Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Effect of Implementing Subgoals in Code.org's Intro to Programming Unit in Computer Science Principles

Effect of Implementing Subgoals in Code.org's Intro to Programming Unit in Computer Science... The subgoal learning framework has improved performance for novice programmers in higher education, but it has only started to be applied and studied in K-12 (primary/secondary). Programming education in K-12 is growing, and many international initiatives are attempting to increase participation, including curricular initiatives like Computer Science Principles and non-profit organizations like Code.org. Given that subgoal learning is designed to help students with no prior knowledge, we designed and implemented subgoals in the introduction to programming unit in Code.org's Computer Science Principles course. The redesigned unit includes subgoal-oriented instruction and subgoal-themed pre-written comments that students could add to their programming activities. To evaluate efficacy, we compared behaviors and performance of students who received the redesigned subgoal unit to those receiving the original unit. We found that students who learned with subgoals performed better on problem-solving questions but not knowledge-based questions and wrote more in open-ended response questions, including a practice Performance Task for the AP exam. Moreover, at least one-third of subgoal students continued to use the subgoal comments after the subgoal-oriented instruction had been faded, suggesting that they found them useful. Survey data from the teachers suggested that students who struggled with the concepts found the subgoals most useful. Implications for future designs are discussed. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png ACM Transactions on Computing Education (TOCE) Association for Computing Machinery

Effect of Implementing Subgoals in Code.org's Intro to Programming Unit in Computer Science Principles

Download PDF
24 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/association-for-computing-machinery/effect-of-implementing-subgoals-in-code-org-s-intro-to-programming-ubuusxr0Dk
Publisher
Association for Computing Machinery
Copyright
Copyright © 2020 ACM
ISSN
1946-6226
eISSN
1946-6226
DOI
10.1145/3415594
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The subgoal learning framework has improved performance for novice programmers in higher education, but it has only started to be applied and studied in K-12 (primary/secondary). Programming education in K-12 is growing, and many international initiatives are attempting to increase participation, including curricular initiatives like Computer Science Principles and non-profit organizations like Code.org. Given that subgoal learning is designed to help students with no prior knowledge, we designed and implemented subgoals in the introduction to programming unit in Code.org's Computer Science Principles course. The redesigned unit includes subgoal-oriented instruction and subgoal-themed pre-written comments that students could add to their programming activities. To evaluate efficacy, we compared behaviors and performance of students who received the redesigned subgoal unit to those receiving the original unit. We found that students who learned with subgoals performed better on problem-solving questions but not knowledge-based questions and wrote more in open-ended response questions, including a practice Performance Task for the AP exam. Moreover, at least one-third of subgoal students continued to use the subgoal comments after the subgoal-oriented instruction had been faded, suggesting that they found them useful. Survey data from the teachers suggested that students who struggled with the concepts found the subgoals most useful. Implications for future designs are discussed.

Journal

ACM Transactions on Computing Education (TOCE) – Association for Computing Machinery

Published: Oct 4, 2020

Keywords: Code.org

References

  • Optimizing learning from examples using animated pedagogical agents
    Atkinson, Robert K.
  • Computer-based examples designed to encourage optimal example processing: A study examining the impact of sequentially presented, subgoal-oriented worked examples
    Atkinson, Robert K.; Derry, Sharon J.
  • How People Learn: Brain, Mind, Experience, and School
    Bransford, John
  • Improving examples to improve transfer to novel problems
    Catrambone, Richard
  • Generalizing solution procedures learned from examples
    Catrambone, Richard
  • The subgoal learning model: Creating better examples so that students can solve novel problems
    Catrambone, Richard
  • Task analysis by problem solving (TAPS): Uncovering expert knowledge to develop high-quality instructional materials and training
    Catrambone, Richard
  • AP Computer Science Principles: Course and Exam Description
    CollegeBoard,
  • Using the SOLO taxonomy to understand subgoal labels effect in CS1
    Decker, Adrienne; Margulieux, Lauren E.; Morrison, Briana B.
  • The Systematic Design of Instruction (8th ed
    Dick, W.; Carey, L.; Carey, J. O.
  • Subgoal labeled worked examples in K-3 education
    Johanna, Joentausta; Hellas, Arto
  • Learner sourcing subgoal labeling to support learning from how-to videos
    Kim, Juho; Miller, Robert C.; Gajos, Krzysztof Z.
  • Improving problem solving performance in computer-based learning environments through subgoal labels
    Margulieux, Lauren E.; Catrambone, Richard
  • Employing subgoals in computer programming education
    Margulieux, Lauren E.; Catrambone, Richard; Guzdial, Mark
  • Subgoal-labeled instructional material improves performance and transfer in learning to develop mobile applications
    Margulieux, Lauren E.; Guzdial, Mark; Catrambone, Richard
  • Design and pilot testing of subgoal labeled worked examples for five core concepts in CS1
    Margulieux, Lauren E.; Morrison, Briana B.; Decker, Adrienne
  • Learning loops: A replication study illuminates impact of HS courses
    Morrison, Briana B.; Decker, Adrienne; Margulieux, Lauren E.
  • Subgoals help students solve parsons problems
    Morrison, Briana B.; Margulieux, Lauren E.; Ericson, Barbara; Guzdial, Mark
  • Subgoals, context, and worked examples in learning computing problem solving
    Morrison, Briana B.; Margulieux, Lauren E.; Guzdial, Mark
  • Who needs what: Recommendations for designing effective online professional development for computer science teachers
    Qian, Y.; Hambrusch, S.; Yadav, A.; Gretter, S.