Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

The Strategic Promotion of Distrust in Government in the Tea Party Age

The Strategic Promotion of Distrust in Government in the Tea Party Age AbstractThis paper argues that distrust in government is not an inadvertent byproduct of economic change, scandals, and cultural and identity politics, but rather grows out of strategic efforts to promote and harness it for political purposes. Elites encouraging distrust interact with grassroots movements, which they can only loosely direct and control. Identifying four strategic benefits of distrust: organizational, electoral, institutional and policy, the paper discusses how Republicans and conservative movement organizations in the Tea Party age used distrust to develop groups and achieve coherence, try to influence primaries and win elections, argue for the constitutional powers of institutions they control, and seek to influence public policy. Paying special attention to health policy, we examine how, after distrust was successfully used to thwart President Bill Clinton’s proposed reforms, it was employed to try to stop and then to exact a price for President Barack Obama’s passage of the Affordable Care Act. While Tea Party rhetoric and current streams of distrust are often associated with racialized messages and anti-Obama sentiment, we contend they are likely to persist after Obama leaves office, particularly given the Tea Party’s comfort with ungovernability and long-standing conservative use of government distrust. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png The Forum de Gruyter

The Strategic Promotion of Distrust in Government in the Tea Party Age

Fried, Amy; Harris, Douglas B.
The Forum , Volume 13 (3): 27 – Oct 1, 2015
Download PDF
27 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/de-gruyter/the-strategic-promotion-of-distrust-in-government-in-the-tea-party-age-0mF710a0Vh

References

References for this paper are not available at this time. We will be adding them shortly, thank you for your patience.

Publisher
de Gruyter
Copyright
©2015 by De Gruyter
ISSN
1540-8884
eISSN
1540-8884
DOI
10.1515/for-2015-0028
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

AbstractThis paper argues that distrust in government is not an inadvertent byproduct of economic change, scandals, and cultural and identity politics, but rather grows out of strategic efforts to promote and harness it for political purposes. Elites encouraging distrust interact with grassroots movements, which they can only loosely direct and control. Identifying four strategic benefits of distrust: organizational, electoral, institutional and policy, the paper discusses how Republicans and conservative movement organizations in the Tea Party age used distrust to develop groups and achieve coherence, try to influence primaries and win elections, argue for the constitutional powers of institutions they control, and seek to influence public policy. Paying special attention to health policy, we examine how, after distrust was successfully used to thwart President Bill Clinton’s proposed reforms, it was employed to try to stop and then to exact a price for President Barack Obama’s passage of the Affordable Care Act. While Tea Party rhetoric and current streams of distrust are often associated with racialized messages and anti-Obama sentiment, we contend they are likely to persist after Obama leaves office, particularly given the Tea Party’s comfort with ungovernability and long-standing conservative use of government distrust.

Journal

The Forum – de Gruyter

Published: Oct 1, 2015

References

  • The Exaggerated Life of Death Panels : The Limits of Framing Effects in the Care Debate Available at SSRN http papers ssrn com sol papers cfm abstract id
    Hopkins
  • The Obama Trigger Presidential Approval and Tea Party Membership
    Maxwell
  • The Remarkable Staying Power of Death Panels of Policy
    Frankford
  • Death Panels
    Kessler
  • Has the Tea Party Era Radicalized the Republican Party ? Evidence from Text Analysis of the Republican Primary Debates
    Medzihorsky
  • Ira Fear Itself The New Deal and the Origins of Our Time New York Company
    Katznelson
  • Fein Source of Bias in Public Opinion Stability
    Druckman
  • Lisa The Tea Party Citizenship Movement The Precipitous Rise of the Tea Party edited by Lawrence Rosenthal and Christine University of California
    Disch
  • warns Reform is Popular Politico http www politico com news stories html
    Allen
  • the Republican Party and the New American Party System Perspectives on
    Milkis
  • Vanessa The Tea Party and the Remaking of Republican Conservatism Perspectives on
    Williamson
  • Pew Research Center Trust in Government Nears Record Low But Most Federal Agencies Are Viewed Favorably http www people press org trust in government nears record low but most federal agencies are viewed favorably
  • Governing with the Polls
    Fried
  • Republican Party Platform Republican Party Platform by The Presidency Project Accessed September http www presidency ucsb edu ws pid
    August
  • The Politicization of Climate Change and Polarization in the American Public s Views of Global Warming The
    McCright
  • The Ruling Class Inside the Imperial Congress Special Abridged Edition The Heritage Foundation
    Felten
  • The Exaggerated Life of Death Panels : The Limits of Framing Effects in the Care Debate Available at SSRN http papers ssrn com sol papers cfm abstract id
    Hopkins
  • Off The Republican Revolution and the Erosion of American Democracy New Yale University
    Hacker
  • Joe Public Transformed Welfare Reform as Policy Feedback
    Soss
  • The Republican Resurgence in
    Jacobson
  • Tea Time in America ? The Impact of the Tea Party Movement on the Midterm Elections
    Karpowitz
  • Christine Steep The Precipitous Rise of the Tea Party University of California
    Rosenthal
  • The Imperial Congress Crisis in the Separation of New York
    Jones
  • Patricia Tempers Flare Over Care Plan Detroit Free
    Antsett
  • The of Healthcare Politico http www politico com pdf luntz pdf
    Luntz
  • Republican Party Platform Republican Party Platform of by The American Presidency Project Accessed September http www presidency ucsb edu ws pid
    August
  • Presidential - Congressional Power Prescriptions in Conservative Political Since Presidential Studies
    Piper
  • Republican Party Platform Republican Party Platform of by The American Presidency Project Accessed September http www presidency ucsb edu ws pid
    August
  • The Tea Party the Presidential Election
    Bradberry
  • Public How Political Actors View the Democratic Process Chicago University of Chicago
    Herbst
  • Pew Research Center Trust in Government Nears Record Low But Most Federal Agencies Are Viewed Favorably http www people press org trust in government nears record low but most federal agencies are viewed favorably
  • The Whites of Their Eyes : The Tea Party s Revolution And the Battle Over Princeton Princeton University
    Lepore
  • Partisan Majorities and Responsible Democracy InDefense of the Founders Republic : Critics of Direct Democracy in the Progressive Era edited by New York
    Harris
  • Beyond Welfare Framing and the Racialization of on Social
    Winter
  • Sarah Statement on the Current Health Care Debate Facebook Post https www facebook com note php note id
    Palin
  • Governing with the Polls
    Fried
  • Andrea Louise Policy Feedbacks and the Impact of Policy Designs on Public of Policy
    Campbell
  • The Remarkable Staying Power of Death Panels of Policy
    Frankford
  • Ideological Republicans and Group Interest Democrats : The Asymmetry of American Perspectives on
    Grossmann
  • the Republican Party and the New American Party System Perspectives on
    Milkis
  • Elizabeth Gene Political Trust in Polarized Times InMotivating Cooperation and Compliance with Authority : The Role of Institutional Trust edited by on Motivation New York
    Theiss
  • Andrea Louise Policy Feedbacks and the Impact of Policy Designs on Public of Policy
    Campbell
  • Free The Political Beliefs of Americans New University
    Hadley Cantril
  • Public How Political Actors View the Democratic Process Chicago University of Chicago
    Herbst
  • President Obama Polarized Public Opinion by Racial Attitudes and
    Tesler
  • Martha and Social Welfare Policy The Social Security Act of
    Davies
  • Kevin Who Wants to Have a Tea Party ? The Who What and Why of the Tea Party Movement
    Arceneaux
  • Muffled Echoes the of Public New York Columbia University
    Fried
  • Ideological Republicans and Group Interest Democrats : The Asymmetry of American Perspectives on
    Grossmann
  • Reaching for a New Deal Ambitious Governance Economic Meltdown and Polarized InReaching for a New Deal Ambitious Governance Economic Meltdown and Polarized Politics in Obama s First Two Years edited by Theda New York Foundation
    Skocpol
  • Jonathan Long Time Coming Why Reform Finally Passed
    Oberlander
  • All Politics is National : The Rise of Negative Partisanship and the Nationalization of and Senate Elections in the st Century Association Annual Meeting Chicago
    Abramowitz
  • Politicians Don t Pander Political Manipulation and the Loss of Democratic Responsiveness Chicago University of Chicago Press
    Jacobs
  • The Politicization of Climate Change and Polarization in the American Public s Views of Global Warming The
    McCright
  • Kevin Who Wants to Have a Tea Party ? The Who What and Why of the Tea Party Movement
    Arceneaux
  • Melanie The Second Face of the Public Presidency : Presidential Polling and the Shift from Policy to Personality Polling Presidential Studies
    Jacobs
  • Politicians Don t Pander Political Manipulation and the Loss of Democratic Responsiveness Chicago University of Chicago Press
    Jacobs
  • Ian Beyond Beltway Debate Turns Hostile New York Times
    Urbina
  • It s Even Worse than it Looks : How the American Constitutional System Collided with the New Politics of Extremism New York Basic
    Mann
  • Pathways to Polling Crisis Cooperation and the Making of Public Opinion Professions New York
    Fried
  • warns Reform is Popular Politico http www politico com news stories html
    Allen
  • When the Tea Party Came to New York
    Draper
  • Beyond Tocqueville The Multiple Traditions in America
    Smith
  • Sarah Statement on the Current Health Care Debate Facebook Post https www facebook com note php note id
    Palin
  • Party Ideologies in New York University
    Gerring
  • Tea Talk The Rhetoric of Tea Party Governors New England Meeting Portsmouth New Hampshire
    Melcher
  • Martha Memorable Moments When Town Meetings Turned to Rage National Public Radio It s All http www npr org sections itsallpolitics memorable moments when town hall meetings turned to rage
    Shanahan
  • Old Tea Party : Partisan Polarization and the Rise of the Tea Party Movement The Precipitous Rise of the Tea Party edited by Lawrence Rosenthal and Christine University of California
    Abramowitz
  • Elizabeth Gene Political Trust in Polarized Times InMotivating Cooperation and Compliance with Authority : The Role of Institutional Trust edited by on Motivation New York
    Theiss
  • On Red Capes and Charging Bulls : How and Why Conservative Politicians and Interest Groups Promoted Public Anger Is It About Government That Americans Dislike edited by and Elizabeth and New York : Cambridge University
    Fried
  • Change They Can t Believe In : The Tea Party and Reactionary Politics in Princeton Princeton University
    Parker
  • Republican Party Platform Republican Party Platform by The Presidency Project Accessed September http www presidency ucsb edu ws pid
    August
  • Fein Source of Bias in Public Opinion Stability
    Druckman
  • The Ruling Class Inside the Imperial Congress Special Abridged Edition The Heritage Foundation
    Felten
  • Partisan Majorities and Responsible Democracy InDefense of the Founders Republic : Critics of Direct Democracy in the Progressive Era edited by New York
    Harris
  • Beyond Welfare Framing and the Racialization of on Social
    Winter
  • Sally Political and Cultural Dimensions of Tea Party Support The
    Perrin
  • Geoffrey Rule Ruin The Downfall of Moderate and the Destruction of the Republican Party From Eisenhower to the Tea Party University
    Kabaservice
  • The Whites of Their Eyes : The Tea Party s Revolution And the Battle Over Princeton Princeton University
    Lepore
  • Has the Tea Party Era Radicalized the Republican Party ? Evidence from Text Analysis of the Republican Primary Debates
    Medzihorsky
  • Geoffrey Rule Ruin The Downfall of Moderate and the Destruction of the Republican Party From Eisenhower to the Tea Party University
    Kabaservice
  • Obama Lies Grandma Dies : The Uncertain Politics of Medicare and the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of and
    Gitterman
  • Sunshine Hillygus The Dynamics of Care Partisanship Self Interest and Racial Resentment of Policy
    Henderson
  • Vanessa The Tea Party and the Remaking of Republican Conservatism New York University
    Skocpol
  • Ted Anti - Minority Attitudes and Tea Party Movement Membership
    Tope
  • III Hood III The Tea Party Sarah the Congressional Elections : The Aftermath of the Election of Barack Obama
    Bullock
  • Remedy Reaction The Peculiar Struggle Over Care Reform New London Yale University
    Starr
  • Prior Quality Controlled : An Ethnographic Account of Tea Party Messaging and Action
    Francis
  • and Elizabeth Liking the Pieces not the Package Contradictions in Public Opinion during Reform
    Brodie
  • Jackie They Don t Give a Damn About Governing : Conservative Media s Influence on the Republican Party Shorenstein Center on Media Discussion Paper Series Cambridge School Shorenstein Center on Media http shorensteincenter org wp content uploads
    Calmes
  • Fighting for Our The Epic Battle to Make Health Care a Right in the United States The Rockefeller Institute Press
    Kirsch
  • and Elizabeth Liking the Pieces not the Package Contradictions in Public Opinion during Reform
    Brodie
  • Obama Lies Grandma Dies : The Uncertain Politics of Medicare and the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of and
    Gitterman
  • President Obama Polarized Public Opinion by Racial Attitudes and
    Tesler
  • Ken Ken The Blueprint : Obama s Plan to Subvert the Constitution and Build an Imperial Presidency
    Blackwell
  • Patricia Tempers Flare Over Care Plan Detroit Free
    Antsett
  • Situational Constitutionalism and Presidential The Rise and Fall of the Liberal Model of Presidential Government Presidential Studies
    Piper
  • The Tea Party the Presidential Election
    Bradberry
  • Sunshine Hillygus The Dynamics of Care Partisanship Self Interest and Racial Resentment of Policy
    Henderson
  • Remedy Reaction The Peculiar Struggle Over Care Reform New London Yale University
    Starr
  • Gauging the Scope of the Tea Party Movement in America Washington Post http www washingtonpost com wp dyn content article AR html sid ST
    Gardner
  • Grassley Warns of Government Pulling Plug On Grandma CBS News http www cbsnews com news grassley warns of government pulling plug on grandma
    Montopoli
  • When the Tea Party Came to New York
    Draper
  • Melanie The Second Face of the Public Presidency : Presidential Polling and the Shift from Policy to Personality Polling Presidential Studies
    Jacobs
  • Reaching for a New Deal Ambitious Governance Economic Meltdown and Polarized InReaching for a New Deal Ambitious Governance Economic Meltdown and Polarized Politics in Obama s First Two Years edited by Theda New York Foundation
    Skocpol
  • III Hood III The Tea Party Sarah the Congressional Elections : The Aftermath of the Election of Barack Obama
    Bullock
  • Lisa The Tea Party Citizenship Movement The Precipitous Rise of the Tea Party edited by Lawrence Rosenthal and Christine University of California
    Disch
  • Sally Political and Cultural Dimensions of Tea Party Support The
    Perrin
  • Grab Obama s Dangerous Plan for a One Party Florida
    Morris
  • All Politics is National : The Rise of Negative Partisanship and the Nationalization of and Senate Elections in the st Century Association Annual Meeting Chicago
    Abramowitz
  • Republican Party Platform Republican Party Platform of by The American Presidency Project Accessed September http www presidency ucsb edu ws pid
    August
  • Off The Republican Revolution and the Erosion of American Democracy New Yale University
    Hacker
  • Party Ideologies in New York University
    Gerring
  • Prior Quality Controlled : An Ethnographic Account of Tea Party Messaging and Action
    Francis
  • Ira Fear Itself The New Deal and the Origins of Our Time New York Company
    Katznelson
  • Ken Ken The Blueprint : Obama s Plan to Subvert the Constitution and Build an Imperial Presidency
    Blackwell
  • Grassley Warns of Government Pulling Plug On Grandma CBS News http www cbsnews com news grassley warns of government pulling plug on grandma
    Montopoli
  • Vilifying Conservative Tropes of Victimage in the Care Debates University
    Duffy
  • Old Tea Party : Partisan Polarization and the Rise of the Tea Party Movement The Precipitous Rise of the Tea Party edited by Lawrence Rosenthal and Christine University of California
    Abramowitz
  • Responsive Partisanship Public Support for the Obama Care Plans of and
    Kriner
  • Martha and Social Welfare Policy The Social Security Act of
    Davies
  • It s Even Worse than it Looks : How the American Constitutional System Collided with the New Politics of Extremism New York Basic
    Mann
  • The Primaries Project : How the Tea Party is Winning While Losing Brookings Accessed http www brookings edu blogs fixgov posts primaries project tea party tennessee kansas kamarck
    Kamarck
  • Free The Political Beliefs of Americans New University
    Hadley Cantril
  • Ian Beyond Beltway Debate Turns Hostile New York Times
    Urbina
  • It s Time to Bury the Death Panel Myth for Good Is This the Way to do it Washington Post September http www washingtonpost com blogs wonkblog wp its time to bury the death panel myth for good is this the way to do it
    Millman
  • Liz Tracking Poll Late Special Focus on the Supreme Court Decision Foundation http kff org health reform poll finding kaiser health tracking poll late june a special focus on the supreme court decision
    Hamel
  • Sarah The Averaged Citizens and the Making of a Mass Public University
    Igo
  • Balz Sarah in Iowa Attacks Obama and Crony Capitalism The Post September
    Dan
  • Fighting for Our The Epic Battle to Make Health Care a Right in the United States The Rockefeller Institute Press
    Kirsch
  • Gauging the Scope of the Tea Party Movement in America Washington Post http www washingtonpost com wp dyn content article AR html sid ST
    Gardner
  • Vilifying Conservative Tropes of Victimage in the Care Debates University
    Duffy
  • Martha Memorable Moments When Town Meetings Turned to Rage National Public Radio It s All http www npr org sections itsallpolitics memorable moments when town hall meetings turned to rage
    Shanahan
  • Newt Remarks to the Congressional Center Conference on House Leadership InMasters of the edited by and CO
    Gingrich
  • Vanessa The Tea Party and the Remaking of Republican Conservatism New York University
    Skocpol
  • Grab Obama s Dangerous Plan for a One Party Florida
    Morris
  • The Republican Resurgence in
    Jacobson
  • On Red Capes and Charging Bulls : How and Why Conservative Politicians and Interest Groups Promoted Public Anger Is It About Government That Americans Dislike edited by and Elizabeth and New York : Cambridge University
    Fried
  • Liz Tracking Poll Late Special Focus on the Supreme Court Decision Foundation http kff org health reform poll finding kaiser health tracking poll late june a special focus on the supreme court decision
    Hamel
  • The Imperial Congress Crisis in the Separation of New York
    Jones
  • Christine Steep The Precipitous Rise of the Tea Party University of California
    Rosenthal
  • Majority Party Leaders Uses of Public Congress The Presidency
    Harris
  • Jackie They Don t Give a Damn About Governing : Conservative Media s Influence on the Republican Party Shorenstein Center on Media Discussion Paper Series Cambridge School Shorenstein Center on Media http shorensteincenter org wp content uploads
    Calmes
  • The Obama Trigger Presidential Approval and Tea Party Membership
    Maxwell
  • Vanessa The Tea Party and the Remaking of Republican Conservatism Perspectives on
    Williamson
  • Majority Party Leaders Uses of Public Congress The Presidency
    Harris
  • Death Panels
    Kessler
  • Presidential - Congressional Power Prescriptions in Conservative Political Since Presidential Studies
    Piper
  • Joe Public Transformed Welfare Reform as Policy Feedback
    Soss
  • The of Healthcare Politico http www politico com pdf luntz pdf
    Luntz
  • Situational Constitutionalism and Presidential The Rise and Fall of the Liberal Model of Presidential Government Presidential Studies
    Piper
  • Ted Anti - Minority Attitudes and Tea Party Movement Membership
    Tope
  • Survey Research in the United States Roots and Emergence Berkeley University of California
    Converse
  • It s Time to Bury the Death Panel Myth for Good Is This the Way to do it Washington Post September http www washingtonpost com blogs wonkblog wp its time to bury the death panel myth for good is this the way to do it
    Millman
  • Sarah The Averaged Citizens and the Making of a Mass Public University
    Igo
  • Balz Sarah in Iowa Attacks Obama and Crony Capitalism The Post September
    Dan
  • Survey Research in the United States Roots and Emergence Berkeley University of California
    Converse
  • Muffled Echoes the of Public New York Columbia University
    Fried
  • The Primaries Project : How the Tea Party is Winning While Losing Brookings Accessed http www brookings edu blogs fixgov posts primaries project tea party tennessee kansas kamarck
    Kamarck
  • Jonathan Long Time Coming Why Reform Finally Passed
    Oberlander
  • Tea Time in America ? The Impact of the Tea Party Movement on the Midterm Elections
    Karpowitz
  • Beyond Tocqueville The Multiple Traditions in America
    Smith
  • Tea Talk The Rhetoric of Tea Party Governors New England Meeting Portsmouth New Hampshire
    Melcher
  • Responsive Partisanship Public Support for the Obama Care Plans of and
    Kriner
  • Pathways to Polling Crisis Cooperation and the Making of Public Opinion Professions New York
    Fried
  • Republican Party Platform Republican Party Platform of by The American Presidency Project Accessed September http www presidency ucsb edu ws pid
    August
  • Newt Remarks to the Congressional Center Conference on House Leadership InMasters of the edited by and CO
    Gingrich
  • Change They Can t Believe In : The Tea Party and Reactionary Politics in Princeton Princeton University
    Parker