang Imperial Palace in China
    Li, Q.; Yuichi, F.; Morris, M.; Marchettini, N.; Brebbia, C.A.; Pulselli, R.; Bastianoni, S.
  • Engineering geology in shaping and preserving the historic urban landscapes and cultural heritage: achievements in UNESCO world heritage sites
    Margottini, C.; Lollino, G.; Giordan, D.; Marunteanu, C.; Christaras, B.; Yoshinori, I.; Margottini, C.
  • Protection of human rights to the city and preservation of historic urban landscapes: ways to coherence
    Markevičienė, J.
  • The rebirth of the water in Rome. Aqueducts and fountains
    Martone, M.; Gambardella, C.
  • Public perception of urban identity in post-soviet city: the case of Vinnytsia, Ukraine
    Melnychuk, A.; Gnatiuk, O.
  • Historic urban landscapes and visualising Ballarat: citizen participation for sustainable urban planning and design
    Murphy, A.; Dahlhaus, P.; Thompson, H.; Both, A.; Duckham, M.; Kealy, A.
  • Changes of approach to urban context in international guidelines and experiences in Lithuanian urban environment
    Navickiene, E.; Riaubiene, E.
  • The historic urban landscape recommendation: a new UNESCO tool for a sustainable future
    O’Donnell, P.M.; Turner, M.
  • The role of regulatory systems
    O’Donnell, P.M.; Bandarin, F.; Oers, R. Van
  • Cultural landscape preservation: an evolving field
    O’Donnell, P.M.
  • Historic urban landscape forum, London, UK, 21-22 March 2017
    Palaiologou, G.
  • Historic cities as model of sustainability
    Pereira Roders, A.; Van Oers, R.
  • Editorial: bridging cultural heritage and sustainable development
    Pereira Roders, A.; Van Oers, R.
  • How can urbanization be sustainable? A reflection on the role of city resources in global sustainable development
    Pereira Roders, A.
  • Planning and heritage. Cultural heritage - a challenge for Europe
  • The new holistic paradigm and the sustainability of historic cities in Spain: an approach based on the World Heritage Cities
    Pino, J.M.
  • The historic urban landscape. Managing heritage in an urban century
    Porfyriou, H.
  • The role of spatial networks in the historic urban landscape: learning from venice in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries
    Psarra, S.
  • Tools for regeneratin of the urban landscape social enterprise as a link between people and landscape
    Ragozino, S.
  • Lights and shadows over the Recommendation on the Historic Urban Landscape: ‘managing change’ in Ballarat and Cuenca through a radical approach focused on values and authenticity
    Rey-Pérez, J.; González Martínez, P.
  • Historic urban landscape, an approach for sustainable management in Cuenca (Ecuador)
    Rey-Pérez, J.; Siguencia Ávila, M.
  • Towards the implementation of the historic urban landscape approach in the Guayaquil waterfront (Ecuador): a scoping case study
    Rey-Pérez, J.; Valencia Avellán, D.
  • The perception of the place through the citizen participation. The implementation of the historic urban landscape in Cuenca (Ecuador)
    Rey-Pérez, J.; Forero, J.; Tenze, A.; Zhou, J.; Van Oers, R.
  • Urban regeneration and the management of change: liverpool and the historic urban landscape
    Rodwell, D.
  • Urban morphology, historic urban landscapes and the management of historic cities
    Rodwell, D.
  • The historic urban landscape and the geography of urban heritage
    Rodwell, D.
  • Cultural paradigm inertia and urban tourism
    Ronchini, C.; Fayos-Solá, E.; Cooper, C.
  • Coreografías contemporaneas de granada. La investigación a través del dibujo y sus resultados inesperados]
    Rooney, B.E.
  • Devising financial tools for urban conservation
    Rypkema, D.; Bandarin, F.; Oers, R. Van
  • Festivals, rituals, and urban landscape in eighteenth-century Maharashtra
    Sahasrabudhe, C.; Kashyap, A.
  • Captain, where can we find the attributes?
    Sanjbod, H.S.; Hermans, L.; Reijnders, D.; Veldpaus, L.
  • Urban planning and sustainable development in the 21st century, conceptual and management issues
    Santander, A.A.; Garai-Olaun, A.A.
  • Historic urban landscapes: a review on trends and methodologies in the urban context of the 21st century
    Santander, A.A.; Garai-Olaun, A.A.; Arana, A.F.
  • Smart experiential paths and historical urban landscape: a case of sustainable enhancement
    Sepe, M.; Marchettini, N.; Brebbia, C.A.; Pulselli, R.; Bastianoni, S.
  • Improving sustainable enhancement of cultural heritage: smart placemaking for experiential paths in pompeii
    Sepe, M.
  • Urban landscape factors that influenced the character of George town, Penang Unesco world heritage site
    Shamsuddin, S.; Sulaiman, A.B.; Amat, R.C.
  • The historic urban landscape practice in Latin America, Cuenca as a case study
    Siguencia Ávila, M.; Andrade, S.V.; Van Balen, K.; Vandesande, A.
  • Heritage values protection, from the monument to the urban dimension. Case study: the historic centre of Santa Ana de los Ríos de Cuenca, Ecuador
    Siguencia Ávila, M.; Rey-Pérez, J.
  • Sustainability of Historical Landscape to Gwanghalluwon Garden in Namwon City, Korea
    Sil Shin, H.; Chen, Y.; Ho Lee, W.; Hyun Kim, D.
  • Lhasa community, world heritage and human rights
    Sinding-Larsen, A.
  • Planning and managing historic urban landscapes
    Siravo, F.; Bandarín, F.; van Oers, R.
  • Civic engagement tools for urban conservation
    Smith, J.; Bandarín, F.; van Oers, R.
  • Introduction
    Sonkoly, G.
  • The historic centre of Vienna as a world heritage site from a historical perspective
    Sonkoly, G.
  • Defining and managing the historic urban landscape: reflections on the English experience and some stories from liverpool
    Sykes, O.; Ludwig, C.
  • Still a place to call home? Development and the changing character of place
    Taha, S.
  • The historic urban landscape. Managing heritage in an urban century
    Taylor, K.
  • Cities as cultural landscapes
    Taylor, K.; Bandarín, F.; van Oers, R.
  • The Historic Urban Landscape paradigm and cities as cultural landscapes. Challenging orthodoxy in urban conservation
    Taylor, K.
  • Historic Urban landscape. Contribution to the critical reading of the cultural territories
    Trindade-Changas, M.A.N.; Amoeda, R.; Lira, S.; Pinheiro, C.
  • Researching and mapping the historic urban landscape
    Turner, M.; Singer, R.
  • Urban resilience in climate change
    Turner, M.; Singer, R.
  • Social sustainability of the historic urban landscape
    Turner, M.
  • Preliminary report on the draft recommendation on the historic urban landscape
  • Recommendation on the historic urban landscape, including a glossary of definitions
  • Hangzhou outcomes. International conference ‘culture for sustainable cities
  • Culture urban future. Global report on culture for sustainable urban development
  • Valuing urban heritage through participatory heritage websites: citizen perceptions of historic urban landscapes
    van der Hoeven, A.
  • Historic urban landscapes on social media: the contributions of online narrative practices to urban heritage conservation
    van der Hoeven, A.
  • Conclusion: the way forward: an agenda for reconnecting the city
    Van Oers, R.; Bandarin, F.; Van Oers, R.
  • Historic urban landscapes: an assessment framework, part I”, 33rd
    Veldpaus, L.; Pereira Roders, A.
  • Urban heritage: putting the past into the future
    Veldpaus, L.; Pereira Roders, A.; Colenbrander, B.J.F.
  • Reframing China’s heritage conservation discourse. Learning by testing civic engagement tools in a historic rural village
    Verdini, G.; Frassoldati, F.; Nolf, C.
  • Sustainability of historical heritage: the conservation of the Xi'an city wall
    Wang, S.; Jiang, Y.; Xu, Y.; Zhang, L.; Li, X.; Zhu, L.
  • Informal settlements and urban heritage landscapes in South Africa
    Weiss, L.M.
  • Conserving urban landscape heritage: a geographical approach
    Whitehand, J.W.R.; Gu, K.
  • The HUL Guidebook. Managing heritage in dynamic and constantly changing urban environments
    WHITRAP; Ballarat, C.
  • Digital historic urban landscape methodology for heritage impact assessment of Singapore
    Widodo, J.; Wong, Y.C.; Ismail, F.
  • Archaeology: reading the city through time
    Williams, T.; Bandarín, F.; van Oers, R.
  • Learning from Italian typology- and morphology-led planning techniques: a planning framework for Yingping, Xiamen
    Xie, S.
  • HUL and conservation of the historic city of Kulangsu: a scoping case
    Yan, S.
  • Heritage andamp; development" strategy on historic urban landscape (HUL): the added value of multi-Temporal hub application
    Yang, M.; Brumana, R.; Previtali, M.
  • Preliminary research on planning of decentralizing ancient towns in small-scale famous historic and cultural cities with a case study of Tingchow County, Fujian Province
    Yin, M.; Xu, J.; Yang, Z.
  • Dynamic integrity: a concept to historic urban landscape
    Zancheti, S.M.; Loretto, R.P.