Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
Loading next page...
/lp/de-gruyter/a-discourse-analysis-of-recent-mainland-chinese-historiography-on-the-TItF0FK0Tx
References (67)
-
(2007)
Deutungskämpfe: Theorie und Praxis -
(2007)
Lüèlùn Rìběn zài Dōng Yà cháogòng tǐxì zhōng de juésè yǔ zuòyòng 略论日本在东亚朝贡体系中的角色与作用 [Brief Discussion of Japan's Role and Function in the East Asian Tributary System -
M. Wild (2019)
Renewal -
Yuan-kang Wang (2013)
Explaining the Tribute System: Power, Confucianism, and War in Medieval East AsiaJournal of East Asian Studies, 13
-
(2004)
Zentrum und Peripherie in China und Ostasien. -
J. Gommans (2011)
Strange Parallels: Southeast Asia in Global Context, c. 800-1830, Vol 2: Mainland Mirrors: Europe, Japan, China, South Asia and the IslandsJournal of The Economic and Social History of The Orient, 54
-
S. Lee, K. Pomeranz (2001)
The Great Divergence: China, Europe, and the Making of the Modern World EconomyInternational Journal, 56
-
(2009)
Rethinking the ‘Tribute System’ -
W. Wohlforth (1999)
The Stability of a Unipolar WorldInternational Security, 24
-
K. Pomeranz (2001)
The Great Divergence. China, Europe, and the Making of the Modern -
National Knowledge Infrastructure (Zhōngguó Zhīwǎng 中国知网) -
(2019)
Míngdài 'hǎishàng sīchóu zhi Lù' fāzhǎn móshì de lìshǐ fǎnsī 明代 '海上丝绸之路'发展模式的历史反思 [Reflections on the Development Model of Míng Era 'Maritime Silk Routes -
V. Lieberman (2003)
Strange Parallels: Southeast Asia in Global Context, c.800-1830 -
(2006)
Guójì guānxi lǐlùn zhōng de Zhōngguó xuépài shēngchéng kěnéng hé bìrán 国际关系理论中国学派生成的可能和必然 [The Possibility and Necessity of the Formation of a Chinese School of International Relations Theory -
(2003)
Rìběn yǔ Dōng Yà 'cháogòng tǐxì' 日本与东亚'朝贡体系 -
R. Lebow (2008)
A Cultural Theory of International Relations: Frontmatter -
(2004)
Shíwǔ shìjì Zhōng-Xī hánghǎi fāzhǎn qǔxiàng de duìbǐ yǔ sīsuǒ 15 世纪中西航海发展取向的对比与思索 [Comparing and Contemplating the Development Tendencies of Fifteenth-Century Chinese and Western Navigation -
Shénme shì Xīn-Tiānxiàzhǔyì? 什么是新天下主义？ [What Is Neo-Tianxiaism? -
(2016)
The Belt and Road: What Will China Offer the World in Its Rise -
(2006)
Lùn Míngchū de hǎijìn yǔ cháogòng màoyì 论明初的海禁与朝贡贸 易 [On the Early Míng Maritime Ban and Tribute-Trade -
(2017)
Duì gǔdài Dōng Yà cháogòng tǐzhì de zàisīkǎo 对古代东亚朝贡体制的再思 考 [Rethinking the Pre-Modern East Asian Tributary System]. -
(2007)
Ist Ostasien eine europäische Erfindung? Anmerkungen -
Kirk Larsen (2011)
The Qing Empire (China), Imperialism, and the Modern WorldHistory Compass, 9
-
Jason Lim (2015)
Renewal: The Chinese State and the New Global HistoryAsian Studies Review, 39
-
David Kang (2010)
East Asia Before the West: Five Centuries of Trade and Tribute -
(2017)
“ Shìlùn Zhōngguó zài Dōng Yà cháogòng tǐxì zhōng de dìwèi hé zùoyòng 试论中国在东亚朝贡体系中的地位和作用 [ Analysing China ’ s Position and Function in the East Asian Tributary System ] -
Ta-tuan Chʿên, J. Fairbank (1968)
The Chinese world order : traditional China's foreign relationsThe American Historical Review, 75
-
(2007)
Fù, Bǎichén 付百臣 -
(2017)
“ Qīngdài Měnggǔ cháogòng fǎlǜ zhōng de duōyuán fǎwénhuà 清代蒙 古朝 贡 法律制度中的多元法文化 [ On Diversity in the Legal Culture of the Qīng - Era Mongol Tributary Law System ] -
P. Perdue (2015)
The Tenacious Tributary SystemJournal of Contemporary China, 24
-
(1997)
Qīngdài Hán-Zhōng cháogòng guānxi kǎo 清代 韩中朝贡关系考 [Analysis of Qīng-era Korean-Chinese Tributary Relations -
(2014)
Huàyǔ, shìjiǎo yǔ fāngfǎ: Jìn nián lái Míng-Qīng cháogòng tǐzhì yánjiū de jǐge wèntí 话语,视角与方法: 近年来明清朝贡体制研究的几个问题 -
(2018)
Cháogòng tǐxì yǔ Sòngdài guójiā ānquán 朝贡体系与宋朝国家 安全 [Tributary System and National Security During the Sòng Dynasty -
(2007)
Ist Ostasien eine europäische Erfindung? Anmerkungen zu einem Artikel von Wang Hui -
(2011)
Zàilùn Qīngdài cháogòng tǐzhì 再论清代朝贡体制 [Rethinking the Qīng-Era Tributary System -
(2014)
“ Lùn Míngcháo Xīyù cháogòng màoyì zhèngcè de déshī 论明朝西域 朝贡贸易政策的得失 [ On the Gains and Losses of Míng - Era Tributary Trade in the Western Regions ] -
K. Rothschild (2016)
Global Perspectives On Global History Theories And Approaches In A Connected World -
(2016)
=Kāng Cànxióng 康灿雄 -
(2001)
Hé, Àiguó 何爱国 -
Hui Wang (2014)
China from Empire to Nation-State -
(2016)
Míngdài Wūliánghā Měnggǔ Sānwèi cháogòng zhìdù 明代兀良哈蒙 古三卫朝贡制度 [The Tributary System of the Mongolian Uriyangqa Three Commanderies During the Míng Dynasty -
(2015)
Míngdài nǚzhēn cháogòng zhìdù yánjiū 明代女真朝贡制度研究 -
A. Frank (2022)
ReOrientReOrient
-
S. Jäger (2001)
Kritische Diskursanalyse : eine Einführung -
Gang Deng (1997)
The Foreign Staple Trade of China in the Pre-Modern EraInternational History Review, 19
-
(1990)
Kindai Chūgoku no kokusai-teki keiki – Chōkō bōeki shisutemu to kindai Ajia 近代中国の国際的契機―朝貢貿易システムと近代アジア -
(2011)
Cóng cháogòng kàn Míngcháo Hàn-Zàng jiāoliú 从朝贡看明朝 汉藏交流 [Míng-Era Han-Tibetan Interaction from the Perspective of Tributary Exchange -
R. Keller (2004)
Diskursforschung : eine Einführung für SozialwissenschaftlerInnen -
Zhang Feng (2009)
Rethinking the ‘Tribute System’: Broadening the Conceptual Horizon of Historical East Asian PoliticsThe Chinese Journal of International Politics, 2
-
(2016)
Xīfāng zhīqián de Dōng Yà: Cháogòng màoyì wǔbǎi nián 西方之前的东亚: 朝贡贸易五百年 -
S. Lee, G. Frank (1998)
Reorient Global Economy in the Asian AgeInternational Journal, 54
-
J. Fairbank, S. Têng (1941)
On The Ch'ing Tributary SystemHarvard Journal of Asiatic Studies, 6
-
A. Schottenhammer (2012)
The “China Seas” in world history: A general outline of the role of Chinese and East Asian maritime space from its origins to c. 1800Journal of Marine and Island Cultures, 1
-
(2014)
Míngchū Nánhǎi cháogòng zhìdù yǔ fēngjiàn guójiā hǎiyáng zhànlüè shùlùn 明初南海朝贡制度与封建国家海洋战略述论 [On the Early Míng South China Sea Tributary System and Maritime Strategy of Feudal States -
(1900)
Weigelin-Schwiedrzik, eds., Ostasien 1600–1900 -
(2016)
Qīngdài cháogòng wénshū yánjiū 清代朝贡文书研究 -
(2002)
Shāhālǔ qiǎnshǐ Zhōngguó jì 沙哈鲁遣使中国记 [Records on the Envoy of Shahrukh Mirza to China -
Andreas Hirseland (2007)
Review: Margarete Jäger & Siegfried Jäger (2007). Deutungskämpfe. Theorie und Praxis Kritischer Diskursanalyse, 8
-
(2000)
Shìlùn cháogòng zhìdù de yǎnbiàn 试论朝贡制度的演变 -
Chiang Kai-shek (1948)
China's Destiny and Chinese Economic TheoryInternational Affairs, 24
-
(2011)
Cháogòng -cèfēng' zhìxù lùnxī '朝贡--册封'秩 序论析 [Analysis of the 'Tributary-Feudal' Order -
(2017)
Jiā, guó, Tiānxià -Xiàndài Zhōngguó de gèrén, guójiā yǔ shìjiè rèntóng 家国天下--现代中国的个人，国家与世界认同 [Home, Country, Tianxia -The Personal, National and Global Identity of Modern China -
Susanne Kassel (2007)
Margarete Jäger/Siegfried Jäger: Deutungskämpfe. Theorie und Praxis Kritischer DiskursanalysePublizistik, 52
-
K. Pomeranz (2000)
The great divergence : China, Europe, and the making of the modern world economyForeign Affairs, 79
-
(2008)
China, East Asia and the Global Economy -
(2009)
Zhōnghuá cháogòng tǐxì: Guānniàn jiégòu yǔ gōngnéng 中华朝贡体 系:观念结构与功能 [China's Tributary System: Its Conceptual Structure and Function -
(1988)
=Ālǐ Ākèbā’ěr 阿里·阿克巴尔
- Publisher
- de Gruyter
- Copyright
- © 2020 Sebestyén Hompot, published by Sciendo
- ISSN
- 2521-7038
- eISSN
- 2521-7038
- DOI
- 10.2478/vjeas-2020-0006
- Publisher site
- See Article on Publisher Site
Abstract
AbstractThe article investigates the recent (2000–2019) mainland Chinese historiography on the Sinocentric tributary system of the Míng and Qīng periods (1368–1912). The theoretical approach of the article is based on Foucauldian discourse theory, as well as Chinese theoretical scholarship on the evolution of Chinese thought. Its methodology is primarily based on Reiner Keller’s sociological discourse research method. The main body of the article is structured upon the major fields of argumentation of the discourse, identified by the author as “the validity of the term ‘tributary system,’” “the tributary system and pre-modern Chinese culture,” “the tributary system and Míng-Qīng Chinese socio-economic history,” and “the tributary system and the regional political order.” The article argues that the ‘discursive struggle’ in recent historiography on the tributary system is primarily a result of its contested interpretation and evaluation under current dominant framings of an ideal international order—one centred around the principles of national sovereignty and “win-win” economic cooperation.
Journal
Vienna Journal of East Asian Studies – de Gruyter
Published: Dec 1, 2020